Why Gerard Butlers Phantom of the Opera Was So Divisive

Why Gerard Butlers Phantom of the Opera Was So Divisive

Quick Links

  • Gerard Butler Becomes a Surprising Choice for The Phantom
  • The Phantom of the Opera Is an Oscar-Nominated Silver Screen Production

As a long-time admirer of musicals and romantic tales that tug at one’s heartstrings, I must say that The Phantom of the Opera was an absolute delight for me! Having grown up listening to Andrew Lloyd Webber’s masterpiece, I was initially skeptical about how it would translate onto the big screen. However, Gerard Butler’s captivating portrayal of the tormented Phantom left me spellbound and brought tears to my eyes on more than one occasion.


In the 2000s, musicals underwent a significant surge in popularity, thanks to blockbuster cinema versions of shows like “Moulin Rouge!”, “Chicago”, “Dreamgirls”, and “Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street”. These productions left audiences spellbound with their memorable characters, gripping storylines, and catchy melodies. In 2004, the cinematic interpretation of Andrew Lloyd Webber’s renowned musical “The Phantom of the Opera” was released, featuring Gerard Butler, Emmy Rossum, and Patrick Wilson in leading roles, bringing the captivating tale to life on the big screen.

In my opinion, I was captivated by the breathtakingly beautiful image that graced our screens, showcasing phenomenal performances from its exceptionally gifted lead trio. This film, which resonated deeply with audiences, raked in over $154 million and garnered widespread acclaim for its compelling retelling of the timeless story. However, it seems that the musical aspect didn’t quite strike a chord with critics as much, resulting in a 33% Rotten Tomatoes score compared to its impressive 84% approval rating among fans, as reflected on the Popcornmeter. I’m curious to delve into why The Phantom of the Opera was so polarizing at the time and why it truly deserves all the adoration it receives today.

Webber’s Acclaimed Phantom of the Opera Comes to Life

Why Gerard Butlers Phantom of the Opera Was So DivisiveWhy Gerard Butlers Phantom of the Opera Was So DivisiveWhy Gerard Butlers Phantom of the Opera Was So Divisive

The 2004 romantic drama musical film “The Phantom of the Opera,” directed by Joel Schumacher, unfolds in 1870s Paris at a prestigious opera house. There, hidden in the shadows beneath the building, resides a mysterious, disfigured figure who secretly influences the management to advance his gifted and promising protegee, Christine Daaé (played by Emmy Rossum), in her burgeoning stage career. This tale is inspired by Andrew Lloyd Webber’s iconic stage production of the same name.

In this tale, I find myself, a tormented soul known as The Phantom (Gerard Butler), driven to extreme measures – even murder and chaos – to ensure the woman I adore, a promising opera singer named Christine, becomes a renowned star and the face of our beloved opera house. However, my heart is shattered when Raoul de Chagny (Patrick Wilson), Christine’s former childhood sweetheart, reappears with intentions to win her affections once more.

Gerard Butler Becomes a Surprising Choice for The Phantom

Why Gerard Butlers Phantom of the Opera Was So DivisiveWhy Gerard Butlers Phantom of the Opera Was So DivisiveWhy Gerard Butlers Phantom of the Opera Was So Divisive

The musical production of “The Phantom of the Opera” showcases outstanding performances from its diverse and skilled actors, however, when it was announced that Gerard Butler would play the lead character, there was much debate among the media and public. Initially, Hugh Jackman was considered for the lead role because he is a well-known leading man in Hollywood with ample singing and theater experience. Unfortunately, Jackman had to decline the offer due to scheduling issues related to “Van Helsing.” Likewise, Anne Hathaway was chosen to portray Christine Daaé, but she had to withdraw because she was occupied filming “The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement” at that time.

Following Gerard Butler’s captivating portrayal in Dracula 2000, director Joel Schumacher was deeply captivated by Butler’s talent and decided to cast him as the tormented and smitten Phantom. Surprised at being selected for the role, Butler expressed his doubts due to his youth and limited musical background, having only sung in a rock band before. However, he swiftly started vocal lessons and ultimately delivered an impressive rendition of “The Music of the Night” for Schumacher and Andrew Lloyd Webber, leaving both of them impressed by his performance.

Despite not having traditional vocal training, Butler captivated audiences with his impressive renditions of timeless melodies such as “Angel of Music,” “The Phantom of the Opera,” and “The Point of No Return.” He successfully challenged skeptics by delivering a compelling performance as the famed tormented antagonist. Ahead of the release of The Phantom of the Opera, Butler spoke in an interview about the film’s enduring charm and fascination, sharing his thoughts with Female.com.

Deep within us all lies a romantic and passionate spirit, and a captivating dark romance can spark emotions regardless of age. This film, in particular, offers an exceptional experience. It carries the essence of classic Hollywood, yet it’s also modern, energetic, and visually stunning – much like Joel’s signature style. From a cinematic perspective, it’s a delightful spectacle.

The Phantom of the Opera Is an Oscar-Nominated Silver Screen Production

Why Gerard Butlers Phantom of the Opera Was So DivisiveWhy Gerard Butlers Phantom of the Opera Was So DivisiveWhy Gerard Butlers Phantom of the Opera Was So Divisive

On December 22, 2004, The Phantom of the Opera made its grand debut, leaving audiences spellbound with its breathtaking visuals and captivating performances from Butler, Rossum, and Wilson as the tragic lovers. The magnificent and ornate stage designs, along with the iconic soundtrack, also received praise from fans, although the overall critical response was somewhat divided. Some critics believed that Schumacher prioritized style over substance and felt that he should have deviated more from the original musical. Instead, they perceived it as a faithful but uninspired adaptation rather than a fresh modern retelling.

Despite varying opinions from critics, both enthusiasts of the original musical and admirers of exceptional stars were left astounded by the big-screen adaptation, earning the movie a distinguished A CinemaScore and a strong 7.2 IMDb rating from over 133,000 votes. Contrary to what critics gave The Phantom of the Opera (a mere 33% on Rotten Tomatoes), viewers were enamored with Gerard Butler’s chilling portrayal of the Phantom, causing the film to garner an impressive 84% approval on Popcornmeter based on over 250,000 reviews. This demonstrates that critics don’t always hit the mark on their assessments.

The film adaptation of “The Phantom of the Opera” raked in approximately $154 million at the box office and secured three Academy Award nominations and three Golden Globe mentions, among them Best Motion Picture – Musical or Comedy. Additionally, Gerard Butler received a Satellite Award nomination for Best Actor. Initially met with skepticism for taking on the title role, Butler delivered an outstanding performance that captivated audiences with his emotional portrayal in this mesmerizing musical. Impressed with the final result, Andrew Lloyd Webber, the creator of the original production, had previously expressed satisfaction with it.

“The movie is both visually and auditorily stunning, and I believe it excellently captures the stage production. Although it sticks closely to the original material, the film adds a more profound emotional depth. It may not resemble the theater in terms of visuals or direction, but it retains the same fundamental spirit. This is everything I could have wished for.

The Phantom of the Opera is available to Rent/Buy on Prime Video.

Read More

Sorry. No data so far.

2024-11-09 20:01