10 Best John Wayne Westerns That Still Hold Up

10 Best John Wayne Westerns That Still Hold Up

As someone who has spent countless hours immersed in the wild west genre, I must say that these iconic John Wayne films are truly a testament to the power of storytelling and the enduring allure of the old frontier.


John Wayne, even without a clear destination, stood out among the grandest landscapes of cinema and left an indelible impression. His strong, heavy persona, particularly when paired with the essence of the American frontier, is unrivaled. His debut leading role in a Western was in 1930 with Raoul Walsh’s “The Big Trail,” but it was his iconic portrayal in “Stagecoach” that marked the beginning of the golden age of Westerns. Throughout his career, spanning from his first role to his final moving performance in “The Shootist,” John Wayne starred in many timeless Westerns that continue to be relevant today.

Over the years, I’ve had the privilege of weaving together an extensive collection of tales, something few actors can claim. From squaring off against Japanese soldiers in “The Sands of Iwo Jima,” to breaking the spirit of a wild and relentless train in “Red River,” and standing against outlaws in “El Dorado” and “Hondo,” I’ve consistently infused these roles with my unique charm and heroism, captivating audiences. My most consistent collaborator was director John Ford, and our early successes paved the way for more on-screen partnerships with esteemed actors like Henry Fonda and James Stewart. The films we created were either pulsating with raw action or delving deeply into intricate morals.

Decades on, very few of John Wayne’s films have waned in their impact and capacity to ignite debates. His iconic roles continue to be revered today, demonstrating that the following ten Westerns from his repertoire are as potent as ever. Let’s delve into an extensive (yet not exhaustive) list of John Wayne’s most impactful and lasting Western movies, timeless classics in the genre.

10 Stagecoach (1939)

Stagecoach

A Classic That Stood the Test of Time

The Stagecoach film was remarkably progressive by depicting Wayne in a captivating role years before he became synonymous with the Western genre. This classic movie is admired for rejuvenating the genre, a feat largely attributed to John Ford’s exceptional directing skills that breathed life into the untamed frontier. The striking visuals, exhilarating action sequences, and intricate character development create an adventure that remains compelling even now. Wayne’s portrayal of a vengeful outlaw is both authentic and appealing, making it a must-see experience.

9 True Grit (1969)

In the later stages of his professional journey, Henry Hathaway’s “True Grit” takes you back to a rough and lawless Arkansas frontier town. It narrates the tale of Mattie Ross, a resolute 14-year-old farm girl who tragically witnesses the brutal murder of her father at the hands of Tom Chaney, a ruthless hired hand. With unwavering resolve to bring Chaney to justice for his crimes, Mattie enlists the aid of the toughest U.S. Marshal available, the hard-drinking Rooster Cogburn. Joining them on their pursuit is a Texas Ranger named La Boeuf, who has been tracking Chaney in connection with another murder.

A Late-Period Gem Starring John Wayne

Experiencing this gripping tale set amidst perilous Wild West terrain is like living a story destined for the annals of history. True Grit, undeniably, earns its place among Western enthusiasts’ favorites by masterfully blending intense action, somber wit, and understated warmth.

In the movie, Wayne delivers an impressive performance as the powerful Cogburn, with his chemistry with Kim Darby’s Mattie Ross being one of its standout aspects. Hathaway’s tight direction, coupled with enduring themes such as bravery and atonement, make it a powerful and deserving addition to Wayne’s esteemed body of work.

8 The Shootist (1976)

10 Best John Wayne Westerns That Still Hold Up10 Best John Wayne Westerns That Still Hold Up10 Best John Wayne Westerns That Still Hold Up

The last movie starring Wayne was titled “The Shootist“. Directed by Don Siegel, this film was adapted from Glendon Swarthout’s novel with the same title. Set in 1901, it revolves around the story of John Bernard Books, a renowned gunfighter. After receiving a terminal cancer diagnosis and realizing his time is limited, Books seeks a tranquil location to spend his final days with grace. However, news of his arrival stirs tension, leading someone from his past to surface with an intent for revenge.

Delivers a Somber Farewell to an Icon

In “The Shootist,” John Wayne delivered a deeply emotional farewell performance. He portrayed a determined yet unyielding character grappling with his approaching death, yet harboring no remorse for the lives he had taken as they all deserved it. Siegel’s direction masterfully depicts the deterioration of the frontier and the legacy of Books, while also exploring themes of masculinity and mortality. “The Shootist” is not just a demonstration of Wayne’s remarkable acting skills, but it also carries great importance within the Western genre.

