This 1990s Stephen King Adaptation Remains One of the Most Underrated

This 1990s Stephen King Adaptation Remains One of the Most Underrated

Quick Links

  • Needful Things Plot and Cast
  • Needful Things Performed Badly at The Box Office
  • Needful Things Found a Second Life with a Cult Following

As a longtime fan of Stephen King’s works, I must say that my initial viewing of “Needful Things” left me a tad underwhelmed. The focus on Max von Sydow’s character seemed to overshadow the other residents’ struggles, which I felt were crucial in conveying the tragic events unfolding in Castle Rock. Yet, time has been kind to this film, and it has found new life as a cult classic among horror enthusiasts – myself included.


In terms of horror literature, it’s challenging to find a more impactful figure than Stephen King, especially when it comes to movie adaptations. His works have inspired over 350 films, and while some are highly acclaimed like ‘The Shining’ and ‘Misery’, others such as ‘Dreamcatcher’ and ‘The Lawnmower Man’ receive mixed reactions. Despite the abundance of these films, there are undoubtedly a few that don’t get the recognition they deserve, fading into obscurity with the passage of time.

1993’s “Needful Things” is often overlooked among Stephen King adaptations, having initially underperformed at the box office and received negative criticism upon release. However, over time, this film has developed a dedicated cult following who appreciate aspects that were once criticized. This analysis will explore the initial reception of “Needful Things” and its subsequent success to demonstrate why it continues to be considered one of King’s most overlooked adaptations.

Needful Things Plot and Cast

This 1990s Stephen King Adaptation Remains One of the Most UnderratedThis 1990s Stephen King Adaptation Remains One of the Most UnderratedThis 1990s Stephen King Adaptation Remains One of the Most Underrated

In the quaint town of Castle Rock, Maine, a fresh store opens, managed by Leland Gaunt (Max von Sydow). Gradually, he starts striking deals with locals for their most valued items. As these trades escalate, the town’s tranquility deteriorates, sparking rivalries that flare into violence. Residents grow increasingly suspicious of each other, and fear permeates the once peaceful community. With tensions running high, it falls upon newly engaged Sheriff Alan Pangborn (Ed Harris) to sift through reality and myth as townspeople start killing one another, while whispers circulate that Gaunt might be a conduit for an ancient evil, willing to go to any lengths to prevail.

Initially, I was merely a traveling merchant wandering across the vast, unseeing expanse of a far-off world. I was constantly on the move, always departing… and eventually, I would provide them with weapons. And they would accept them every time. Naturally, I had left before they fully understood what they’d acquired from me. (This is a paraphrase of Leland Gaunt’s lines in Needful Things, spoken by Max von Sydow.)

The movie Needful Things features Ed Harris portraying Sheriff Alan Pangborn, who has made significant appearances in films like 1993’s The Firm and 1992’s Glengarry Glen Ross. However, Harris is arguably more recognized for his roles in the Western film Appaloosa, where he also served as director, Pollock, and The Truman Show. Max von Sydow takes on the enigmatic and controlling character of Leland Gaunt, owner of Needful Things shop. With over 150 roles under his belt throughout his career, it’s challenging to single out a defining performance for the esteemed Max von Sydow.

Prominent additional characters are Bonnie Bedelia portraying Polly Chambers, Sheriff Alan Pangborn’s fiancée; Amanda Plummer and Valri Bromfield playing contentious townsfolk Nettie Cobb and Wilma Jerzyck; J.T. Walsh as the volatile mayor Danforth Keeton III; and Ray McKinnon in the role of Deputy Norris Ridgewick, a determined officer.

In his roles as writer, producer, and director, Fraser C. Heston has noteworthy credits beyond assistant directing the comedy “City Slickers” and the movie “Needful Things.” Interestingly, Fraser is the son of acclaimed actor Charles Heston, and he had a minor role in “The Ten Commandments” as the baby Moses. The screenplay for this film was penned by W.D. Richter, who has 16 writing credits to his name but is known for working on cult classics like “Invasion of the Body Snatchers” (1978) and John Carpenter’s “Big Trouble in Little China.”

