Good American Family Ending: The Truth Behind Natalia’s Age & Trial Outcome

by

Caution: This recap discusses key plot points from episode 8 of ‘Good American Family’. If you haven’t watched it yet and wish to avoid spoilers, please come back later!

In the finale of ‘Good American Family’, Natalia Grace’s (Imogen Faith Reid) contentious legal battles reached their conclusion. However, despite the court resolving many disagreements, there remain several unanswered questions about the true-crime series. The show presents a story based on real events, but it has been portraying that story from two contrasting perspectives: Natalia Grace’s and Kristine (Ellen Pompeo) & Michael Barnett’s (Mark Duplass). In the finale, these differing viewpoints converged into one final court case as the ensemble cast of ‘Good American Family’ gathered to face Michael’s criminal neglect charges.

In the final episode of “Good American Family,” Natalia Grace and Cynthia Mans (played by Christina Hendricks) confronted the Barnetts over a period of more than ten years since she had lived with them. However, contrary to portrayals, the court’s ruling, which was somewhat controversial, failed to clarify the truth about Natalia Grace’s age and the alleged abusive actions of Kristine and Michael Barnett. The question remains: how much of “Good American Family” is based on facts, and what is the true message behind this series?

The Judge’s Ruling About Natalia Grace’s Age In Good American Family’s Ending Explained

Because The Prosecution Didn’t Appeal The Ruling On Natalia Grace’s Age In 2017, Her Age Wasn’t Admissable In The Final Trial

In 2017, when Natalia Grace and the Mans family lost their custody hearing, the prosecution didn’t challenge the decision regarding Natalia’s age. Consequently, during Michael’s trial, the judge barred any discussion about her age because it was deemed irrelevant. This move was made as Natalia had been treated as an adult in this case, and the charges of child neglect and abuse were subsequently dropped.

In the trial involving Natalia Grace, it was disadvantageous that she was considered an adult rather than a child. The court wouldn’t allow any references to her age, and witnesses who did so were disqualified. Moreover, the statute of limitations for adults meant that any actions taken by Michael Barnett (and indirectly Kristine) before 2014 could not be brought to court. Consequently, due to the judge’s decision about Natalia Grace’s age, Michael Barnett and Kristine were found not guilty, a situation Detective Drysdale described as a “miscarriage of justice.

Why Natalia Grace Couldn’t Use The Facebook Messenger Texts In The Trial

Since Natalia Grace Was Being Treated As An Adult, The Messages Were Protected By Spousal Privelege

The judge’s decision regarding Natalia Grace’s age significantly impacted the Facebook Messenger conversations between Michael and Kristine. In these messages, they openly discussed mistreating Natalia, acknowledging she was a child, and using derogatory terms towards her. These messages could have been highly detrimental if presented as evidence, but since Natalia Grace was deemed an adult for the trial, the Facebook Messenger exchanges were safeguarded by spousal privilege. Spousal privilege is a legal concept that ensures the private communications between married individuals are not admitted in court to work against them.

Typically, Kristine and Michael’s messages wouldn’t be allowed in a negligence case due to spousal privilege. However, since allegations were made that Natalia Grace was a minor, these texts could be obtained. In a just world, Natalia might have prevailed in Good American Family, but this wasn’t the case. Instead, the court treated her as an adult, stripping the prosecution of their ability to utilize the messages as evidence.

Did Natalia Grace Really Talk To The Barnetts After Michael’s Court Case?

Michael Publicly Apologized To Natalia Grace In 2024

As a movie enthusiast, I must say that the climactic scene in the final episode of “Good American Family” between Michael and Natalia Grace was nothing short of riveting. In this confrontation, Michael found himself facing the repercussions of his past actions and the pain he had inflicted on Natalia. However, what transpired between them in the show seemed more akin to theatrical embellishment rather than an accurate depiction of reality.

In actuality, Michael and Natalia did engage in a post-trial conversation, but “Good American Family” took creative liberties with certain aspects of their dialogue. In real life, it wasn’t until 2024 that Michael publicly apologized to Natalia, and Kristine was nowhere to be found during this encounter (as detailed in “The Curious Case of Natalia Grace”).

How Old Is Natalia Grace Really In Good American Family?

There’s No Way To Tell For Sure If Natalia Grace Was Born In 1989 Or 2003

Following eight episodes filled with contrasting narratives, allegations, and a lot of suspense, the show Good American Family failed to clarify Natalia Grace’s actual age. However, this is because no one can say for certain how old Natalia Grace truly is. The abundance of lies, accusations, and conflicting legal documents make it difficult to determine if her birth year is 1989 or 2003. While Good American Family suggests that Natalia Grace was born in 2003, the truth remains uncertain – it’s a matter of who you decide to trust.

What Happened To Natalia Grace & The Barnetts After Good American Family In Real Life

The Mans Family Was Accused Of Abusing Natalia Grace, Kristine Wrote A New Book, & Michael Switched Sides

The series “Good American Family” concludes following Michael Barnett’s trial in 2023, but there’s much more to Natalia Grace’s story beyond that point. As hinted at in the final scenes, the Mans family, who adopted Natalia Grace, faced accusations of abuse towards her and their other children (as reported by People). In December 2023, Natalia Grace escaped from the Mans household and is currently residing with the Depaul family in New York. She has a boyfriend and is working towards her GED, aspiring to become a teacher one day.

Following their time on Good American Family, the lives of Kristine and Michael Barnett have remained active. While Michael has made a few public appearances, such as his apology on The Curious Case of Natalia Grace, he’s primarily kept a low profile. Conversely, Kristine continues to speak openly about her connection with Natalia Grace in current conversations. Reports suggest she is penning a memoir titled “Witch Hunt: The Kristine Barnett Story“, although it has yet to see widespread distribution (according to People).

The Real Meaning Of Good American Family’s Ending Explained

Good American Family Questions If We Can Believe Anyone In Natalia Grace’s Story

The TV series Good American Family, though inspired by real events, delves into themes of deception, narratives, and whom we decide to trust. As creator Katie Robbins expressed (via Time), “With any story, you’re predisposed to believe what you’re hearing” was the motivation behind her work, aiming to challenge our inherent biases. By portraying both sides of Natalia Grace’s predicament, Good American Family invites its audience to scrutinize the people we trust and ponders whether a seemingly ‘good American family’ can be fully relied upon. At the minimum, it encourages us to approach information that significantly impacts an individual’s welfare with a measure of skepticism.

In my opinion, “Good American Family” is a tale that brilliantly explores how truth can wither when the right people spin the right lies and enough people believe them. Throughout the series, characters such as Detective Drysdale often asserted, “If you tell a lie convincingly, the truth becomes irrelevant.” Essentially, this drama underscores the chilling idea that the truth can be buried beneath well-crafted deception. Despite Natalia Grace’s true age being exposed through her passport, by the show’s end, it remained shrouded in mystery due to the Barnetts’ adept manipulation of both the legal system and public perception.

In essence, Good American Family serves as a platform for shaping public belief, and it poses a question to its audience: who do they choose to trust – Natalia Grace or Kristine and Michael? Public opinion holds significant sway in the U.S., and while Natalia Grace may not have prevailed legally, she triumphed in the court of public sentiment. Good American Family plays a role in shaping this court of public opinion, inviting viewers to scrutinize the evidence presented within the show with discernment.

Read More

2025-05-01 23:58