As a cinephile with over three decades of movie-watching under my belt, I can confidently say that these films are truly exceptional masterpieces. Each one offers a unique perspective on crime and mystery, drawing us into intricate narratives that keep us guessing till the very end.
While the appeal of horror films is unquestionable, thrillers with a good mystery are great competition. Not violent or scary enough to be horror, these mystery thrillers always play with viewers’ psyches and make us lose a night’s sleep or two. In some cases, viewers will try to solve the cases along with the movie and try to come up with the identity of the killer, or guess if the film will even have a conventional ending (they often don’t).
Despite being genre films and not commonly praised by global film critics, mystery thrillers have often been unfairly judged due to the type of experience they offer. Often criticized by movie reviewers, these films are typically associated with lower quality productions. However, there are exceptions to this rule as shown in the following list: 10 mystery thrillers that boast exceptionally high scores from both critics and audiences on Rotten Tomatoes.
10 The Third Man (1949)
99% on the Tomatometer – 93% on the Popcornmeter
In “The Third Man”, the character Holly Martins, a writer of pulp novels, journeys from America to Vienna upon hearing about the death of his old friend, Harry, under suspicious circumstances. Despite the authorities claiming it was an accident, Martins senses foul play and notices telltale signs of murder. As he and Harry’s girlfriend, Anna, delve deeper into the investigation, they uncover evidence suggesting they might be caught up in a complex web of deceit.
The timeless film noir masterpiece directed by Carol Reed, often hailed as one of the greatest British films ever produced, showcases cinematography that earned an Academy Award and bears similarities to German expressionism. Memorable moments from this movie are primarily associated with its distinctive shots, such as the one featuring a man standing in a tunnel, which stands out as particularly iconic. Although it wasn’t widely praised during its release, it has since become a cornerstone of the film noir genre.
9 Shadow of a Doubt (1943)
100% on the Tomatometer – 89% on the Popcornmeter
Under the Suspicion of Guilt is a tale about Charlie Newton, a teenage girl who feels an unusual bond with her uncle Charlie. She invites him over, and upon his arrival, the family is charmed by his presence. However, as events unfold, young Charlie begins to suspect that her seemingly perfect uncle might not be as virtuous as he seems, but rather a potential serial killer that the police are in pursuit of.
1943 saw Alfred Hitchcock release his iconic black-and-white noir mystery thriller, a standout work that might just be the pinnacle of his early career. The character of Uncle Charlie is carefully crafted to arouse doubt and suspicion, but we see him through the sharp eyes of Charlie, a teenage observer who’s clever enough to catch what others miss. If you find the story reminiscent of Park Chan-wook’s film Stoker, your observation is spot on, as Shadow of a Doubt has influenced modern horror thrillers significantly.
8 The Guilty (2018)
98% on the Tomatometer – 87% on the Popcornmeter
As a movie critic, I found myself captivated by the gripping tale of “The Guilty,” where I step into the shoes of Asger, a Copenhagen-based police officer who, following a tragic accident that claimed a life, now handles emergency calls. The eve before his hearing looms, but an enigmatic call from Iben, a woman speaking in riddles, disrupts his routine. Piecing together fragments of information, it becomes evident to Asger that Iben has fallen victim to kidnapping. However, confined to a desk, his investigative tools are strikingly minimal, making this mission all the more challenging.
Hailing directly from Denmark is an engaging thriller that cuts straight to the chase. Despite being primarily set in one location, the captivating acting of Jakob Cedergren as Asger, coupled with the writing duo Gustav Möller and Emil Nygaard Albertsen, keeps you on tenterhooks. Since its debut, this film has received critical acclaim, and in 2021, an American remake was released, directed by Antoine Fuqua and featuring Jake Gyllenhaal.
7 Blue Ruin (2013)
96% on the Tomatometer – 79% on the Popcornmeter
Blue Ruin follows the tale of drifter Dwight Evans, who makes his home in a car. A shocking revelation – the man who cold-bloodedly murdered Dwight’s parents is soon to be freed from prison. Seeking retribution and closure, Dwight embarks on a quest for revenge. However, as he delves deeper into the mystery surrounding his parents’ murder, he encounters unexpected challenges.
Under the direction of Jeremy Saulnier from Rebel Ridge, on a budget under half a million dollars, the movie “Blue Ruin” stands as a contemporary masterpiece of revenge. Featuring Macon Blair in a reliable performance, this film portrays a chilling descent into the mindset of an unbalanced individual driven by vengeance, disregarding reason. The character Dwight finds himself paying a heavy toll due to his lack of professional expertise.
