Rewatching Sinners: Uncovering the Layers of a Modern Classic

by

CAUTION: The forthcoming article reveals some significant plot points from the 2025 hit movie, Sinners. If you haven’t watched it yet, I advise you to exercise caution and only delve deeper if you are confident that you can handle potential spoilers.

It’s unclear if the disclaimer above is still relevant since most people have already watched Ryan Coogler’s popular horror movie “Sinners.” Despite the widespread acclaim for the film, I initially didn’t share this enthusiasm.

Let me clarify something: Although I thoroughly enjoyed the story about vampires taking over a juke joint’s opening in the 1930s South, I don’t entirely share the widespread opinion that it is not only one of the best horror movies of the year, but potentially the best film of 2025. Frankly, I couldn’t pinpoint what everyone else seemed to appreciate, so I decided to rewatch “Sinners” as soon as it was accessible through an HBO Max subscription. Now that I’ve seen it again, I can see why it has received such high praise. In fact, I suspect my initial viewing was influenced by several factors.

Going In, I Expected A Pure Horror Movie

It’s no surprise to those familiar with me or my work that horror is my preferred film genre, and as a devotee of both Ryan Coogler and Michael B. Jordan, the upcoming horror film Sinners was the one I was looking forward to the most in 2025. However, one might label it as a film with deceptive advertising because, upon closer inspection, classifying it as a horror movie is only partially accurate.

Initially, Sinners seems to be a straightforward period drama with subtle hints of supernatural elements. However, it takes quite some time before vampires are introduced into the plot, which can make the movie feel disconnected or fragmented. Knowing the story’s structure ahead of time can help prepare for this tonal shift and even build excitement for the appearance of Jack O’Connell as Remmick, the main vampire character. Interestingly, the anticipation of this scene significantly affected my overall impression of the film.

I Was Initially Disappointed By Its Portrayal Of Vampires

In my latest review of “Sinners,” I find myself torn between admiring it as a chilling horror masterpiece or an enthralling crime thriller – a dilemma I believe many viewers will share. Upon my initial viewing, I was captivated by the crime-centric aspects and the film’s mesmerizing soundtrack, which overshadowed any of its supernatural allure. However, upon rewatching, my feelings have evolved, and I can now appreciate both the horror and crime elements equally.

I’ve watched plenty of great vampire films, and my top picks often introduce fresh elements to the legacy established by Bram Stoker’s “Dracula.” However, the film from “Sinners” didn’t seem to offer much beyond revealing that their creatures are bound together in a hive mind (and the drooling, I suppose). I found its second half lacking in uniqueness and interest compared to other portrayals, leaving me somewhat disappointed. Fortunately, tastes can shift…

I Was More Impressed With The Horror Elements The Second Time

As a horror movie enthusiast, I’ve often found that what truly makes a film terrifying isn’t always a groundbreaking concept, but rather a unique twist on something already known. Initially, when I first watched Sinners, it didn’t quite resonate with this idea for me. However, upon revisiting the movie, I wholeheartedly rescind my initial thoughts.

It became apparent to me that it’s unfair to fault the movie for its predominantly conventional portrayal of vampirism, as the quality of the bloodsuckers themselves is what truly matters, and in this aspect, the film truly shines. From Remmick’s chilling charisma, the gripping emotional tension, and the stunning visuals that are both terrifyingly eerie and captivatingly beautiful, it may have surpassed the original Nosferatu as my favorite vampire film of all time. Though Coogler has stated that it stands alone with no need for a sequel, I would still welcome an expansion of this universe, particularly if the Choctaw vampire hunters take center stage in future installments.

I Felt More Connected To The Characters The Second Time

As a movie enthusiast, I must confess that during my initial viewing, I didn’t quite resonate with the human characters as deeply as I had hoped. Let me clarify, the cast is extraordinary, especially Miles Caton who makes an impressive debut as Sammie Moore. However, I found it challenging to forge a meaningful connection with him or many of the others huddled at the Juke Joint. But this rewatch has been a game-changer! Now, I consider this masterpiece one of the most remarkable examples of meticulously crafted, character-driven storytelling in recent film history.

The intricate yet contrasting relationship between Smoke and Stack, powerfully portrayed by Jordan’s exceptional dual acting, is strikingly clear and deeply resonated with me, particularly the poignant sorrow of Smoke over losing his child with Annie (Wunmi Mosaku). Initially, I didn’t fully appreciate during my first watch of Sinners the significance of loss to the narrative – it transcends just death, delving into the loss of humanity and identity. A scene that stuck with me is Grace’s (Li Jun Li) shock at seeing her husband, Bo (Yao), transformed into a mindless horde.

Watching Sinners At Home Allowed Me To See More Of The Movie

In contrast to many initial recommendations for Sinners, I opted against watching it in an IMAX theater and instead chose my preferred local cinema, which lacks IMAX capability and features a rather compact main screen. Consequently, I was unaware at the time that I wasn’t experiencing the full movie as intended, but upon re-viewing, it became apparent to me.

On my 150-inch home theater screen, I clearly noticed that the aspect ratio adjusted to fit the IMAX footage at crucial points in the movie. This modification significantly boosted the visual impact for me, particularly during the vampire attack scenes. It even made me ponder over my decision of supporting my favorite smaller theater instead of visiting an IMAX theater.

After watching it again, I still rank Sinners as my second favorite movie of the year (surpassed only by Warfare, which gave me an unexpectedly nostalgic feeling). However, I am eager to declare that I consider it a near-flawless film and one of the most deeply rewarding and imaginative cinematic journeys I’ve ever embarked on. The scene where spirits of musicians from various eras perform with Sammie is particularly noteworthy, as it was captivating to me from the very beginning. It’s delightful to have even more reasons to applaud this timeless masterpiece now.

Read More

2025-07-13 16:08