Netflix’s Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders Breaks Streaming Records in Just 24 Hours

by

Enthusiasts of true-crime programs are well aware that Netflix offers an abundance of content that delves into some of the most notorious murder mysteries throughout history. Their latest sensation, “Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders,” debuted yesterday and has quickly climbed the rankings, placing second only to their popular dark comedy series “Sirens.” Given the captivating nature of this three-part docuseries that investigates one of the largest unsolved cases in American history, it’s no wonder it’s gaining traction.

Under the guidance of Yotam Guendelman and Ari Pines, the documentary titled “Cole Case: The Tylenol Murders” delves deeply into one of America’s most extensive criminal investigations that reshaped pharmaceutical distribution practices. Set in the 80s, the story unfolds in Chicago where a series of deaths from tainted Tylenol capsules caused widespread fear about public health safety. The authorities were in a race against time to identify the perpetrator, with James William Lewis emerging as the prime suspect. However, he was never charged and passed away in 2023 at the age of 76.

The Tylenol case significantly altered how medications like Tylenol are packaged and distributed from then on. No longer could people just open a bottle and pour out pills as they used to; instead, Johnson & Johnson introduced tamper-evident packaging with induction seals and child-resistant caps. Additionally, stricter quality control measures were enforced in factories nationwide.

‘The Tylenol Murders’ Joins Another True-Crime Series on Netflix’s Top 10 List

In the Top 10 list of TV shows currently streaming on Netflix, the true-crime documentary titled “Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders” is joined by another recently released series, namely “Fred and Rose West: A British Horror Story“. Released on May 14, 2025, the latter remains at #8 in the rankings. Similar to “The Tylenol Murders“, this documentary spans over three episodes and delves into the chilling story of two notorious British murderers.

The increasing interest in these two shows indicates that the true-crime genre continues to thrive and gain momentum, with new docuseries quickly rising to the top as audiences eagerly consume them. HBO Max is another popular streaming platform that provides a wealth of content related to Investigation Discovery, such as their latest series, “Sherri Papini: Caught In the Lie“.

Crime enthusiasts might remember the Papini case receiving widespread attention in 2016, following the mysterious disappearance of a woman who was both young and a mother, occurring broad daylight. Three weeks later, she notoriously misled the FBI about being abducted, leading to her serving an 18-month prison sentence. The case was revisited last year in the three-part Hulu documentary titled “The Perfect Wife: The Baffling Disappearance of Sherri Papini“.

Of course, there’s an abundance of true-crime mysteries to dive into, and Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders is the latest addition this year that’s been making waves on social media. You can stream the three-part docuseries on Netflix now, but be cautious: if you have a headache, it might make you reconsider taking some Tylenol.

Read More

2025-05-27 20:33