As a long-time Gilmore Girls fanatic who has spent countless hours sifting through Stars Hollow’s quirky charm and Rory’s love life debacles, I must say that the controversial affair between Logan and Rory in Gilmore Girls: A Year In The Life left me with mixed feelings. On one hand, I found myself reminiscing about their youthful passion and shared ambition; on the other, the infidelity plotline seemed to tarnish the relationship’s purity.
Among the most captivating TV series to revisit, particularly during autumn television programming, “Gilmore Girls” boasts a highly dedicated fanbase who have spent years debating Rory’s romantic destiny. The show concluded with Alexis Bledel’s character Rory turning down Logan’s proposal, leaving fans puzzled. Netflix’s brief revival rekindled the debate, particularly due to Matt Czuchry’s portrayal of Logan engaging in an affair with Rory. While some appreciated the on-screen reunion regardless of context, others, including one of the original “Gilmore Girls” scriptwriters, found this significant plot twist troubling.
It’s been noted by fans that the Gilmore Girls characters aren’t flawless. In fact, their moral compass often shifts from warm to cool. Despite this, many found the infidelity plotline involving Rory and Logan in Gilmore Girls: A Year In The Life to be an unnecessary addition, as it spoiled their relationship for some viewers. This is a point of contention that even Stan Zimmerman, a former writer, expressed to People, explaining why this choice in the streaming series bothered him so much.
The cheating thing bothered me. Otherwise, [Logan] would’ve been perfect for [Rory]. I just loved their coloring. I just loved them together. They pushed each other’s buttons, but pushed each other to be better people.
That last statement, I’m not totally sold on. Let’s not forget who supported Rory leaving college (Logan) and who shook some sense into her with the ever-memorable “I know you” speech (Jess). Listen, I liked Logan and Rory together, and much like Czuchry’s own opinions, I don’t think Logan was a terrible boyfriend. Many fans are Team Logan, including Emily Gilmore herself Kelly Bishop.
I believe that each of Rory’s boyfriends brought out distinct aspects of her personality, and they all seemed suitable in their unique ways. Nevertheless, no one is flawless, and Logan occasionally showed signs of egotism and rule-bending tendencies, which he seemed to amplify in Rory. At the time of A Year in the Life, Rory was not unfamiliar with infidelity as she had previously been involved with her first boyfriend Dean while he was married. However, a long-term affair is an entirely different matter. It’s likely something Lorelai would disapprove of, and something early seasons Rory would have never envisioned for herself.
Despite all that transpired during the show’s original run from 2000-2007, I believe Logan and Rory’s affair wasn’t too far off their adult personalities, as suggested by Zimmerman. This aligns with creator Amy Sherman-Palladino’s viewpoint, who stated it as follows:
Amy likely would have responded something like, “Stan, let’s just stop for a moment. Everyone makes mistakes, some more serious than others, and sometimes people have affairs. Let’s try to be understanding.
I agree with her. In fact, I think this affair needed to happen for a specific reason.
My Hot Take: The End Of Gilmore Girls: A Year In The Life Was Actually Perfect
Let me explain without causing any objections first. This is indeed a full-circle moment, as Rory is expecting a child, and it seems Logan, the man she’s deeply attached to, may not be fully present in their lives. Does this scenario sound familiar? The series finale finds Rory potentially raising her child alone, much like Lorelai did, with a father figure situation reminiscent of that involving her own dad, Christopher. Although an affair was crucial for the plot, it’s important to acknowledge its controversial reception.
The Netflix-produced series concludes abruptly right after the revelation of the pregnancy plotline, leaving numerous queries unresolved. If you’re a fan of Gilmore Girls, you can likely predict where the story continues. I personally believe that the most satisfying endings are those that are bittersweet and prompt continued contemplation about the show even after it has ended.
In other words, I wouldn’t object if those questions were addressed in a future season. It’s possible that Rory’s child, who would likely be a girl, is around high school age and preparing to attend Chilton. Could we witness the reappearance of Jess in Stars Hollow, taking on a role similar to Luke for Lorelai? There are so many potential scenarios.
As suggested by the creator of “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel”, there may be another Gilmore reunions in store when the circumstances are ideal. In the meantime, I’ll keep my fingers crossed and prepare for a thrilling autumn marathon of “Gilmore Girls” on Netflix, which is accessible to anyone with a subscription.
Read More
Sorry. No data so far.
2024-10-07 16:37