Why ‘Avengers: Doomsday’ Should Ditch the Fox X-Men Cast for Good!

by

In the most remote corners of the web, where die-hard comic book enthusiasts dominate the conversation, there’s a significant stir concerning the X-Men actors appearing in the latest movie, Avengers: Doomsday. Although the film won’t be out for some time, it’s important to remember who we’re talking about – these are the realms of the internet where conversations range from speculating whether Batman could overpower the entire Justice League with enough preparation time, to questioning if Squirrel Girl truly possesses more power than Thanos.

What’s truly captivating about superhero fandom is the intensity and enthusiasm these discussions evoke. There’s a lot of buzz surrounding this recent announcement, as it’s been revealed that the original X-Men characters from Fox will feature in an upcoming film. This is quite significant. Fans are ecstatic at the possibility of witnessing the X-Men within the Marvel Cinematic Universe for the first time. Additionally intriguing is the prospect of seeing several original cast members alongside established MCU stars, making this even more enticing.

On the contrary, not all share this viewpoint. In truth, some find it somewhat disappointing! This is a minority perspective, yet it deserves attention as well. Here’s a case for why Fox’s X-Men shouldn’t be part of the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

It’s Not Nostalgia Anymore, It’s Over-Exposure

Over the past 25 years, the original cast has delivered a remarkable run that X-Men fans will cherish as a lifetime of movie memories. Yet, we’ve seen them grow older in these years and endured some cringeworthy scenes. Moreover, they’ve demonstrated the limits of their characters, providing us with thrilling action without relying too heavily on CGI or stunt doubles, making it feel like the original actors, not just younger versions, are taking on those intense roles.

Didn’t we all feel deeply touched, even shedding real tears in some instances, as Deadpool and Wolverine seemed to bid a poignant farewell to the Fox X-Men universe? Given its impressive cameos, such as Tyler Mane’s Sabretooth and Dafne Keen’s X23, and serving as closure for Hugh Jackman’s iconic Wolverine, it was primarily designed to pave the way for Deadpool to enter the Marvel Cinematic Universe. In essence, wasn’t it intended to also mark the end of the old Fox franchise so we could start anew in the MCU with a fresh cast?

Do We Want To See Our Favorite X-Men Characters Devolve Into Caricatures?

It turns out that Patrick Stewart’s Professor X and Ian McKellen’s Magneto are joining the cast of Doomsday, which is exciting news for X-Men enthusiasts. These two actors have done an outstanding job portraying these iconic mutant rivals, and their performances have been a delight to watch over the years. However, it’s important to acknowledge that Stewart is 84 and McKellen is 85. Despite their advanced ages, they continue to demonstrate acting skills that surpass many younger stars. Yet, some fans may be hoping for new characters or adaptations for these beloved actors. As Deadpool once joked about Hugh Jackman’s situation with Disney, it seems there might be a grain of truth in that humor.

Indeed, it was a fox that took his life. However, Disney miraculously resurrected him. It seems they have plans to keep him busy until he reaches the ripe age of ninety.

The initial comment may not hold up if we continue to follow these characters when the actors, who are now approaching their nineties, are literally in that age group. However, it’s not just about the original cast growing older and no longer able to portray their characters at their prime. It also means that Channing Tatum will once again play Gambit in the upcoming film, which is referred to as “Doomsday”.

Gambit Deserves To Be Done Right This Time

Ryan Reynolds’ generous act of making Tatum’s dream come true by casting him as Gambit was undeniably impressive. The portrayal was instantly iconic, but there’s a question about whether he should continue playing the character. He nailed the role and delivered a memorable performance, yet his portrayal was also comical and eventually turned into a popular internet meme. Is it appropriate to maintain this humorous take on Gambit, a cherished X-Men character who wasn’t part of the original film series?

25 years ago, there was a chance for Fox to cast a talented actor like Olivier Martinez for the role of Gambit, but they didn’t seize the opportunity. Now, what we really want is not just to see Gambit on screen, but to witness a portrayal that is both serious and well-executed by a seasoned actor.

Nostalgia Is a Powerful Drug, Especially for X-Men Fans

For fans of X-Men worldwide, Deadpool & Wolverine delivered a heartfelt farewell note symbolizing the Fox era. This touching tribute served as a heartwarming recognition of the stars and stirred memories of cherished moments. Yet, amidst the wave of nostalgia, it’s essential to recall that the franchise also had its flaws.

It’s hard to overlook the disappointment many Rogue fans felt when comparing Anna Paquin’s portrayal of Rogue to their ideal version. The films lacked iconic costumes for characters like Gambit, Wolverine rarely bled or donned his cowl, and Apocalypse was essentially just Oscar Isaac with teal makeup. These elements overshadowed the nostalgia, as most X-Men fans yearn to witness their beloved characters brought to life in the grandeur of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, complete with stylish costumes and exhilarating action scenes that truly highlight their powers and the awe they inspire on screen.

In order for this transition to take place, it’s essential that the initial Fox franchise comes to an end and a successor rises from its ashes. It’s inevitable that this will occur at some point, but we’re not sure yet which original cast members will still be around when the new phase truly gets underway. The release date for “Avengers: Doomsday” is set for May 1, 2026.

Read More

2025-04-06 19:05