Star Trek: Insurrection – The Forgotten Movie That Should’ve Been Better Than First Contact

by

Instead of “One Star Trek: The Next Generation movie should have been better than First Contact, but actually turned out to be the worst in the series,” you could say:

“Unfortunately, the Star Trek: The Next Generation film didn’t live up to expectations and ended up being the weakest among all the movies. After a string of successful films featuring the original crew of the USS Enterprise, it was expected that the cast of The Next Generation would carry on the Star Trek legacy on the big screen.

Star Trek Generations” represented a stumble but an essential learning experience as the cherished science fiction universe moved from its original to a new phase. The 1996 release, “Star Trek: First Contact,” shifted towards action and became highly successful. Regrettably, it stood as the peak for the troubled era of Star Trek movies based on The Next Generation series.

In 2002, two additional films were released, yet the crew of the Starship Enterprise didn’t receive a farewell as powerful as their previous counterparts. Despite the fact that “First Contact” deviated from the traditional “Star Trek” themes, it was still an excellent movie that demonstrated the enduring vitality of the 30-year-old franchise.

One specific TNG movie fell short of expectations, primarily due to its near success in recapturing the enchantment of the TV series it originated from. While action sequences can be engaging when Star Trek transitions to the big screen, what was missing were compelling narratives and intricate ethical quandaries.

The Plot Of Star Trek: Insurrection Is Perfect For The TNG Crew

It Bears A Striking Resemblance To A Classic Two-Part Episode Of TNG

After the pulse-pounding excitement of First Contact, Star Trek: Insurrection served as a refreshing change in 1998. Unlike the nonstop action, the film placed Picard and his team against an ethical dilemma, requiring them to uphold their Federation values to ultimately prevail. Upon its release, it was likened to a two-part episode of TNG (The Next Generation).

The comparison was spot-on, drawing inspiration from the third season episode titled “Who Watches the Watchers.” While some aspects of the film’s structure could have been better organized, it had a stronger connection to the series than its predecessor did. It appeared that the creators aimed to preserve the Star Trek values and concepts.

In a significant departure from his usual adherence to rules, Picard finds himself compelled to defy the very institution he holds dear, Starfleet. This bold move is necessitated by the need to uphold what is right. The movie presented an opportune moment for him to break free from his traditional ways and challenge an order. Although all elements were in place for a powerful cinematic experience, the final product failed to meet expectations.

Star Trek TNG Movies Release Year Rotten Tomatoes Score
Star Trek Generations 1994 47%
Star Trek: First Contact 1996 93%
Star Trek: Insurrection 1998 55%
Star Trek: Nemesis 2002 38%

Insurrection Ultimately Forgot To Be An Interesting Movie

A Star Trek Movie Is Supposed To Be Grander Than The TV Show

Even though Star Trek: The Next Generation has many exceptional episodes, it was anticipated that the movies would be more expansive and spectacular compared to their television versions. Regrettably, Insurrection didn’t seem to get the memo and found itself somewhere between a significantly expanded two-part episode and a full-scale movie production.

In this rephrased version, I’ve attempted to maintain the original sentiment while making it more accessible:

The computer-generated images were groundbreaking for the series, yet they didn’t contribute much in the grand scheme of things. As for Captain Picard, his decision to disobey a superior officer’s direct order seemed unexpected, given that he has consistently demonstrated loyalty, even when he disagrees with orders.

Admiral Dougherty seems an unusual choice as a villain because he appears ruthless enough to order the forced relocation of the Ba’ku, yet also naive in being taken aback by the Son’a. This is unexpected given that Star Trek has already explored the ‘evil admiral’ trope before, and Dougherty’s final act of ‘I did it for the Federation’ leaves us puzzled.

When a movie like “First Contact” is so exciting, you tend to overlook small issues such as plot holes and inconsistencies. However, “Insurrection” failed to deliver an engaging experience. It lacked character development and didn’t offer much action, making the story dull and uninteresting. This is disappointing because it feels like a significant missed chance in the vast “Star Trek” universe.

Read More

2025-07-04 20:09