7 The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1962)

10 Best John Wayne Westerns That Still Hold Up10 Best John Wayne Westerns That Still Hold Up10 Best John Wayne Westerns That Still Hold Up

In “The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance,” James Stewart and John Wayne appear together in a memorable Western, based on a short story by Dorothy M. Johnson. Stewart portrays U.S. Senator Ransom Stoddard, who journeys back to the small frontier town of Shinbone for the funeral of an old acquaintance, Tom Doniphon (played by Wayne). When inquired about his path to success, Stoddard reveals the real tale behind the killing of the notorious bandit Liberty Valance, unveiling a more intricate story than previously assumed.

Deconstructs a Legend at a Leisurely Pace

Under the guidance of director John Ford, The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance offers a clever and insightful challenge to traditional Western storytelling. This film uncovers historical myths, delves into the complexities of violence, politics, and the foundation of legends. Although Stewart’s character takes center stage, it is Wayne’s Doniphon who plays a crucial role in this retrospective tale. Filled with humor, irony, and intrigue, the movie maintains a timeless ambiance that remains surprisingly relevant today.

6 Fort Apache (1948)

10 Best John Wayne Westerns That Still Hold Up10 Best John Wayne Westerns That Still Hold Up10 Best John Wayne Westerns That Still Hold Up

At Fort Apache, we find Lt. Col. Owen Thursday, who aspires to establish his authority and win favor among the people of the Apache region. Upon setting foot in the West, he looks down upon the locals, displaying a hostile attitude towards the Native Americans. This behavior catches the eye of Captain Kirby York, the unspoken leader of the post. As they challenge Thursday’s harsh tactics and his connections with local settlers, Captain York and his troops find themselves at odds with Thursday, who is ready to fight and disregard the potential repercussions of his actions.

A Story About Clashing Cultures

In the movie “Fort Apache,” director John Ford delves more profoundly into the topic of Western expansion, exploring its consequences such as cultural conflicts and effects on Native American communities. The film features well-rounded characters that ring true to life, while the grand landscapes serve as an evocative backdrop for the story.

In a more casual and straightforward manner: Wayne delivers a strong performance as Captain York, a character who strives for understanding amidst contrasting beliefs with Henry Fonda’s character, Thursday. The film itself is powerful and emotionally charged, leaving a lasting impact as a timeless classic.

5 She Wore a Yellow Ribbon (1949)

10 Best John Wayne Westerns That Still Hold Up10 Best John Wayne Westerns That Still Hold Up10 Best John Wayne Westerns That Still Hold Up

The Yellow Ribbon is the second installment in John Ford’s Cavalry Trilogy, and it is proceeded by Rio Grande. In this film, John Wayne portrays Cavalry Captain Nathan Brittles, who embarks on his final patrol to maintain peace among the volatile Cheyenne and Arapaho frontier before his impending retirement. He continues his service alongside his long-time friend and subordinate. However, when a superior orders him to escort two women to safety, the looming danger of an upcoming conflict intensifies.

An Underrated Masterpiece

As a movie enthusiast, I must say that John Ford masterfully directed this deeply nuanced and multi-layered cinematic masterpiece, leaving an indelible mark on its audience. With John Wayne at the helm as our grizzled, steadfast Captain, the narrative unfolded with both finesse and emotional resonance, much like the untamed landscapes it portrayed. The film boasts striking imagery of the frontier and a remarkable ensemble cast that truly brought the supporting characters to life. Delving into themes of honor and duty, this movie struck a chord with viewers from all corners of the globe.

In my opinion, while John Ford’s masterpiece, “She Wears a Yellow Ribbon,” often gets overshadowed by other Westerns of his, such as the iconic “The Sands of Iwo Jima,” it showcases John Wayne at his finest and incomparable.

4 The Horse Soldiers (1959)

10 Best John Wayne Westerns That Still Hold Up10 Best John Wayne Westerns That Still Hold Up10 Best John Wayne Westerns That Still Hold Up

Set against the backdrop of the American Civil War in 1863, The Horse Soldiers is inspired by a historical fiction novel by Harold Sinclair. The narrative unfolds as we follow Colonel John Marlowe, tasked with a clandestine operation far beyond Union territories. He gathers a small but determined cavalry unit and together they brave numerous dangers in the treacherous landscape. However, their most formidable obstacle comes from within their ranks: Major Henry Kendall, the regiment’s physician, and Miss Hannah Hunter, a charming Southern lady whose allegiance could potentially derail Marlowe’s mission.

