Kevin Costner’s Best Westerns, Ranked

Kevin Costner's Best Westerns, Ranked

As a film enthusiast with a penchant for Western movies, I must say that Kevin Costner has left an indelible mark on the genre with his diverse and captivating works. Among all his Western films, my personal favorite is undeniably “Dances With Wolves.” Having grown up watching classic Westerns, it was refreshing to see a movie that focused on the humanization of Native Americans rather than the typical cowboy-versus-Indian narrative.


Kevin Costner is a versatile and award-winning actor who has enthralled viewers with his powerful on-screen presence and talent for portraying numerous characters for many years. His artistic aspirations and knack for selecting roles have contributed significantly to his success. However, when it comes to Westerns, Costner’s work in the genre is somewhat limited in quantity.

Most fans recognize him for his Academy Award-winning performance in “Dances With Wolves,” a film that was not only his directorial debut but also one of his highest-grossing movies ever. Throughout his career before and since, Costner has shown himself to be a captivating actor with the versatility to tackle the ethically intricate landscape of the American West.

As a movie enthusiast, I can’t help but acknowledge the indelible impact Kevin Costner has left on the Western genre, particularly in the critically acclaimed drama series “Yellowstone.” Whether he dons the hat of a rugged rancher or wearies as a world-weary lawman, he infuses his roles with an authenticity that resonates deeply. This authenticity is not just raw strength, but also a quiet resilience and an unmatched charm – traits that define the genre’s most iconic characters and narratives. Here’s a brief rundown of seven unforgettable Western movies graced by Kevin Costner’s presence.

7 ‘The Postman’ (1997)

Kevin Costner's Best Westerns, RankedKevin Costner's Best Westerns, RankedKevin Costner's Best Westerns, Ranked

In this post-apocalyptic tale of resilience, directed by Kevin Costner (his second directorial venture), the movie titled “The Postman” takes us into the ruins of a once powerful United States, now transformed into a desolate wasteland following a devastating event that crippled humanity and technology. In this narrative, Costner portrays an unnamed wanderer who discovers a postman’s uniform and mailbag, deciding to impersonate a postman in order to deliver messages to isolated settlements and kindle hope for the rebuilding of the nation.

Costner is Tasked With Reviving Hope in Despair

Initially met with harsh criticism from critics, The Postman surprisingly garnered immense appreciation from viewers, who lauded its innovative storytelling and Costner’s moving portrayal in the central role. The film masterfully blends the raw authenticity of neo-Western genre with the imaginative allure of science fiction, presenting a tale that underscores the importance of maintaining hope and resilience amidst insurmountable challenges. Costner’s character serves as the catalyst for America’s rebirth, becoming the film’s emotional core and delivering an impactful and indelible performance.

6 ‘Horizon: An American Saga — Chapter 1’ (2024)

Kevin Costner's Best Westerns, RankedKevin Costner's Best Westerns, RankedKevin Costner's Best Westerns, Ranked

Originally conceived in 1988, Horizon: An American Saga – Chapter 1 is the initial installment of a four-part grand narrative, masterfully directed by and featuring Kevin Costner. This historical drama is set during the mid-19th century, focusing on the interwoven lives of settlers and Native Americans in the American West amidst the Civil War. The story unfolds as these characters grapple with the profound changes brought about by the war’s aftermath. In this tale, Costner portrays Hayes Ellison, a veteran soldier tasked with bridging the divide between settlers and Native American communities, while simultaneously contending with the hardships of frontier existence.

A Triumphant First Chapter of a Western Epic

Just like other Westerns, “Horizon: An American Saga — Chapter 1” captures and embodies the essence of the frontier. The movie, skillfully crafted with a keen attention to historical accuracy and a deep appreciation for the genre’s rich themes, runs for an extended 3 hours and 1 minute. However, since it’s the first installment in a series of four Westerns, it feels more like an extensive setup chapter that introduces numerous characters and locations, but doesn’t dwell on them long enough for viewers to form strong connections with them.

Despite some factors, the captivating narrative and the movie’s portrayal of the pursuit of peace during tumultuous times has left viewers eagerly anticipating the following film, scheduled to debut around 2025.

5 ‘Wyatt Earp’ (1994)

Kevin Costner's Best Westerns, RankedKevin Costner's Best Westerns, RankedKevin Costner's Best Westerns, Ranked

Under the skillful and imaginative guidance of Lawrence Kasdan, the film “Wyatt Earp” unfolds as a sweeping biographical saga, shedding light on the life of the iconic frontier marshal, Wyatt Earp. The narrative journeys through his early years as an Iowa farm boy, his involvement in the infamous Gunfight at the O.K. Corral, and beyond, offering a deep and multifaceted portrayal of his life amidst the evolving West. It further explores Wyatt’s intricate family dynamics with brothers Morgan and Virgil, as well as his connection with Doc Holliday, providing a rich tapestry of personal relationships against the backdrop of the American frontier.

Costner Breathes New Life Into a Legendary Icon

Packed with personal conflicts, political tension, and unyielding conflict, the 1994 film Wyatt Earp distinguishes itself among Westerns due to its expansive storyline and historical authenticity. While 1993’s Tombstone gained more recognition, this epic movie showcases Kevin Costner’s captivating portrayal of the main character, Wyatt Earp. His performance skillfully encapsulates Wyatt’s resoluteness and moral ambiguity. Supporting actors like Dennis Quiad as Doc Holliday, Gene Hackman, David Andrews, Mark Harmon, Michael Madsen, and others deliver equally compelling performances in their significant roles.

