10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone

10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone

As a connoisseur of Spaghetti Westerns, having spent countless hours watching the dusty plains and gritty characters come to life, I must say that this list truly encapsulates the essence of the genre. From the brooding silences of “The Great Silence” to the playful antics of “A Pistol for Ringo”, these films offer a unique blend of action, humor, and tragedy that is unparalleled in any other film genre.


When you think of Spaghetti Westerns, the one name that immediately stands out among the rest is Sergio Leone. The Italian filmmaker single-handedly established and defined the gritty subgenre in the 1960s with his Dollars Trilogy starring Clint Eastwood. From iconic, close-up, gunslinging shots to the sweeping, atmospheric scores, Leone’s films had a certain charm and appeal, and they left an indelible mark on cinema.

Although Leone is undoubtedly the reigning monarch in the genre of Spaghetti Westerns, it’s important to remember that he wasn’t the sole creator during this golden era. A plethora of captivating films were produced that offer equal measures of entertainment, visual grandeur, and edge-of-your-seat suspense. These movies don’t just embody the fundamental aspects of the genre such as morally complex protagonists, lawless frontier towns, and unexpected bursts of violence, but also infuse them with their distinctive perspectives. Here, we present a compilation of 10 exceptional Spaghetti Westerns directed by filmmakers other than the legendary Sergio Leone.

10 ‘Face to Face’ (1967)

10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone

In the second part of Sergio Sollima’s trilogy of Western films, titled “Face to Face“, we follow the life of Brad Fletcher, a humble history professor from Boston University, who decides to retire and relocate to the American West to recuperate from tuberculosis. Once there, he finds himself embroiled with the merciless outlaw, Solomon “Beauregard” Bennet. Not long after, Fletcher undergoes a dramatic change, turning into a fierce and unyielding figure himself.

A Twisted Tale of Redemption

Face to Face explores the concept that an individual’s character and moral compass are shaped by their surroundings. It blends the traditional elements of Spaghetti Westerns with intricate morality and deep psychology, resulting in a story centered around opportunities for change and atonement. To complement Sollima’s direction, stellar performances from Gian Maria Volonté as Fletcher and Tomás Milián as Beauregard are showcased, along with a captivating score composed by Bruno Nicolai and Ennio Morricone.

9 ‘Day of Anger’ (1967)

10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone

The story titled Day of Anger unfolds in the gritty and anarchic setting of Clifton, a town shrouded in dust. It revolves around a young man named Scott Mary, who finds himself trapped in a monotonous existence as a disrespected street sweeper. However, his life takes an unexpected turn when a mysterious gunfighter, Frank Talby, arrives in town and befriends him. He tutors Scott in the art of shooting and the ethics of the Wild West, transforming him into a formidable marksman himself.

A Spaghetti Western Coming-of-Age Story

Under the guidance of renowned director Tonino Valerii, the movie titled “Day of Anger” initially appears as a conventional Western. However, it gradually evolves into a tense confrontation that challenges notions of loyalty and justice within the American frontier. This genre-blending film can be considered a unique masterpiece. Lee Van Cleef portrays Talby, an enigmatic and powerful character, while Giuliano Gemma plays Scott, whose transformation from an underdog to a hero is captivating. In essence, it’s a significant and lasting film that stands apart from the works of Sergio Leone.

8 ‘Keoma’ (1976)

10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone

Despite coming after the peak of the Spaghetti Western trend, Keoma stands out as one of the genre’s finest films. The narrative revolves around Keoma, the half-Native American protagonist, who returns to his hometown following the Civil War. He soon learns that his town is under the oppressive rule of Caldwell and that his brothers, with whom he has a strained relationship, are among Caldwell’s followers. Driven by a desire to liberate them all, Keoma engages in a series of dramatic confrontations against the oppressive forces.

Brooding and Poetic Twist on Revenge

Under the meticulous guidance of director Enzo G. Castellari, the film Keoma takes the common theme of revenge in spaghetti westerns and transforms it into a profound and emotional examination of family, pain, and aggression. The film’s evocative atmosphere and philosophical undertones are crucial to its success, but it is Franco Nero’s mesmerizing portrayal as the protagonist Keoma that critics rave about as “endlessly entertaining.

7 ‘My Name Is Nobody’ (1973)

10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone

Titled “My Name is Nobody,” this international production featuring Italian, French, and German collaborators, presents a comical take on the waning days of the Old West. The story revolves around Jack Beauregard, an accomplished gunslinger contemplating retiring from his dangerous profession and relocating to Europe. However, his peaceful retirement plans are thwarted by Nobody, a greenhorn gunfighter who adores Jack and yearns to witness his prowess in action and reclaim glory by battling a gang of 150 outlaws single-handedly.