One of John Ford’s Underrated Westerns

Originally panned by critics as “uninspired,” The Horse Soldiers eventually resonated with audiences and established itself as a notable Western in John Wayne’s extensive filmography. As is characteristic under Ford’s skillful guidance, the movie offers fresh insights into the Civil War and captures a poignant portrait of a nation on the brink of self-destruction—a mix of heart-wrenching and lingering emotions. The action scenes feel authentically gritty, and the tension between characters runs deep. Ultimately, the film stands as a testament to Ford’s talent for breathing new life into conventional stories.

3 Rio Bravo (1959)

In one of their most notable partnerships, Rio Bravo features Howard Hawks and John Wayne. Here, Wayne portrays John T. Chance, a small-town sheriff who apprehends the volatile rancher Joe Burdette for murder. When word reaches Nathan Burdette, the influential patriarch of the Burdette ranching dynasty, he insists on his brother’s release, vowing to employ any means necessary to free him. With the odds stacked against him and hostilities escalating, Chance remains resolute in his efforts to safeguard the town.

Builds Tension in a Controlled Manner

In a skillful blend of gripping tension and subtle wit, the film Rio Bravo establishes an exemplary benchmark for rugged Westerns. It moves at a leisurely pace yet makes a lasting impression. John Wayne delivers a commanding performance, and he is ably backed by the charming company of Dean Martin, Ricky Nelson, Walter Brennan, and Angie Dickinson. Hawks’ narrative keeps viewers captivated from start to finish, culminating in an enjoyable climax. Essentially, it embodies the quintessential Western, offering entertainment without compromising its intelligence.

2 The Quiet Man (1952)

10 Best John Wayne Westerns That Still Hold Up10 Best John Wayne Westerns That Still Hold Up10 Best John Wayne Westerns That Still Hold Up

In his retirement, former American boxer Sean Thorton, originally from Ireland’s town of Innisfree, decides to retrieve his inherited property—a humble plot of land. Upon his arrival, he crosses paths with spirited and passionate local woman, Mary Kate Danaher. A romantic connection sparks between them, but tensions rise when her overprotective brother Will, who had previously lost a bidding war to Thorton, becomes hostile. This sibling rivalry threatens Sean’s budding relationship with Mary Kate.

A Swoon-Worthy and Delightful Turn

In an alternate phrasing: John Ford earned his fourth Academy Award for Best Director due to his enchanting direction and representation of the lush Irish countryside, creating a cinematic experience that was both rich and verdant. The film The Quiet Man, classified as a romantic Western, provides fans with an opportunity to witness a more light-hearted and sensitive aspect of John Wayne’s acting prowess. His affection for Mary Kate, portrayed by Maureen O’Hara, was both poignant and comical in nature. The offbeat characters and underlying tension served to underscore the profound significance of love, ultimately highlighting its power to conquer all obstacles.

1 The Searchers (1956)

1868 finds Ethan Edwards back in Texas following an eight-year absence, spent fighting in both the American Civil War and the Second Franco-Mexican War. Upon his return, he learns that his hometown has been attacked by the Comanches, resulting in the death or kidnapping of his relatives. Determined to find his niece Debbie, who miraculously survived, Ethan teams up with his nephew Martin Pawley on a perilous journey through treacherous Comanche lands. Unbeknownst to them, they are about to confront unspeakable atrocities ahead.

Wayne’s Most Hypnotic Masterwork

Praised by critics as “outstanding” and “impressive,” “The Searchers” represents a pinnacle in the careers of both John Ford and John Wayne. This film offers a profound exploration of survival and the cost of obsession, set against the desolate and unyielding landscape of the American West.

In a remarkable display of acting prowess, Wayne Edwards shone exceptionally in what is arguably his greatest performance to date. Roger Ebert hailed the character as one of the most captivating roles that Ford and Wayne ever brought to life, going so far as to label the movie a must-watch due to its skillfully crafted, moving, and patient narrative.

Read More

2024-09-17 02:32