4 ‘Let Him Go’ (2020)

Kevin Costner's Best Westerns, RankedKevin Costner's Best Westerns, RankedKevin Costner's Best Westerns, Ranked

In Kevin Costner’s filmography, the cowboy movie that neither he nor Lawrence Kasdan directed is “Let Him Go,” a recent foray back into the genre. This tense thriller is set in the harsh, unforgiving landscapes of 1960s Montana and follows retired sheriff George Blackledge (played by Costner) and his wife Margaret (Diane Lane), as they embark on a perilous mission to save their grandson from the grip of a brutal family living in seclusion in the Dakotas’ wilderness. After their son passes away, their daughter-in-law marries into the notoriously violent Weboy clan. Determined to shield their own, the Blackledges spring into action.

A Gripping Exploration of Family and Duty

The film “Let Him Go” is often underestimated, offering a powerful emotional intensity within the Western genre. The gripping narrative, combined with its portrayal of a harsh, dangerous landscape and morally complex characters, creates an intense viewing experience that’s truly captivating. Additionally, it’s noteworthy that this film clocks in at under two hours, which is relatively short for a Kevin Costner Western, making it a compelling choice for those who prefer their cinema concise yet impactful.

Regarding Costner, he gives a subtle yet powerful portrayal of George, a character motivated by duty, affection, and the desire to guarantee his family’s future stability. The film’s direction by Thomas Bezucha showcases the stunning landscapes of Montana and maintains an engaging tempo. Unfortunately, Let Him Go didn’t fare well at the box office despite its masterful creation of a simmering tension from start to finish.

3 ‘Silverado’ (1985)

Kevin Costner's Best Westerns, RankedKevin Costner's Best Westerns, RankedKevin Costner's Best Westerns, Ranked

As the sun set on the waning Western genre, Lawrence Kasdan’s “Silverado” transported me back to the gritty, sun-scorched town of yesteryears named Silverado. In this film, four weary outlaws – Emmett, Paden, Mal, and Jake – unwittingly find themselves entangled in a tale that transforms them from rogues to unlikely champions. Upon their arrival in the sleepy town, they quickly become embroiled in the deep-rooted corruption and injustices that have festered for far too long. They stand tall against the tyranny of a rogue sheriff and a relentless rancher, becoming the beacon of hope for the oppressed citizens of Silverado.

A Rousing Celebration of the Western Archetype

Apart from being a thrilling tribute to the traditional Western genre, “Silverado” skillfully intertwines several narratives while delving into the pasts and motivations of its characters, ensuring viewers grasp their moral compasses and bond. Directed with an astute sense for narrative structure and aesthetics, this film incorporates a contemporary flair in its gun-slinging tale, leveraging the talents of its accomplished cast, consisting of Kevin Kline, Scott Glenn, Danny Glover, and Kevin Costner.

In a different phrasing, Kevin Costner portrays Jake, an untamed, relentless gunfighter who infuses vigor and charisma into his companions. Essentially, the film showcases the skills of a young and at that time lesser-known Kevin Costner in an exceptional manner.

2 ‘Open Range’ (2003)

Kevin Costner's Best Westerns, RankedKevin Costner's Best Westerns, RankedKevin Costner's Best Westerns, Ranked

In the second most powerful Western film of Kevin Costner’s career, titled “Open Range“, we follow two experienced cowboys, Boss Spearman and Charley Waite, portrayed by Robert Duvall and Costner, as they lead their cattle herd across the vast American West. They encounter a town under the control of a corrupt sheriff and his minions, leading to a lethal confrontation that compels them to revisit their past choices and ignite a battle for justice.

Breathtaking Modern-Day Western

Open Range delves into themes of friendship, loyalty, and the hardship of frontier life through a confident and insightful narrative voice. Directed by Kevin Costner, this captivating and emotional Western pays homage to Hollywood’s classic western era while stirring a range of feelings within viewers. Notably, an exceptional gunfight scene during the finale stands as one of the genre’s most memorable moments. As for the acting, Costner delivers a compelling portrayal of Waite, and his collaboration with the esteemed Duvall forms the heart of the movie’s dramatic essence, creating an undeniable connection on screen.

1 ‘Dances With Wolves’ (1990)

Kevin Costner's Best Westerns, RankedKevin Costner's Best Westerns, RankedKevin Costner's Best Westerns, Ranked

As a devoted cinephile, I can’t help but reminisce about my first encounter with “Dances With Wolves,” a cinematic masterpiece that marked Kevin Costner’s directorial debut. This film resonated profoundly, both critically and commercially, weaving an unforgettable tale. The story unfolds around Lieutenant John Dunbar, a Union Army officer who finds himself wounded in battle and stationed at a secluded outpost on the American frontier. As he patiently waits for reinforcements, Dunbar endeavors to assimilate with the local Lakota Sioux tribe, forming deep connections that ultimately transform him into an integral member of their community. His life takes an unexpected turn as he embarks on a transformative journey of self-discovery, forever altering his perspective of the world around him.

A Singular Cinematic Masterpiece

In a more focused manner on the character’s transition from soldier to tribal member, “Dances With Wolves” stands as an undeniable masterpiece. This movie not only solidified Kevin Costner’s reputation as a director but also revolutionized the genre of Westerns by offering a deep and transformative storyline.

The movie powerfully showcases Indigenous people and their cultures, breaking away from stereotypical stories to portray them as multidimensional individuals striving to protect their traditional lifestyle amid fast-paced change. Costner’s character as the savior is heartwarming, while the film’s direction and cinematography are breathtakingly beautiful. Winning seven Academy Awards, it earned recognition for Best Picture and Best Director for Kevin Costner.

Read More

Sorry. No data so far.

2024-11-24 23:35