Needful Things Performed Badly at The Box Office

This 1990s Stephen King Adaptation Remains One of the Most UnderratedThis 1990s Stephen King Adaptation Remains One of the Most UnderratedThis 1990s Stephen King Adaptation Remains One of the Most Underrated

It’s important to note that the exact budget for the film “Needful Things” isn’t known, but it’s estimated to be approximately $15 million. Given its box office earnings of $15.2 million, it seems that the movie didn’t perform financially well and fell short of expectations for a major studio release during summer. Critics and viewers have given mixed to negative reviews, with a Rotten Tomatoes rating of 32% from 28 reviews and an audience score of 44% based on more than 10,000 ratings. However, the movie gets slightly better marks on other platforms like IMDb (6.3) and Letterboxd (3/5).

The film received a mixed-to-negative response and underperformed at the box office, which can be explained by several factors. To diehard Stephen King fans, the movie veered too much from the original material, neglecting significant character development that added depth to the book’s exploration of the psychological deterioration of Castle Rock, Maine’s residents. This departure was perceived as a missed opportunity compared to other highly-regarded adaptations of King’s works. Furthermore, the movie’s emphasis on Max von Sydow’s Leland Gaunt overshadowed the other characters, causing some critics to argue that it lacked the emotional connection required to portray the hardships endured by the townsfolk effectively.

The general flow and direction of the movie also came under scrutiny, with pacing issues resulting from an admittedly disjointed storyline that jumps between characters with a lot of exposition in between. Many felt that it lacked the same horror and profundity of the original work or any other Stephen King Adaptation; it is difficult to even place it among the top ’90s adaptations of the author’s work with Misery in 1990 and Green Mile in 1999, even though it is one of the higher-rated movies from the era. However, time has been kind to Needful Things, and it garnered a cult following and has found new appreciation among horror fans.

Needful Things Found a Second Life with a Cult Following

This 1990s Stephen King Adaptation Remains One of the Most UnderratedThis 1990s Stephen King Adaptation Remains One of the Most UnderratedThis 1990s Stephen King Adaptation Remains One of the Most Underrated

Over time, certain early criticisms of “Needful Things” have been more warmly received; this can partly be attributed to nostalgia, as the ’90s style and slight campiness of the production have become appealing to horror fans from that period. However, other aspects of the film also shine on their own. For instance, Max von Sydow’s performance, a blend of charm and menace, has proven to be a standout, despite initial complaints. In fact, his portrayal, which balances between alluring and ominous, makes him an excellent central figure for delving into the sorrows that beset the peaceful town.

“You’re disgusting, Dan. I like that in a person.” Leland Gaunt (Max von Sydow) in Needful Things

Some admirers of Stephen King acknowledge that the film accurately captures one essential aspect: the small-town ambiance that King skillfully creates, which is portrayed convincingly enough among the townsfolk to disregard its other imperfections. The incorporation of genuine dark humor, such as the scene where a young child gruesomely takes his own life after declaring “Mickey Mantle sucks,” (for full understanding, you need to watch the movie) has led many online viewers to consider it an underrated horror masterpiece.

In a Reddit discussion, the movie titled Stephen King’s adaptation received a lot of positive feedback. The original poster, GodFlintsone, shared their thoughts by saying “it may not be in the top echelon of Stephen King film adaptations of his books, but I found it to be an unexpectedly enjoyable horror ride.” They concluded by expressing that “to be honest, this movie was a subtle blast. If you’re seeking something entertaining to conclude your Halloween season horror movie marathon, there are certainly worse ways to invest two hours.”

It’s worth mentioning that the original film adaptation of “Needful Things” was significantly shortened. However, showing the movie as a full miniseries on TBS provided viewers with the intended experience, as it included extra character development and plot details that added depth to the story. The theatrical release is 102 minutes long, while the extended version runs for 191 minutes. You can rent “Needful Things” on Amazon Prime, Apple TV, or YouTube.

Read More

2024-08-18 02:01