Chilling True Crime: Inside the Mind of American Terrorist McVeigh

by

The filmmaker Mike Ott subtly depicts Timothy McVeigh as a cold-blooded perpetrator, not as an obvious villain with horns and scales. He portrays McVeigh as a calculating white supremacist who planned the bombing of the Alfred P. Murrah Federal Building in Oklahoma City on April 19, 1995, which remains the worst act of domestic terrorism in American history. The film shows that McVeigh was a seemingly ordinary individual, making his malevolent intentions all the more chilling. What makes this portrayal particularly disturbing is the fact that he had allies and accomplices who shared his horrific goals, operating quietly behind the scenes.

Alfie Allen portrays McVeigh in this narrative. Initially, he’s stopped by a state trooper for speeding, but uses a bogus driver’s license to hide his real identity. Despite his quiet demeanor, there’s no apparent danger about him. He’s released with a warning after exceeding the speed limit by 20mph. Later, McVeigh establishes a stall at an Oklahoma gun show to sell Second Amendment bumper stickers. As he reads “The Turner Diaries”, he catches the eye of a skinhead. Frédéric, played by Anthony Carrigan, perceives a fellow spirit in him. They engage in conversation, but McVeigh is cautious around strangers. Already, the foundations of his purpose have been laid.

Mass Murderers

Afterward, McVeigh journeys to Arkansas to meet Richard Snell, a remorseless racist convict on death row. During their conversation, they reflect upon the incident at Waco and express a shared sentiment that justice needs to be served for the government’s intrusion into the compound. Snell remains unfazed by his impending execution for a noble cause. He also inquires about McVeigh’s encounter with Terry Nichols (Brett Gelman), who had remarried and was expecting a child. That was his upcoming destination. Upon reuniting, Nichols warmly greets McVeigh while they shoot at targets together. He makes lewd remarks about his new Filipino wife’s submissive nature. However, before engaging in any business with a local anti-government militia, Nichols shares that he has been conducting experiments with explosives.

In most of the movie, Allen maintains a calm and focused expression, taking in everything around him. McVeigh intentionally kept his emotions hidden so as not to reveal his true intentions. However, when circumstances provoked him, his icy exterior couldn’t conceal his anger or desire.

The audience will be shocked by McVeigh’s reaction towards an interracial couple. This reaction serves as a chilling indication that McVeigh was actually a violent and racist individual. Anything that contradicted his beliefs would provoke his simmering wrath.

The Evil in Ordinary People

In this story, Ashley Benson plays the role of Cindy, a charming waitress at a neighborhood diner. The character of McVeigh reveals his passionate side subtly, much like a hidden snake in the grass. Cindy becomes interested in an ordinary man and they start dating. However, their relationship lacks any deep emotional bond. McVeigh maintains his secretive nature but allows himself to engage in a physical relationship with someone he finds appealing without fully revealing himself.

Ott (California Dreams, Analog Days) isn’t merely narrating a story about a cold, mechanical character. McVeigh had substance and emotions, though they were reserved for specific individuals. Cindy discovers this truth painfully as she attempts to explore beyond his superficial persona.

The film adopts a straightforward, unadorned narrative style throughout, with minimal music, simple editing, and muted colors. To put it another way, the storytelling in this movie is starkly plain. The characters appear as ordinary citizens from various parts of the country, which becomes unsettling when McVeigh interacts with Frédéric’s family during a barbecue. At first, everything seems normal, but upon closer inspection, one can see a Nazi swastika tattoo on a woman’s arm while she washes dishes. This is a shocking revelation, serving as a chilling reminder of the hidden dangers and pervasive nature of hate in our society. In other words, these seemingly ordinary people were not overtly exhibiting their hatred through goose-stepping or saluting, but they posed a threat nonetheless.

‘McVeigh’ Is an Aloof & Ethical Approach to True Crime Tragedy

McVeigh, in its 90-minute duration, is not a light watch. The slow-paced approach, minimal action, and absence of overtly racist elements employed by Ott might leave some viewers feeling that more intense or dramatic scenes were needed to fully capture the true nature of this man.

It seems Ott aims to narrate this tale with ethical integrity, avoiding an overly dramatic portrayal that might transform it into mere entertainment. While he does build up to the bombing scene, his intent is not to make it thrilling or exciting. Instead, we observe the harrowing aftermath and deeply affecting visuals of the bombing, but only through archival news footage that has become indelible in our collective national memory.

1. McVeigh portrays a detailed character analysis, historical context, and a chilling depiction of what relentless individuals can achieve. My colleague who watched the movie questioned why there wasn’t more information about McVeigh’s childhood and upbringing to lead up to the attack. I hadn’t considered this. However, it seems clear to me that Ott chose to focus on that particular timeframe for a reason. Providing additional details might not be necessary, and 90 minutes is sufficient; this isn’t meant to delve into McVeigh’s psyche but rather to explore his societal impact.

2. McVeigh is a film by Rogue Wave Pictures and Symbolic Exchange, set for theatrical release on March 21st through Decal.

Read More

2025-03-21 13:02