Jeff Daniels’ War Movie Disaster: Racist Epic Fails Spectacularly

by

As a movie enthusiast myself, I can’t help but appreciate the versatile talent of Jeff Daniels. This man has truly made a name for himself, amassing numerous accolades over his nearly half-century career in both television and film. He’s graced us with his presence in every genre imaginable – from the timeless laughs of comedies like “Dumb & Dumber” and “101 Dalmatians”, to the raw emotions of indie dramas such as “The Squid and the Whale”, and even the far-reaching realms of sci-fi masterpieces like “Looper” and “The Martian”.

However, there’s one production I believe he might prefer not to list on his resume: the 2003 Civil War epic “Gods and Generals”, directed by Ronald F. Maxwell.

The film “Gods and Generals,” modeled after Jeff Shaara’s namesake novel, primarily revolves around the life of Confederate General Stonewall Jackson, played by Stephen Lang. Joining the main cast are Robert Duvall as Confederate General Robert E. Lee and Jeff Daniels portraying Lieutenant Colonel Joshua Chamberlain of the Union Army. This film serves as a prequel to Maxwell’s 1993 movie “Gettysburg,” another adaptation from a Shaara novel that received mixed reviews. Interestingly, Daniels reprised his role as Chamberlain in “Gods and Generals,” but he couldn’t have foreseen the poor box office performance or the public relations fiasco that would ensue.

‘Gods and Generals’ Was Doomed From the Start

The movie “Gods and Generals” is renowned for being one of the costliest independent films ever made, as Ted Turner, creator of TNT, TBS, and CNN, invested almost $60 million into its production. This massive budget was evidently utilized, resulting in a film that spans an impressive five and a half hours – making it one of the longest war movies ever produced. Instead of dividing the story into two films released over a period of two years, as initially considered by Turner and Maxwell, they opted to reduce the initial theatrical release by a significant two hours. Unfortunately, this decision led to a film that moved slowly, featured extensive exposition, heavily emphasized both tactical strategy and Christianity, and portrayed historical figures as self-righteous.

In a conversation with HistoryNet, Maxwell admitted that the abridged version of the film received negative feedback due to the need to remove substantial parts. He explained, “Due to the large amount we had to remove, I must admit, the narrative felt fragmented, and we couldn’t completely rectify this issue.” The extended director’s cut of the movie was released in 2011, but unfortunately, it didn’t significantly alter public perception and even further emphasized the issues with Gods and Generals, such as its prominent pro-Confederate perspective.

‘Gods and Generals’ Perpetuates Dangerous Mythologies

In Gods and Generals, Maxwell aims to delve into each character’s motivation for joining the war, portraying the Confederate soldiers as men defending their land and livelihoods against greedy Union opportunists. However, many critics argue that this representation of history is idealized, with a notable absence of race-related themes. This perspective has been favorably received by certain far-right figures and publications, but most viewers find it to be a reinterpretation of history with strikingly few references to racial issues.

As a history enthusiast, I find myself at odds with the portrayal in “Gods and Generals.” This film has been criticized by historians for perpetuating the so-called “Lost Cause” narrative, which asserts that the Civil War wasn’t about slavery but rather state rights. However, this perspective erases the harsh realities faced by enslaved people, who endured unpaid labor, sexual abuse, corporal punishment, lack of education, and were denied freedom in every form. Instead, it implies that they were either indifferent or even content with their circumstances, which is not only inaccurate but also disrespectful to truthful cinematic depictions of the horrors of slavery.

Historian Steven E. Woodworth pointed out in The Journal of American History that such a message could pose potential risks, as detailed in his article.

I wholeheartedly endorse the film “Gods and Generals“, which portrays the main ideas of the Lost Cause narrative that scholars have been addressing for over five decades. In this movie’s universe, slavery holds no significance to the Confederate cause. Instead, the Confederates are depicted as valiantly fighting for, not against, freedom. This theme is consistently emphasized by various white southern characters throughout the film.

Revisionist History

As a dedicated cinephile, I’ve consistently stood by “Gods and Generals,” despite its controversial portrayal that some have labeled as a “celluloid celebration of slavery and treason.” Jeff Shaara, the author himself, attempted to distance the movie from negative connotations by highlighting the significant differences between his book and the film. He shared his thoughts with a blogger, explaining that while he offered suggestions, they were mostly disregarded, particularly concerning historical details he found problematic. In the end, he acknowledged that it wasn’t his film; it was Ron Maxwell’s and Ted Turner’s vision.

It’s reasonable that Shaara might prefer to disassociate himself from the shadow cast by Gods and Generals, but his argument weakens when we consider that his own work carries a subtly pro-Confederate perspective, even if it’s not as extreme or blatant as some.

Jeff Daniels, who is known for backing democratic politicians and possibly opposing conservative, pro-Confederacy views, has been particularly quiet about his role in the movie “Gods and Generals“. Instead, he focuses on sharing details about his various TV and film roles, as well as his work as a playwright and musician. It’s possible that Daniels hopes his silence will make the connection to the film disappear from public memory, replaced by a more favorable narrative – much like director Ron Maxwell attempted to do with his depiction of the American Civil War.

Read More

2025-04-26 17:32