The Big Bang Theory’s Comic Book Blunder Exposes Its Biggest Flaw

by

Despite the characters in The Big Bang Theory seeming to have almost exhaustive knowledge of comic books at first glance, they’ve actually committed some notable errors, supporting one of the show’s most persistent criticisms. From the very first episode to the final series installment of The Big Bang Theory, Leonard (Johnny Galecki) and his companions frequently express their affection for the DC universe’s costumed heroes. Throughout the 12 seasons of The Big Bang Theory, there are numerous references to superheroes, with an increase after Stuart’s (Kevin Sussman) introduction in season 2, making the comic book store a more frequent setting.

The consistent element in the show makes it a crucial part, and removing it could alter the series significantly. Except for Stuart’s upcoming Max series, the spin-offs of Big Bang Theory haven’t delved into the world of comics much so far. In truth, the initial two spin-offs don’t showcase much of nerd culture, but Young Sheldon does present Sheldon Cooper’s (Jim Parsons) affinity for The Flash. Maybe it was a wise decision to steer clear of comic book references in the main series as it never quite hit the mark, especially at times when it mattered most.

Sheldon Got A Fact About Wonder Woman’s Hair Color Wrong

He Should Definitely Know She Can Be Blonde

In season 4, episode 11 of “The Big Bang Theory,” titled “The Justice League Recombination,” the gang goes to a New Year’s Eve costume contest dressed as the Justice League. They convince Penny’s boyfriend Zack to play Superman and persuade a reluctant Penny to be Wonder Woman, despite her disinterest. However, when Penny refuses to wear the blonde wig that came with the costume, Sheldon criticizes her because he believes Wonder Woman isn’t supposed to have blond hair. Interestingly, none of the guys correct him, and Sheldon himself should be aware of this inaccuracy.

There have been several depictions of Wonder Woman with blonde hair, one notable example being Cassie Sandsmark from the comic series ‘Young Justice’. Although officially referred to as ‘Wonder Girl’, she possesses many powers similar to Diana Prince due to their shared ancestry from Zeus. In her initial comic book appearances, she wore a black wig to conceal her identity, but this disguise became unnecessary once her secret was unveiled. Given her role in significant DC storylines like ‘Countdown’ and ‘Infinite Crisis’, it’s likely that she’s a character Sheldon would recognize.

This Episode Misunderstands Nerd & Cosplay Culture – Which Is The Biggest Criticism Of The Show

No Real Nerd Would Have Beef With Penny Going Blonde

Disregarding factors like additional characters, different portrayals of Wonder Woman across various universes, and the 1974 version portrayed by Cathy Lee Crosby, Sheldon’s point regarding hair color doesn’t entirely align with the culture that the series generally strives to portray. Despite Sheldon’s meticulous nature, the cosplay community often encourages diverse interpretations of popular characters. Given their frequent attendance at conventions, one or more of the guys would likely have corrected Sheldon in a similar discussion on most other occasions.

The Unfair Treatment Of Penny Is An Even Bigger Issue

She Didn’t Even Really Want To Be There

In The Big Bang Theory, since most comic book enthusiasts who aren’t Caltech workers are typically depicted as socially withdrawn and comfortable in sweatpants, the show often portrays Penny as an unusual or exotic character. Despite the presence of numerous women at Stuart’s party, Leonard assumes they will win the costume contest just because a girl is part of their group. However, it’s more significant that the series overlooks the fact that Penny initially had no interest in attending the party and was only persuaded to go by the guys.

In this particular episode, Sheldon’s friendship with Penny has progressed past its initial stages, though it might not have fully blossomed to its full potential by the series finale. This episode, however, transpires well after their bond has been forged. Interestingly, neither Sheldon nor the rest of the group seem overly concerned that Penny is essentially doing them a kindness. In contrast to her initial portrayal in the unaired pilot of “The Big Bang Theory”, this version of Penny exhibits extraordinary patience towards them all.

In many social gatherings with her male companions, Penny tends to suppress her unique personality. It’s disheartening to see them belittle her for disliking an element of a costume she never agreed to wear. Regrettably, there are some men in nerd communities who exhibit this kind of behavior, but they aren’t the type of characters we’d want as the focus of a sitcom like The Big Bang Theory, which aspired to portray nerd culture sympathetically and favorably. However, it seems that the show often fell short of achieving this goal.

❤️ Love ScreenRant’s prime-time updates? Sign up now for our weekly Network TV newsletter, tailored just for you! By selecting ‘Network TV’ in your preferences, you can stay updated with exclusive behind-the-scenes insights from actors and showrunners of your beloved series.

Read More

2025-06-01 03:18