The Lord of the Rings Movies Cut This Clever Gandalf Trick From the Books (& It Makes the Scene Even Better)

by

In Peter Jackson’s film “The Fellowship of the Ring,” Bilbo Baggins, on the eve of his 111th birthday and secretly his last night in the Shire, decided to play a final prank before departing. He was planning to journey to the Elven realm of Rivendell, a place he had visited during “The Hobbit” many years ago. After delivering a witty yet emotional farewell speech, Bilbo declared, “I’m leaving now. I bid you all a heartfelt goodbye. Farewell.” As he spoke, he slipped the One Ring onto his finger and became invisible, surprising the other hobbits. In Tolkien’s “The Lord of the Rings” novel, this scene was present, but Jackson made one alteration to it.

In the movie, everyone was equally taken aback by Bilbo’s sudden departure, including Gandalf who, despite knowing about Bilgo’s plan to leave the Shire, wasn’t aware of the One Ring’s role. This led him to worry that his friend had carelessly used a magical artifact. However, in the book, Bilbo had previously clued in Frodo and Gandalf on his plan. Although Gandalf disapproved, he couldn’t stop Bilbo from going through with it. Before the celebration, during the chapter “A Long-Expected Party,” Gandalf advised Bilbo, saying, “It is pointless to say more. Follow your plan – stick to it entirely – and I hope it will end well for you, and for us all.” Unaware of this, Gandalf had his own secret plan up his sleeve.

Gandalf’s Reaction to Bilbo’s Disappearance Was Very Different in The Lord of the Rings Novel

In the book, when Bilbo donned the One Ring following his speech, he didn’t just vanish as was customary. Instead, “There was a sudden, brilliant burst of light, causing everyone to squint.” The source of this light was clarified a few pages on, during Bilbo and Gandalf’s conversation at Bag End. Bilbo admitted, “That bright flash took me off guard, not just the others. A minor detail, I presume?” To which Gandalf responded, “It certainly was. You’ve been wise to keep that ring hidden all these years, and it appeared crucial to me to provide your guests with a different explanation for your sudden disappearance.” Essentially, Gandalf created the illusion of casting a spell to make Bilbo vanish in order to give a plausible reason for his sudden departure.

Tolkien never explicitly stated that Gandalf could make someone invisible, only that the hobbits weren’t privy to his full magical prowess. This left it easy for them to suspect Gandalf when Bilbo vanished, and he was ready to accept the blame because he had already been seen as a bother and a disrupter. At first, Bilbo was irritated by Gandalf’s manipulation, calling him meddlesome, but later chuckled and acknowledged his usual wisdom. Scenes from this dialogue were featured in Jackson’s movie, although any mention of Gandalf causing a flash of light had been excluded.

The Lord of the Rings Films Made Bilbo’s Disappearance Clearer For Fans

In my humble opinion as a movie critic, it was shrewdly cunning of Gandalf to veil the truth behind Bilbo’s vanishing act at the festive gathering. The ordinary hobbits present were unlikely to comprehend or take interest in the One Ring, but the Shire occasionally welcomed travelers from bustling towns like Bree. It was prudent that unfounded tales did not circulate, given the ravenous curiosity of the Dark Lord Sauron and the scheming Saruman the White, who both coveted any hints about the whereabouts of this enigmatic artifact. When these formidable adversaries embarked on their relentless pursuit of the One Ring, none of the hobbits could have provided them with information regarding a ring of invisibility – a detail that would have significantly facilitated their quest.

Despite the fact that Jackson chose wisely by excluding this plot detail from the movie, viewers might have been perplexed by a bright flash when Bilbo donned the ring because they weren’t yet acquainted with it at that point in the narrative. Eliminating this element also allowed for the trimming of conversations between Gandalf and Bilbo, making their exchanges more intense. In the adaptation of an extensive tale like “The Lord of the Rings,” it was essential to accelerate certain scenes. Although Gandalf producing a flash of light was an entertaining demonstration of his caution and resourcefulness in Tolkien’s story, the film benefited from its absence.

Read More

2025-06-04 04:35