Batman: Caped Crusader Review – The Dark Knight Strikes Again

Batman: Caped Crusader Review - The Dark Knight Strikes Again

As a Black man who grew up in the 1940s and is now watching this new take on “Batman: Caped Crusader,” I can’t help but feel a mix of emotions as I observe how race and homophobia seem to be non-issues in this version of Gotham City. On one hand, it’s refreshing to see these stories unfold without being bogged down by these issues. But on the other hand, I can’t help but wonder if there are missed opportunities for deeper exploration and representation.


Over the years, Batman has been portrayed in various ways by numerous writers, artists, and actors. Among fans, “Batman: The Animated Series” from the 1990s stands out as an exceptional interpretation of the character. Created by Bruce Timm and Eric Radomski, this animated show offered a captivating blend of action, humor, fear, sadness, excitement, intelligence, and style. Characters like Harley Quinn, Renee Montoya, and a more compassionate Mr. Freeze, introduced or reimagined in the series, became integral parts of DC Comics’ lore. Timm went on to create “Superman: The Animated Series,” “Batman Beyond,” and “Justice League/Unlimited,” while actors Kevin Conroy and Mark Hamill continued voicing Batman and the Joker respectively in numerous other projects.

“The new animated series ‘Batman: Caped Crusader,’ created by Timm, Abrams, and Reeves, shares some elements with ‘Batman: The Animated Series,’ such as the noir influences and Art Deco setting. However, this isn’t just a continuation of the old show. It’s a mix of new ideas and a return to Batman’s original roots. While ‘Batman: The Animated Series’ drew from various comic book eras, ‘Caped Crusader’ focuses more on the strange aspects of Bob Kane and Bill Finger’s earliest Batman comics. Instead of a blend that feels timeless, this version of Gotham is firmly set in a fantastical 1940s. With fewer restrictions of children’s television, ‘Caped Crusader’ can tell more mature stories than its predecessor, although the limitations of modern streaming platforms may still limit its full potential.”

Classic characters done differently

Batman: Caped Crusader Review - The Dark Knight Strikes Again

In the “Batman: Caped Crusader” series, Hamish Linklater portrays Batman as a more solitary and aloof character compared to Kevin Conroy’s portrayal from the DCAU. His version of Bruce Wayne and the Dark Knight are less inviting, keeping people at a distance. Throughout the season, he is just beginning to form professional connections with Jim Gordon (Eric Morgan Stuart), future Batgirl Barbara Gordon (Krystal Joy Brown), and detective Renee Montoya (Michelle C. Bonilla).

In a contrast to “Batman: The Animated Series,” which was less episodic, “Caped Crusader” on Prime Video values the thrill of encountering a new villain each week and creatively reimagines iconic rogues while introducing lesser-known ones. The portrayal of Clayface (Dan Donohue) bridges the gap between the masked actor of classic comics and the shapeshifter of modern versions, with just enough scientific rationalization to keep it believable. In this adaptation, Catwoman (Christina Ricci) is a wealthy kleptomaniac who serves as both a comic relief character for Bruce Wayne and a foil, differing from her previous antihero persona rooted in the underclass. The Penguin undergoes one of the most drastic transformations – I won’t reveal the voice actor to avoid spoilers, but it’s bound to generate conversation.

In passing, it’s worth mentioning that the customary critics will undoubtedly complain about the multicultural cast in this production. I find this debate tiresome. Instead, let’s discuss how the rest of the audience perceives the portrayal of diversity within this narrative and, more significantly, if this diversity seems to be impacted by or, conversely, seemingly unaffected by the historical context. I observed only one line hinting at the challenges Commissioner Gordon faces as a Black man holding a powerful position; otherwise, racism seems insignificant, and homophobia appears almost non-existent in this adaptation of the 1940s. While there is an appeal to ignoring these issues, I can’t help but ponder if we are missing opportunities for deeper exploration (I recently watched AMC’s “Interview with the Vampire,” which brilliantly tackles themes of identity while diversifying period stories without overshadowing the narrative).

As a fan, I’d put it this way: It’s fascinating yet irrelevant to focus on historical accuracy when Batman dives headfirst into the supernatural realm. For instance, when the Gentleman Ghost (Toby Stephens) makes an appearance in the middle of the season, my rational Batman is left baffled. This is where Alfred (Jason Watkins) gets his moment to save the day. The Pennyworth production team excels at horror elements, and one of the most memorable episodes is the one featuring the vampire Nocturna (McKenna Grace). In this episode, Batman demonstrates his remarkable capacity for empathy, bringing us closer than ever to the heart-wrenching scenes reminiscent of “The Animated Series.”

Not enough episodes to do everything justice

Batman: Caped Crusader Review - The Dark Knight Strikes Again

In this season, the roles of two formidable adversaries, Harleen Quinzel aka Harley Quinn (Jamie Chung), and Harvey Dent aka Two-Face (Diedrich Bader), are expanded with longer story arcs. Harley now works as Bruce Wayne’s therapist instead of being tied to the Joker, leading to therapy sessions that delve into darker and more intriguing themes than what was previously explored in “Batman: The Animated Series.” This portrayal of Harley is compelling, even for those who feel she has been overexposed recently. However, I felt that her storyline deserved more development; we’re left with an unfinished arc halfway through the already brief 10-episode season.

Over the entire season, Dent’s gradual transformation into Two-Face is given greater emphasis. As a lawyer, he becomes disillusioned with Gotham’s deeply corrupt justice system and ultimately succumbs to villainy himself. This portrayal of Dent is a common theme in Two-Face stories, making it predictable yet effective. The season finale, penned by comic writer Ed Brubaker, poignantly explores Dent’s tragic side in a satisfying conclusion.

In terms of animation quality, “Batman: Caped Crusader” surpasses “The Animated Series” during its weaker moments, yet falls short of its most breathtaking scenes. While “The Animated Series” focused on smooth transitions and exaggerated facial expressions with varying success across different studios, “Caped Crusader” presents a more uniform appearance but is somewhat limited in comparison. The primary visual drawback for “Caped Crusader” comes from the CGI car chases; although they might fit better with another art style, they currently appear jarring and subpar within this production.

The “Batman: Caped Crusader” animation kept me engaged and entertained, yet it didn’t quite reach the astonishing heights of Bruce Timm’s previous animated series at their peak moments. With only one season completed so far, this show is still in its early stages. I’m thrilled that a second season has been announced and I eagerly anticipate its potential for further development.

“Batman: Caped Crusader” premieres on Amazon Prime Video on August 1.

Read More

Sorry. No data so far.

2024-07-29 17:30