Internet Users Are Finding A Ton Of Movies Critics Were Wrong About (But The Audience Gets), And Some Of These Are Doozies

by

In the recent wave of 2025 movie premieres, there have been several films that have sparked mixed reactions among critics but have been warmly embraced by viewers. For example, while critics were as grumpy as the Red Hulk regarding Captain American: Brave New World, with a 49% score from Rotten Tomatoes, audiences bestowed an 80% approval rating on this Marvel Cinematic Universe production. Similarly, Mel Gibson’s Flight Risk endured poor reviews but managed to secure a 63% audience score. Interestingly, internet users have been revisiting instances in cinematic history where critics proved incorrect about movies that resonated deeply with viewers. Frankly, some of these examples are quite astounding.

It’s often observed that opinions on what constitutes a fantastic film can differ significantly between critics and viewers. The fact that this discrepancy exists underscores the importance of platforms like Rotten Tomatoes, which recently introduced a Popcornmeter to reflect audience scores as they too play a crucial role in determining whether a movie is worth watching. Online communities are increasingly showcasing the diversity of opinions between critics and audiences, with examples as varied as the X feed.

Bullet Train (Critics 54%, Audiences 76%)

@RealEmirHan initiated a feed featuring movies that initial critics’ reviews were inaccurate about. The first film on this list was “Bullet Train,” starring Brad Pitt, which garnered only 54% from the critics but impressed audiences with an impressive 76%. While the critics deemed it “unimpressive” and “devoid of impact,” many viewers found it more amusing than anticipated and appreciated its action-packed, high-intensity fight sequences.

Jumper (Critics 15%, Audiences 44%)

Dalton_Walsh described the teleportation film, “Jumper”, as a “fun” one that merited a higher score. Regrettably, the film starring Hayden Christensen exemplifies a movie with an exceptional plot but poor execution. The idea of traveling to any location is intriguing, however, it falls short in fully developing the world inhabited by Jumpers and those attempting to eliminate them.

Waiting…(Critics 29%, Audiences 75%)

One of Ryan Reynolds’ early witty roles prior to Deadpool was Waiting…, a movie that humorously depicted the day-to-day antics of restaurant staff. As MatthewFalker noted, this low-rated indie comedy is particularly recommended for those working in the food service industry. Despite some critics not finding the film’s humor uproarious, audiences found it amusing enough to deem it a classic.

Man on Fire (Critics 38%, Audiences 89%)

It’s astonishing that a highly acclaimed 2000s action movie like “Man on Fire,” as pointed out by @JonKatz79, received a poor Rotten Tomatoes score of 38%. Many might argue that it showcases one of Denzel Washington’s finest performances and features compelling chemistry between him and his young co-star Dakota Fanning. The action-thriller even played a significant role in inspiring Jenna Ortega to pursue acting. Evidently, the film continues to resonate deeply with audiences.

It’s evident from numerous instances where viewers seem to prefer movies over the opinions of critics, that each audience member has unique factors determining what they find valuable in a film. A movie that manages to stir up favorable emotions even with its shortcomings, is indeed successful on its own terms.

Read More

2025-02-25 22:07