Shocking Threat: Miami Theater Faces Eviction Over Controversial Documentary Screening!

by

The 2024 documentary film titled “No Other Land” stirred politics significantly upon its release, as its portrayal of the Israeli military’s harsh displacement of a Palestinian community in the West Bank to convert their buildings for military training was seen as unflattering. Despite being awarded the Academy Award for Best Documentary Feature just a few weeks ago, no prominent American distributor has chosen to screen it in US theaters. However, some independent theaters have shown it to local audiences. One such theater is O Cinema, located in Miami Beach, Florida.

Despite being co-produced by two Palestinians and two Israelis, Miami Beach’s Jewish mayor, Steve Meiner, labeled the film as one-sided and antisemitic. He then threatened to cut funding for the O Cinema and terminate its lease if they continued showing it, which would lead to the owners being forced out of their building. This move sparked strong criticism from hundreds of filmmakers, activists, and local Miami residents, who viewed it as a breach of the First Amendment rights guaranteed by the Constitution. However, after a majority of Miami Beach’s city commissioners voted against the eviction, the mayor rescinded his resolution, allowing O Cinema to carry on screening No Other Land.

Censorship vs. Freedom of Speech

As a passionate film enthusiast, I was intrigued by the controversy surrounding “No Other Land” after reading about it in The Guardian. Miami Beach Mayor Steven Breiner voiced his disapproval of the movie, labeling it as ‘one-sided,’ ‘inaccurate,’ ‘antisemitic,’ and a ‘propaganda attack’ on the Jewish people, and even threatened to withdraw O Cinema’s lease for the city-owned building following their decision to continue screening it. Initially, O Cinema CEO Vivian Marthell agreed to halt the film’s screenings, but after discussing with her board, she reconsidered her stance, stating that they felt it was crucial to show such a critically acclaimed and award-winning movie. This defiant move led Mayor Breiner to draft a resolution aimed at cancelling the theater’s lease and potentially deducting around $40,000 from the city’s funds for the theater as a form of punishment.

In a highly contested turn of events, I found myself at the center of a storm within and beyond the vibrant Miami community over a proposed resolution that sparked fierce opposition. Critics, including many prominent Jewish figures, contended that it infringed upon the theater’s right to free speech. A notable figure, Jewish film director Billy Corben, dismissed claims of antisemitism levied by another critic and denounced attempts to censor a film like “No Other Land” as a breach of both American and Jewish values. Corben was one of over 750 filmmakers, including the illustrious Oscar-winning director of “Moonlight,” Barry Jenkins, who also hails from Miami, in signing an open letter to the critic, expressing their vehement opposition to his resolution. Organizations such as the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and the National Coalition Against Censorship rallied to the theater’s defense, with ACLU Florida director Daniel Tilley issuing a stark warning: “If the city of Miami Beach adopts this resolution, they will be breaking the law.

A Community Divided

Just moments after Breiner presented his proposal to the City Commission, I found myself in Miami Beach’s City Hall for a public meeting where people were invited to express their thoughts on the matter. Most speakers voiced their opposition to the eviction of O Cinema, and in an historic decision, the seven-member Commission voted against the resolution. Commissioner Alex Fernandez passionately asserted, “The First Amendment leaves no room for doubt. The government should never suppress artistic expression, even when it pushes boundaries or offends deeply.

Breiner consented to withdraw the initial motion, and instead postponed a subsequent motion proposing that the theater exhibit movies depicting a neutral perspective on the ongoing conflict. One of the commissioners suggested dropping both resolutions at this time. Meanwhile, Cinema O persisted in presenting screenings of the film “No Other Land“, all of which proved to be a complete sell-out.

Despite not being acquired yet by significant American distributors or streaming platforms, independent theaters across the nation are presently organizing screenings of No Other Land.

Read More

2025-03-23 07:02