As a film enthusiast with decades of movie-watching experience under my belt, I must say that both “Bugsy” and “Goodfellas” are exceptional gangster films in their unique ways. While “Goodfellas” undeniably steals the show with its iconic scenes, quotes, and unforgettable characters, “Bugsy” offers a more nuanced portrayal of complex relationships within the mob world.
Each decade has boasted a notable gangster film. The 70’s showcased “The Godfather”, the 80’s featured “Scarface”, and the 90’s offered “Goodfellas”. Movies like “American Gangster” highlighted the 2000s, while “The Irishman” dominated the 2010s. Among these, “Goodfellas” stands out for its smooth narration and unforgettable criminal characters, some of whom bring a touch of humor. This film is often hailed as Martin Scorsese’s masterpiece and received six Oscar nominations at the 63rd Academy Awards. However, it is debated whether “Goodfellas” truly holds the title as the best gangster movie of the 1990s. But does it deserve this acclaim?
A year following “Goodfellas”, Barry Levinson’s movie “Bugsy” came out, which earned 10 Oscar nominations and grossed slightly more than “Goodfellas” at the box office (approximately $48 million each). This could imply that it was a better film.
It’s intriguing to note that the captivating gangster film has largely faded into obscurity as time went on, raising questions about its continued absence from prominence. Is it possible it was overhyped? Did the Academy perhaps elevate a film not worthy of such acclaim? Or is it, in fact, an exceptional movie that deserves more recognition than it currently receives?
Bugsy Captures the Industriousness and Stubbornness of the Founder of Las Vegas
In the movie “Bugsy,” director Barry Levinson paints a compelling picture of entrepreneurship while also offering a heart-wrenching portrayal of an obstinate criminal. The film follows the life story of Benjamin “Bugsy” Siegel, a charismatic figure who was a tabloid sensation years before John Gotti rose to prominence. Renowned for his charm and sharp business skills, Bugsy played a pivotal role in the growth and development of Las Vegas Boulevard.
Instead of delving into the backstory of his earnings, the movie initiates with him as an established mobster, well-connected with Mayer Lansky and Charles “Lucky” Luciano. However, the plot thickens when he encounters Virginia Hill on a film set, portraying a cheerful starlet hiding a venomous personality. Struck by her charm, despite being married, he pursues her ardently.
For the remainder of the film, Bugsy is portrayed as a man with immense foresight and drive. As he cruises through Beverly Hills, he comes across a house that catches his eye and swiftly presents an offer the owner can’t resist. He subsequently seizes power over California’s criminal network from Jack Dragna, and forges an alliance with Jewish crime boss Mickey Cohen.
Subsequently, he outlines the blueprint for a milestone that would immortalize his name: building the first significant hotel in Las Vegas (The Flamingo). Being an eloquent man, he effectively convinces fellow powerful gangsters to invest over $1 million (and significantly more) in this venture.
As events unfold, an undercurrent of anxiety grows. It’s becoming increasingly apparent that Bugsy’s reckless romance could lead to trouble. Over time, his associates grow uneasy with his choices, particularly because Virginia has a reputation for being involved with powerful figures in the American organized crime scene. What makes matters worse is that he allows her to manage their finances. The shocking revelation follows: Virginia is suspected of stealing around $2 million.
Bugsy Is Almost the Complete Package…
Busgy embodies the essence of a turbulent period dominated by mobs, exuding a heartfelt warmth and profound understanding. The biopic’s meticulously crafted script, visually appealing production design, expert editing, and clever employment of era-appropriate music almost make it a perfect ensemble. While certain themes and characters reappear, each scene stands independently, showcasing Steven Levinson’s keen eye for depicting diverse aspects of business and criminal life – whether they are mundane, triumphant, or vulgar.
The cast is impressive, with every actor putting genuine emotion into their parts. This dedicated ensemble truly brings authenticity to the film, skillfully conveying emotional responses that, in less capable hands, might seem contrived. As the main character, Warren Beatty delivers a powerful performance, as he has done on numerous occasions throughout his career, and he rightfully received an Oscar nomination for his chilling portrayal of the Jewish mobster. Ben Kingsley also stands out, while Harvey Keitel recalls why he has been invited to star in many iconic gangster films.
In the film, I find myself portraying Virginia Hill, Bugsy’s challenging lover, played by Annette Bening. She exudes an electrifying mix of budding sensuality and fragile innocence on screen that makes her character so endearing. Yet, it’s the grace and composure this talented actress imbues into Virginia that truly captivates.
…but it Lacks Iconic Scenes and Quotes
As a devoted cinephile, I’d say that “Bugsy” and “Goodfellas” are like two beautifully crafted tunes, except one has a more infectious rhythm, more captivating lyrics, and an irresistible chorus for the audience to join in. In Martin Scorsese’s gangster epic, almost every line resonates deeply and powerfully, making it timeless. From Henry Hill expressing his desire to be a gangster, to Billy Batts playfully teasing Tommy with his shine box comment, there’s no shortage of iconic dialogue. On the other hand, “Bugsy” seems to stick to standard mob chatter, and while it offers occasional heated exchanges between a couple, it doesn’t quite reach the same level as Goodfellas in terms of memorable moments.
As a movie enthusiast, I can’t forget the indelible impact that scenes from “Goodfellas” have left on me. Standout moments include Tommy’s memorable “Funny how?” dialogue exchange, the chilling pistol-whipping scene, the thrilling tracking shot at Copacabana, the intense scene where Henry wakes up to Karen pointing a gun at him, and the trio of Henry, Jimmy, and Tommy disposing of Billy Batt’s body. These scenes are crucial in making movies enduring, and Scorsese’s masterpiece certainly delivers them in abundance.
In my opinion, it’s no secret why “Goodfellas” has a more enduring impact compared to “Bugsy.” After all, Martin Scorsese is synonymous with cinematic brilliance, especially in the gangster genre, while Barry Levinson may not be the first artist who springs to mind when discussing masters of this genre or the greatest filmmakers overall. To put it into perspective, while both Vincent van Gogh and El Greco are undeniably talented, their works continue to resonate differently due to Van Gogh’s unique style and profound influence on modern art.
Bugsy
is available to rent in the US on Apple TV+, Spectrum, or Amazon.
Read More
Sorry. No data so far.
2024-09-16 05:01