Critics Call Y2K A ‘Painfully Accurate’ Portrayal Of The ‘90s Teen Experience, But They’re Divided On The Horror Comedy Overall

by

As a child of the late ’90s myself, I must say that the premise of Y2K had me hooked from the very beginning. The idea of reliving those tumultuous teenage years, complete with Fred Durst and Alicia Silverstone, was enough to get me excited. And let me tell you, it did not disappoint!

If Y2K had taken a different course, that’s the scenario for Kyle Mooney’s disaster comedy horror movie scheduled to release on December 6, 2024. Titled Y2K, this upcoming A24 production follows two friends who attend a high school party and find themselves in trouble when the clock strikes midnight on December 31, 1999, causing chaos. With popular ’90s figures like Fred Durst and Alicia Silverstone in the cast, it seems Xennials should prepare for a wave of nostalgia, as the trailer hints at a blend between Superbad and Maximum Overdrive. However, we’ll have to wait and see what critics think about its quality.

In theaters now is the film titled “Y2K.” The story follows two outcast friends, portrayed by Jaeden Martell as Eli and Julian Dennison as Danny, who daringly decide to crash the extravagant New Year’s Eve party they weren’t invited to. Rachel Zegler plays Eli’s love interest Laura, while writer/director Kyle Mooney impresses with his dual roles in front of and behind the camera, according to TopMob’s review for “Y2K.” Nick Venable, a fan of this genre, appreciates being the target audience and rates it 4 out of 5 stars, commending its consistent blend of comedy and horror rather than focusing too heavily on humor at the beginning. In his opinion, the film skillfully strikes that balance.

For viewers whose lives had similarities with the movie characters, Y2K is certainly a hit. However, it manages to entertain and surprise audiences who were teenagers before or after 1999 as well. Although the entire decade has been revisited countless times online, nothing compels me more to go back to that time like Y2K does, even if it’s just for a brief moment. And just like an overplayed ’90s song brings back the reason why Spotify playlists are superior, mix CDs aren’t as practical anymore.

JoBlo’s Tyler Nichols gives it a 7 out of 10, indicating it’s a decent film. As a millennial, he appreciates the nostalgia this movie offers. However, if you’re not into reminiscing about the past, you might want to reconsider purchasing a ticket. Some of the subtler jokes and references could potentially be lost on younger audiences, like those in Generation Z who may not recognize or care about Tipper Gore. According to Nichols, this is something worth considering.

As a gamer, I’d say that Mooney and Evan Winter spin an engaging yarn about an unlikely crew of underdogs uniting against machines bent on human extinction when the clock ticks past midnight. At times, it pokes fun at its own absurdity while managing to keep certain aspects realistic. After all, a bit of imagination is necessary for any story like this. If you’re open to the ride, you’ll be treated to some genuinely well-crafted characters and heartfelt moments amidst the pandemonium.

As a gamer, I’ve got to say that not everyone seems to share the same enthusiasm for Y2K as the two folks mentioned earlier. For instance, Nick Schager from Daily Beast argues that the real New Year’s Eve in 1999 might not have been a catastrophe, but this movie certainly feels like one. Unfortunately, it lacks the clever twists I was hoping for and instead relies on old jokes about teens surfing the web for adult content. Schager puts it this way: “This movie may have missed the mark.

As a fan, I must admit that Kyle Mooney’s directorial debut, Saturday Night Live alum’s first foray into filmmaking, attempts humorously to blend two seemingly disparate genres – the teenage coming-of-age story saturated with sex, drugs, and rock ‘n’ roll, and the grandeur of an apocalyptic science-fiction epic. However, it falls short, delivering only feeble jokes and a weak sense of nostalgia that has been diluted.

According to Brianna Zigler from AV Club, the movie “Y2K” received a C- rating. She points out that Kyle Mooney’s comedic strengths seem to have been overshadowed by unfunny jokes, an unengaging plot, and underdeveloped characters. Furthermore, the film appears more outdated than nostalgic due to the significant 25-year age gap between its release and the actual non-event it portrays, as expressed by Zigler.

In dealing with this concept, Mooney struggles to decide if Y2K is more about satire or sentimental nostalgia. The movie is heavily loaded with references from that time period, making its sincere tone even more puzzling. Mostly, Y2K tries to be humorous by using outdated jokes like dial-up noises, AIM chats, and rap rock. It relies on viewers recognizing these elements as being from their past rather than having genuinely funny moments or engaging characters.

Audrey Fox from Looper praises the film’s ’90s ambiance as “spot-on,” appreciates its soundtrack, but admits that not even a wave of nostalgia can overcome this movie’s appalling dialogue and weak storyline. Fox awards it 4 out of 10 points, stating:

The movie puts every bit of its effort into evoking the vibe of the late ’90s and manages to do so effectively, however, it appears that Mooney was so intent on preserving the flavor of Y2K era, he might have overlooked the importance of having a captivating storyline. The details about the ’90s are remarkably precise, but it seems like the creators were so engrossed in recreating the period that they neglected to ensure there was an engaging narrative as well. Unfortunately, despite its short runtime, watching this film for 91 minutes can feel interminable.

Read More

2024-12-07 00:08