‘You’re Dead Wrong’: Ridley Scott Defends Gladiator II Scene That’s Already Getting Hate Online Over Accuracy

‘You’re Dead Wrong’: Ridley Scott Defends Gladiator II Scene That’s Already Getting Hate Online Over Accuracy

As a lifelong aficionado of historical epics and a devoted fan of Ridley Scott‘s cinematic masterpieces, I eagerly anticipate the release of “Gladiator II.” Having spent countless hours delving into the annals of Roman history, I can confidently say that the idea of a flooded Colosseum hosting a naval battle with sharks is not as preposterous as some critics may claim.


Approximately 20 years after the critically acclaimed film “Gladiator” from the 2000s won numerous Oscars and revolutionized historical epics, director Ridley Scott is preparing to take viewers back to ancient Rome with the upcoming sequel titled “Gladiator II”. The movie, set for release in 2024, features Paul Mescal as Lucius, a fresh gladiator forced into slavery and navigating the treacherous landscape of the Colosseum. The film explores themes such as honor, vengeance, and justice. Although eager fans are looking forward to the movie’s November release, one scene has sparked debate online, with Scott himself speaking out in defense of it. He contends that those criticizing the film for historical accuracy are simply mistaken.

The scene in question features the Colosseum transformed into a flooded arena for a mock naval battle, complete with sharks. As soon as glimpses of this scene from the “magnificent spectacle” of a film, skeptics took to social media to question its historical accuracy, arguing that the ancient Romans lacked the engineering to flood the Colosseum, let alone with live sharks. However, in a recent interview with Collider, the Blade Runner filmmaker gave a no-holds-barred response to those critiques, saying:

You’re dead wrong. The Colosseum did flood with water, and there were sea battles… Dude, if you can build a Colosseum, you can flood it with fucking water. Are you joking? And to get a couple of sharks in a net from the sea, are you kidding? Of course they can.

Fair enough. No more questions, right?

As a passionate gamer, I’m not shy about taking creative risks if it means crafting an epic experience that leaves you speechless. And while there might be disagreements among historians on the finer details, there’s no denying the Romans were technological geniuses in their time. Their love for grandiose spectacles like the “naumachiae” – intricate, staged naval battles designed to showcase their engineering skills and captivate the masses – is a testament to this.

Ridley Scott’s portrayal of the Colosseum’s water system in his work isn’t merely for show; instead, it’s deeply grounded in his approach to historical narrative. Known for a unique blend of thorough research and creative panache, he consistently prioritizes immersive and impactful action filmmaking over minute details. In the upcoming Gladiator II, the battle involving sharks in the navy isn’t a mere spectacle—it’s a means to embody the daring nature of Roman entertainment. Despite criticisms from fans about its realism, the 86-year-old British filmmaker remains unphased by skeptics. For him, if it enhances the story, it’s worth it.

Regardless of the debate on the authenticity of the Colosseum scene filled with sharks, it’s anticipated that Gladiator II will retain the grandeur and emotional intensity that made its predecessor a timeless masterpiece. Director Ridley Scott considers this sequel as some of his finest work, and the early reception for Gladiator II has been overwhelmingly positive. As the release date on November 22nd draws nearer, fans will soon be able to judge whether the director’s vision of Rome, complete with submerged Colosseums and shark-laden waters, lives up to the legacy of Gladiator.

Regardless of whether there’s a discussion or not, it’s undeniable that Scott’s enthusiasm for revitalizing old history is indomitable. If adding some dramatic film elements to the mix makes things more exciting? So much the better.

Ready to revisit the classic film Gladiator again before its sequel premieres? You can stream it right away with a Paramount+ subscription. And for those eager for what’s coming up next year, be sure not to miss our comprehensive list of all the 2025 movies on the horizon.

Read More

Sorry. No data so far.

2024-11-05 18:07