Tim Blake Nelson Disagrees with Martin Scorsese About Marvel

Tim Blake Nelson Disagrees with Martin Scorsese About Marvel

As a long-time admirer of both Tim Blake Nelson and Martin Scorsese, I find myself torn between their perspectives on the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). On one hand, I can understand Scorsese’s argument about the distinction between traditional cinema and the more spectacle-driven nature of the MCU. However, as a fan who has grown up with these films, I must side with Nelson.


Tim Blake Nelson recently voiced his thoughts on the frequent discussions about criticisms leveled against the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) by esteemed filmmaker Martin Scorsese. Ever since Robert Downey Jr.’s Iron Man kicked off the franchise in 2008, the MCU has garnered both ardent praise and harsh criticism. Despite its unquestionable box office success – surpassing $30 billion thus far – the MCU has drawn its fair share of detractors from the more conventional filmmaking community.

Actor Nelson, recognized for his role as Samuel Sterns, also known as The Leader, in The Incredible Hulk, has publicly defended the franchise. Unlike other supporters who have been enthusiastic about Marvel’s success, Nelson’s viewpoint might not be what fans anticipate.

In an interview with Variety, Nelson discussed his return to the Marvel Universe as he gears up for the new movie titled “Captain America: Brave New World“.

“I was profoundly saddened at the thought of not returning to the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). As an actor, my main desire was to discover this character’s fate. After 18 years, I finally had the chance, and it exceeded my expectations. It was a significant challenge that I navigated gracefully under Julius Onah’s guidance, an independent director known for collaborating with actors and offering them chances to portray extraordinary characters. Marvel shares this approach, fostering such collaborations.”

Where Does Scorsese Fit Into All This?

Tim Blake Nelson Disagrees with Martin Scorsese About MarvelTim Blake Nelson Disagrees with Martin Scorsese About MarvelTim Blake Nelson Disagrees with Martin Scorsese About MarvelTim Blake Nelson Disagrees with Martin Scorsese About Marvel

The controversy regarding the Marvel Cinematic Universe’s standing in filmmaking hit its zenith in 2019, when Scorsese made a remark that has since been widely shared on social media for the past five years in the form of memes. At the time, he stated:

I don’t see them. I tried, you know? But that’s not cinema,

A flurry of disagreements ensued among prominent Marvel figures such as James Gunn, Samuel L. Jackson, and, unsurprisingly, Kevin Feige, following Nelson’s comment. Now, Nelson has joined in the discussion, expressing his disagreement with Scorsese’s stance.

As a film enthusiast, I hold Martin Scorsese in the highest regard; he truly stands alone in his craft. However, I find myself at odds with him when he criticizes Marvel movies. While they may not reach the depths of a Scorsese masterpiece or compare to the likes of “Bicycle Thieves” or “Schindler’s List,” I firmly believe that Marvel films are indeed cinema.

Instead of simply disputing Scorsese’s criticism, Nelson went on to discuss the accomplishments of the Marvel Cinematic Universe within the film industry.

Marvel’s achievement in filmmaking is unprecedented, a truly unique phenomenon in the history of cinema. Under the guidance of Kevin Feige and his team, they’ve produced numerous interconnected movies, all set within a single cinematic universe – a term they coined themselves. There’s simply no parallel to this accomplishment. Therefore, no, I don’t believe Marvel’s success story is coming to an end.

As the upcoming film “Captain America: Brave New World” nears its premiere, Nelson’s defense of the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) could serve as a refresher of its enduring quality and allure. Despite ongoing discussions about its cinematic significance, the MCU has proven successful this summer with Deadpool and Wolverine surpassing $1 billion at the box office, indicating that there remains a substantial audience eager for superhero tales…as long as they’re told effectively.

Read More

Sorry. No data so far.

2024-08-12 01:04