‘They’re Very Committed To It’: Star Trek’s Colm Meaney Shares Honest Take On Claims That Fans Are ‘Nuts’

'They're Very Committed To It': Star Trek's Colm Meaney Shares Honest Take On Claims That Fans Are 'Nuts'

As a dedicated Star Trek enthusiast with decades of fandom under my belt, I wholeheartedly agree with Colm Meaney‘s sentiments about the franchise’s fans. I’ve had the pleasure of interacting with countless Trekkies over the years, and I can attest that they are indeed professional, knowledgeable, and passionate about Star Trek. Their commitment to the series has not only enriched my own experience but also fostered a sense of community that transcends geographical boundaries.


To Star Trek enthusiasts like me, Colm Meaney is an invaluable gem. In the humorous yet unofficial ranks of Lower Decks, Miles O’Brien was bestowed the title “The Most Significant Figure in Starfleet History.” Given the multitude of crises his character navigated across The Next Generation and Deep Space Nine, I can’t help but agree that this accolade is well-deserved. What makes Meaney even more admirable is his graceful approach to the sometimes contentious fandom, recently defending Trekkies against undeserved criticism from outsiders.

Meaney recently spoke to ComicBookMovie about his history with the iconic franchise, and just to get it out of the way now, he still hasn’t changed his stance about not appearing in any upcoming Star Trek projects. So that’s out of the picture. But when asked about the legacy of the franchise and dealing with Trekkies, the actor seemed to go on the defensive in discussing the largely pleasant exchanges he’s had with fans:

I didn’t initially agree with the notion that Star Trek fans are all eccentric, but there are a few who might fit that description. However, most of them have always come off as dedicated enthusiasts to me. They’re friendly, open about their thoughts, and then they respect personal space – which is a rare quality nowadays. I must admit, they’ve always impressed me with their in-depth knowledge, far exceeding what I knew when I was involved.

Given today’s streaming services like Paramount+ make it easy for “Star Trek” fans to binge-watch the entire TV series, it’s not surprising that viewers are usually more knowledgeable about the show’s lore than the actors themselves. After all, if an actor like Colm Meaney is occupied with other projects and has no desire to rejoin the franchise, why would he be spending time watching his old episodes?

Meaney consistently complimented the fans for their profound understanding of both “Deep Space Nine” and “The Next Generation”, and he mentioned that this depth of knowledge offered an additional advantage. Instead of fixating on the puzzling instances of “TNG”, it appears they’re all taking away a more profound meaning from these series.

1) It was surprising how much they knew about Star Trek episodes compared to me, but their dedication is commendable. The series has had a significant, positive impact on society, promoting unity among diverse races, aliens, and humans alike. I believe Roddenberry’s vision for a harmonious universe in the show was truly inspiring, and they have faithfully carried this message forward, making it a beacon of positivity.

The reason Star Trek fans are so nice might be because they follow Gene Roddenberry’s idea of working towards a greater good with a compassionate mindset. That sounds plausible to me. However, William Shatner, one of the actors, claims that the franchise has drifted from Roddenberry’s original vision and doesn’t even watch it himself. So, his opinion might not accurately reflect the series’ success. Instead, I agree more with Colm Meaney’s analysis.

I Asked Star Trek: Discovery’s Michelle Paradise If She’ll Return To The Franchise After Series Finale, And Her Response Was So Perfect

'They're Very Committed To It': Star Trek's Colm Meaney Shares Honest Take On Claims That Fans Are 'Nuts'

I love this.

It’s unfortunate that he seems uninterested in reprising his role as Miles O’Brien, given Ronald D. Moore’s recent interest in reviving the franchise as reported by TopMob. It would be disappointing if Deep Space Nine’s sequel didn’t feature Miles prominently, considering his significant contributions to the show, such as the episode where he was forced to dress as a Klingon and detested it.

There’s a bright side to this situation: Actors like Colm Meaney can always reconsider their decisions, and it might be that he hasn’t been approached for a role in the new Star Trek. If he receives an offer and finds the script appealing, I wouldn’t rule out him thinking about it. In fact, it could even be a possibility to please fans who long for Miles O’Brien’s return. However, I must admit that I could be mistaken. But considering how many original cast members have come back, I don’t find it unreasonable to believe he might join the team again.

At the moment, we can carry on exploring Miles O’Brien’s journeys in “Star Trek: The Next Generation” and “Deep Space Nine”, which are available on Paramount+. I’m deeply engrossed in “Deep Space Nine” at present and finding it incredibly enjoyable, so I would strongly suggest that other readers follow suit.

Read More

2024-08-16 04:37