I Watched 1883 For The First Time, I Was Shocked By How Much Differently It Hit Me Than Yellowstone

I Watched 1883 For The First Time, I Was Shocked By How Much Differently It Hit Me Than Yellowstone

As someone who has followed the Yellowstone universe since its inception, I must say that the passing of Elsa Dutton in 1883 left an indelible mark on me, and it’s not just because she was the heart and soul of the show. Growing up in a small Montana town myself, I couldn’t help but see a bit of myself in Isabel May’s portrayal of Elsa – a young girl with big dreams, eager to make her mark on the world.


In the first third of 1883’s premiere, you’ll see a burning wagon and a man burning down his house after losing his daughter and wife to smallpox. That sets the tone for the rest of the series about the ruthless origin story of the Dutton family finding the ranch that will eventually become the Yellowstone. Now, as a fan of the Yellowstone shows, I expect violence, brutality and devastation. However, when I watched 1883 for the first time, it hit differently than the rest of them in all those departments.

I Watched 1883 For The First Time, I Was Shocked By How Much Differently It Hit Me Than Yellowstone

The Challenges The Characters In 1883 Face Feel More Grounded And Realistic

As a devoted fan, I must say that among all of Taylor Sheridan’s creations, 1883 stands out as the most raw and intense Yellowstone spinoff yet. Compared to its predecessors like Yellowstone and its follow-up 1923, this series manages to be just as violent and dramatic, but in a way that feels more gritty and real. The trials and tribulations faced by the characters in 1883 are straightforward yet lethal, making it an emotional rollercoaster ride that leaves a lasting impact. This is what makes it a cut above the rest of Sheridan’s Western offerings.

Most dramatic scenes throughout this series revolve around obstacles presented by nature, which could be readily managed or circumvented in present times. To illustrate, a particularly tragic event depicted in the program is the caravan of settlers attempting to traverse a river.

In general, the struggles depicted in the series “1883” are primarily focused on the everyday hardships experienced by pioneers as they journeyed cross-country, relying solely on their wagons, horses, and livestock. This includes instances of banditry and action, but these are not the main focus compared to the more grounded challenges that come with such a treacherous journey.

1883’s drama mainly revolves around the theme of survival, lending a sense of authenticity that heightens its terror-inducing effect, as there are no train stations for those who have wronged the ranch, no encounters with man-eating lions, and no boat accidents in one season.

I Watched 1883 For The First Time, I Was Shocked By How Much Differently It Hit Me Than Yellowstone

Can We Take A Minute To Talk About The Tragic Yet Heroic Tale Of Sam Elliott’s Shea?

At the beginning of the tale, it’s important to note that the story opens with a man, portrayed by Sam Elliott as Shea, setting fire to his house following the tragic deaths of his wife and daughter due to smallpox. This man is a veteran of the Civil War who plays a significant role in guiding a band of pioneers on their journey westward.

Read More About Yellowstone
I Watched 1883 For The First Time, I Was Shocked By How Much Differently It Hit Me Than Yellowstone

The long-awaited final episodes of Yellowstone Season 5 are approaching, and I just can’t get these 5 questions out of my mind.

That opening scene happens long before he meets the pioneers in Texas, and it is the backbone of his story. Later on in the series, when Elsa loses her first love Ennis (who was a ranchhand moving cattle with the group), Shea reveals that he’s going to make it to Oregon so he can take his wife to the ocean.

Towards the end of the series, it’s revealed that Sam Elliott’s persona had indeed reached the sea. The tale concludes dramatically as he takes his own life by firing a gunshot into his head.

Although his story is deeply sorrowful, it plays a significant role in shaping the emotional core of the series “1883“. Whenever the families within the pioneer group suffer losses, he shares their grief, even though he attempts to conceal it. As a spectator, I could sense the burden that Shea carried, a burden stemming from his past and the responsibility of guiding these people to Oregon. Despite achieving his aim, this journey was not without substantial heartache.

In terms of how viewers perceive the series, Sam Elliott expressed that he didn’t want “1883” to be viewed as just a spinoff of “Yellowstone“. Indeed, it shares clear links to the original Western series, being the Dutton family’s origin story. Yet, this production stands independently with its unique, raw tone, a significant part of which is reflected in Elliott’s character and his tragic yet heroic narrative.

I Watched 1883 For The First Time, I Was Shocked By How Much Differently It Hit Me Than Yellowstone

No Death In The Yellowstone Universe Has Hit Harder Than Elsa’s

Discussing both dramatic and courageous, it’s true that Tim McGraw, Faith Hill, and Sam Elliott make up the initial cast members of the series 1883. However, the main focus of the show appears to be on Isabel May’s character, Elsa Dutton.

She’s the oldest daughter of McGraw’s James and Hill’s Margaret, and she’s the voice of the show.

Moving westward, Elsa’s voiceover delivers an introspective narrative detailing the insights they gained and hurdles they faced along the way. Initially, she was a wide-eyed girl brimming with curiosity about the world. However, by journey’s end, she had transformed into a weary cowboy, hardened by her experiences.

Because of everything that transpired, she was the person I grew most attached to, which makes it clear why I was devastated when she passed away.

She didn’t pass away swiftly; instead, her death spanned an entire episode and more, leaving us with a prolonged agony. We were forced to witness her gradually losing her vitality, which in turn meant we had to bear the sorrow of her parents as they mourned her before she actually passed away. The sight of her taking her last breaths in her father’s arms under a tree that later became part of the Yellowstone ranch was heart-wrenching.

Essentially, Elsa’s death signified the start of the Dutton family legacy as we recognize it today, since that was where they eventually established their home in Montana. Simultaneously, it denoted a sad conclusion to their long voyage.

In essence, although they technically triumphed in this series, James and Margaret suffered immense losses; Elsa’s demise serving as the poignant finale to a heartrendingly tragic tale.

I Watched 1883 For The First Time, I Was Shocked By How Much Differently It Hit Me Than Yellowstone

Learning About James And Margaret’s Fate In 1923 Makes The Show Even More Brutal

Beyond leaving you emotionally drained from the overall storyline, the sequel series titled “1923” also delivered a resonating impact when I watched it for the first time not long ago.

This spinoff follows James’ brother Jacob and his wife Cara years after the wagon journey.

In the opening scene, Elsa sets the story in motion, and it’s soon unveiled that following James’ demise and Margaret’s freezing to death, Jacob and Cara were left to care for their boys, John Sr. and Spencer. Tragically, they didn’t live much beyond this initial voyage, which meant that their sons grew up largely without their parents.

In essence, the opening scene of 1923 echoes a painful memory from 1883, intensifying the harshness of their journey and making one question if the sacrifices they made were justified. James and Margaret, who labored tirelessly to claim this land, didn’t get to enjoy its fruits in old age, leaving behind unanswered questions about the worth of their endeavors throughout the series.

Undeniably, their longevity testifies to the resilience of the Dutton empire, having stood strong for more than a century. Yet, it fills me with sorrow to acknowledge that those who journeyed far to Montana were deprived of witnessing the full bloom of their efforts.

1883 stands out as incredibly poignant and heartbreaking due to its compelling narrative, which sets it apart from other shows within the Yellowstone universe. The cumulative effect of its storyline gives it a unique impact.

Although there won’t be another season for “1883” in 2023, the tale of the Dutton family will carry on as “Yellowstone” Season 5B is set to debut on television schedules on November 10, 2024. If you’d like to revisit James, Margaret, Elsa, Shea, and their companions’ relentless westward journey, you can stream “1883” with a Paramount+ subscription.

Read More

2024-09-14 20:37