6 Chinatown (1974)
98% on the Tomatometer – 93% on the Popcornmeter
As a passionate cinephile, I found myself engrossed in the intricate web of secrets revealed in “Chinatown.” Initially, I was hired to investigate Hollis Mulwray, a towering figure in society, on behalf of someone claiming to be his wife. However, upon Mulwray’s untimely demise and my discovery that I had been working for an imposter, I felt compelled to delve further. My investigation led me down a rabbit hole where I uncovered a potential corruption scheme implicating Mulwray’s business partner and the enigmatic Evelyn. The truth was far more complex than anything I could have imagined.
1974 saw Roman Polanski’s enigmatic film, often hailed as one of the greatest movies ever made, captivating both viewers and critics. The following year, it garnered an impressive 11 Academy Award nominations and emerged victorious in the category of Best Original Screenplay. Jack Nicholson, portraying Jake Gittes, skillfully navigates a complex plot towards a poignant ending that will undoubtedly linger in your thoughts after watching Chinatown.
5 Knives Out (2019)
97% on the Tomatometer – 97% on the Popcornmeter
Knives Out
Rian Johnson’s brilliant blend of genres demonstrated his narrative skills, following the controversy surrounding his take on a “Star Wars” sequel, “The Last Jedi.” With a large cast under his direction, Johnson crafted a well-structured plot with a humorous and captivating vibe, making “Knives Out” one of the most praised films of the year by many film critics. The screenplay earned a nomination for an Academy Award in the Best Original Screenplay category.
4 Rear Window (1954)
98% on the Tomatometer – 95% on the Popcornmeter
Through the Lens
There’s a distinct reason why Hitchcock stands out as the sole director appearing on this list twice: his films artfully captivate inquisitive minds while meticulously unfolding intriguing mysteries. Much like Rear Window, his work demonstrates a mastery of building suspense, maintaining it until reaching a nail-biting climax that leaves viewers breathless for several minutes. This film is often hailed as one of the best movies ever produced.
3 L.A. Confidential (1997)
99% on the Tomatometer – 94% on the Popcornmeter
In the movie “L.A. Confidential,” directed by Curtis Hanson based on James Ellroy’s novel, viewers journey back to 1950s Los Angeles – a time when Hollywood was at its most glamorous, yet beneath its shiny surface lay a city teeming with crime and corruption. Three detectives, each with their unique approaches to justice, team up to tackle a string of crimes that could implicate the city’s elite.
1997 saw the release of the critically acclaimed film “L.A. Confidential,” which went on to win two Academy Awards despite being overshadowed by James Cameron’s “Titanic” that year. Over time, this mystery thriller has garnered the recognition it deserved, often hailed as one of the best films ever made by critics. The portrayal of 1950s Hollywood and exceptional acting by Guy Pearce, Kim Basinger, and Russell Crowe make it a must-watch, as you’ll agree that these critics were spot on with their glowing reviews on Rotten Tomatoes.
2 The Vanishing (1988)
96% on the Tomatometer – 88% on the Popcornmeter
The Vanishing – A Mysterious Disappearance
Ever since it debuted, this movie has risen to the top of its genre, offering a raw, unyielding exploration of nihilism that didn’t soften the seemingly predestined outcome. The tension in the latter half, where audiences can almost predict the ending, is maintained by our persistent hope for Rex getting justice. However, when the puzzle is finally unraveled, the world appears a bit more dismal than before.
1 Memories of Murder (2003)
95% on the Tomatometer – 92% on the Popcornmeter
The film Memories of Murder transports us to 1980s South Korea, a nation grappling with political unrest. A spate of murders terrorizes the city of Hwaseong, leaving detectives Park Doo-man and Seo Tae-yoon with the challenging task of unmasking an elusive serial killer whose methods leave behind cryptic clues that are not straightforward to interpret.
Bong Joon-ho’s mystery thriller, “Memories of Murder,” offers a gripping exploration within the genre, comparable to some of the most outstanding serial killer films in history. It presents viewers with a chilling odyssey as they delve into a storyline involving compelling characters grappling with unsolved crimes without any semblance of hope. This haunting film is etched deeply in the minds of many and is often recognized as one of the finest productions from the 21st century, by critics such as Sight & Sound and CinemaScope.
Read More
Sorry. No data so far.
2024-10-18 02:02