Kelly Clarkson Wasn’t Interested In Being An American Idol Judge, So What Does She Think About Carrie Underwood Getting The Gig?

Kelly Clarkson Wasn’t Interested In Being An American Idol Judge, So What Does She Think About Carrie Underwood Getting The Gig?

As a longtime fan and observer of the American Idol franchise, I must say it’s quite refreshing to see one of its own returning as a judge. The fact that Carrie Underwood, a former winner herself, is coming back to mentor and guide the next generation of talented singers is truly inspiring.


There’s a great deal of anticipation building up for Carrie Underwood’s comeback as a judge on American Idol. Although her debut won’t be listed in the 2024 television lineup yet, both current and past panel members have expressed their opinions about Underwood stepping into Katy Perry’s role. Now, one of the show’s most recognized alums, Kelly Clarkson, has voiced her thoughts. Following rumors that Clarkson herself might be considered for the position, she stated that she isn’t interested. So, what are her feelings towards the job being given to another winner?

After becoming famous from winning the first season of American Idol in 2002, Kelly Clarkson has given back by serving as a coach on The Voice for nine seasons (from 2018 to 2023). Given her own competition background, she understands how valuable it is for contestants to have someone with similar experience in a position of authority. When asked about Carrie Underwood’s new job on Idol, Clarkson expressed her enthusiasm to E! News.

I think that’s brilliant. Like, what better person to have—somebody that’s won that show to come back. To be able to have gone through it all and then have such a huge career like her, that’s invaluable. I think she’s going to do great.

As a die-hard fan, I couldn’t help but get excited when Lionel Richie hinted at Kelly Clarkson possibly replacing Katy Perry on American Idol. However, after some speculation, it appears that Kelly won’t be joining the show. She shared her reasons for staying put on the East Coast, wanting to stay close to her kids, which means no Los Angeles gigs for her in the near future.

Fortunately for the forthcoming “American Idol” competitors, they’ll gain advantage from someone who has had a comparable journey, as Carrie Underwood advanced through the show not long after Kelly Clarkson. Reflecting on these upcoming aspirants, the original victor expressed:

To find someone who has accomplished a task similar to one you aspire to achieve, thereby boosting your confidence by thinking, “If they did it, then I too can reach my goals. My dreams are within my grasp.

Carrie Underwood shared insights about how ‘American Idol’ is a cherished dream for its competitors and she aims to be truthful yet compassionate in her judging approach. Simon Cowell, who served as a judge during Underwood’s season alongside Paula Abdul and Randy Jackson, concurred that honesty is crucial, deeming Underwood an excellent selection for the show. Randy Jackson also expressed fondness during this full-circle moment, reminiscing about Underwood’s audition as one of his personal favorites from all time.

Keith Urban, another previous judge, also endorsed the “Blown Away” singer as an ideal pick, emphasizing that she offers a unique viewpoint that neither Lionel Richie nor Luke Bryan can provide. Richie concurred, stating that they are unaware of what it’s like to stand on that stage, and he finds her comeback after 20 years a captivating tale.

The air date for American Idol Season 23 hasn’t been revealed yet, usually it starts in February. Given the excitement around Carrie Underwood’s initial appearance, it seems quite likely that Kelly Clarkson will be glued to her television screen when the time arrives.

Read More

2024-09-13 23:07