Netflix’s Controversial Musical Grounds ‘Wicked’ with Golden Globes Win

by

The contentious crime musical, which tells the story of a Mexican cartel leader who transitions into a woman and leaves the criminal world behind, surprisingly won multiple accolades at this year’s Golden Globes, making it the second most-nominated film in Golden Globe history. It took home not only the award for Best Motion Picture – Non-English Language but also Best Motion Picture – Musical or Comedy. However, some movie enthusiasts are left puzzled and disgruntled about this recognition. The topic of the movie is not the main cause of their frustration; instead, it’s the fact that a film they consider to be of poor quality has garnered so much awards attention. This is not an issue related to political correctness or activism but rather a genuine confusion over the movie’s success.

Through their post on Twitter, user @smhrbst expressed disagreement with director Jacques Audiard regarding the film “Emilia Pérez,” a Mexico-set musical about transgender experiences. They criticized that Audiard seemed to treat the themes of the movie, such as transness and Mexican identity, as mere playthings rather than showing genuine empathy for these subjects beyond using them symbolically. In their opinion, it was a shallow representation.

User @georgecarmi expresses disbelief by labeling the situation a “misconception,” stating, “Frankly, we’re living history during this awards season. It’s hard to imagine a film as poorly made as Emilia Perez receiving accolades. This seems like an unprecedented delusion from voting committees that might not recur again.” Meanwhile, @metaplexmovies notes, “EMILIA PÉREZ allows voters to feel self-satisfied for choosing something deemed as avant-garde, thought-provoking, and socially aware, all at once. Despite thinking it’s outdated rubbish, I must admit I’m not surprised by its success!

Golden Globe Viewers Take Issue With ‘Emilia Pérez’s Big Wins

Meanwhile, @PUSHED2START criticizes Emilia Pérez by calling a Spanish musical directed by a French director who doesn’t speak Spanish and dislikes musicals “garbage,” saying that the Golden Globes should be ashamed for giving such an award. Additionally, @chrrypm expresses disappointment that Emilia Pérez won after the French director claimed he didn’t care about researching Mexican culture. Interestingly, a clip shared by Deadline shows Challengers director Luca Guadagnino leaving the Golden Globes event immediately after Emilia Pérez was announced as the winner, suggesting that the shock and disappointment over her win may be significant.

In the film “Emilia Pérez,” helmed by Jacques Audiard, Zoe Saldaña, Karla Sofía Gascón, Selena Gomez, Adriana Paz, Mark Ivanir, and Édgar Ramírez grace the screen. Upon its premiere, this musical garnered positive feedback from critics, with a 76% rating on Rotten Tomatoes. According to reviews, “Karla Sofía Gascón portrays Emilia Perez in a captivating blend of music, crime, and suspense that transcends genres while boldly telling an authentic trans story.

Following her groundbreaking nomination for a Golden Globe as the first trans actress, Karla Sofía Gascón delivered a bold statement alongside her co-stars and team members: “Light triumphs over darkness in every instance.

In every situation, light triumphs over shadow. No matter if we’re imprisoned or hurt, they cannot seize our spirit, our defiance, or our honor. Speak up! Be true to yourself, and recognize your own identity as well.

Read More

2025-01-06 15:01