Hilarious and Playful Tribute to Westerns

Tonino Valerii launched his directing journey working under Sergio Leone, and he brought the movie “My Name is Nobody” to life from his own concept. This film showcases a standout performance by Terence Hill as the witty and quirky Nobody, who contrasts beautifully with Henry Fonda’s grizzled portrayal of Jack. The film boasted a lighthearted atmosphere, marking a shift from typical storytelling patterns, and as the body count rose, so did the humor and enjoyment in this timeless classic.

6 ‘A Bullet for the General’ (1966)

10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone

Set amidst the tumultuous Mexican Revolution, A Bullet for the General introduces us to El Chuncho (Gian Maria Volonté), a shadowy outlaw with a murky sense of right and wrong and an unquenchable lust for wealth. He’s known for pilfering weapons from trains, channeling them to the rebellious forces. One day, he encounters Bill Tate, an American who infiltrates his gang while concealing ulterior motives, yet finds himself relying on Chuncho’s wisdom throughout their shared journey.

Thrives on its Revolutionary Themes

As I watch this Zapata Western unfold, the atmosphere becomes increasingly tense as friendships are strained and loyalties are put to the test, culminating in a pivotal confrontation that reveals each character’s underlying motives. What sets this film apart is its transformation of the traditional Western genre into a raw and politically charged portrayal of the Mexican Revolution. Its authenticity, coupled with gripping action sequences and an evocative score by Luis Bacalov, has garnered widespread acclaim and enduring appeal.

5 ‘Django’ (1966)

As a passionate admirer, I can’t help but associate the name “Django” with the gritty world of Spaghetti Westerns, evoking the picture of a solitary, gun-toting outlaw pushing a coffin along, poised to mete out his unique brand of retribution against any who dare challenge him. The 1966 masterpiece, under the guidance of Sergio Corbucci, paints a vivid portrait of our protagonist in a lawless frontier town, torn between two rival factions – a band of Mexican revolutionaries and a malicious gang reminiscent of the Ku Klux Klan, led by Major Jackson.

The Quintessential Spaghetti Western Classic

In contrast to Sergio Leone establishing and dominating the genre, Corbucci capitalized on and competed with the popularity of his films through “Django”. This movie is now a significant part of the Spaghetti Western genre due to Corbucci’s raw and unyielding approach. The powerful portrayal of Franco Nero in the leading role, as he navigates racial conflicts and political turmoil, results in intense action sequences, thought-provoking social commentary, and iconic one-liners.

4 ‘The Mercenary’ (1968)

Amidst the tumultuous landscape of Mexico’s revolutionary battles, “The Mercenary” presents an extraordinary alliance and their intense bond plunged into intense action. On one side, we have Sergei Kowalski, a Polish mercenary, and on the opposite end, Paco Roman, a peasant transformed into a revolutionary, eager to engage in combat and master the art of warfare. However, Paco’s desire for wealth and power clashes with Kowalski’s plans, leading to a thrilling confrontation.

Features a Dynamic Duo

Under the skillful guidance of Sergio Corbucci, the film The Mercenary breaks free from all preconceived notions. It combines the finest aspects of its genre with a delightful fusion of humor and action. The unexpectedly endearing partnership between Franco Nero’s character Kowalski, who carries a cynical edge, and Tony Musante’s character Paco, who embodies idealism, adds layers of depth and vitality to the movie. Moreover, Ennio Morricone’s iconic music score lends an emotional resonance to the narrative.​​​​​​​

3 ‘Death Rides a Horse’ (1967)

10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone

Under the Scorching Sun Rides a Vengeance Story: Bill Meceita endures the horrific slaying of his family at the hands of a ruthless quartet. Though he carries the physical scars and emotional wounds, he spends fifteen years meticulously preparing himself into an expert marksman. His path crosses with Ryan, a shadowy figure nursing a similar grudge against the killers. Together, they embark on a relentless pursuit to bring the outlaws to justice.

A Revenge Western Fueled by Tragedy

In Spaghetti Westerns, gloomy and violent stories are commonplace. However, Director Giulio Petroni takes it a step further in Death Rides a Horse. Instead of just serving up revenge tales, he delves deeper into the characters’ psyches, making them grapple not only with their personal desire for vengeance but also the deep-seated trauma that has molded their entire existence. To top it off, the film offers exhilarating action scenes and an intriguing dynamic between John Philip Law and Lee Van Cleef, which adds to its appeal.

2 ‘A Pistol for Ringo’ (1965)

As a devoted cinephile, let me tell you about a film that truly captured my attention: “A Pistol for Ringo,” masterfully penned and orchestrated by Duccio Tessari. This captivating production is a collaborative effort between Italian and Spanish cinematic talents. The story revolves around the intriguing character of Ringo, a cunning gunslinger who unwittingly gets entangled in the tumultuous affairs of a small town overrun by a ruthless gang of outlaws.

Far From the More Brooding Entries in the Genre

The lively tempo and whimsical style of the film “A Pistol for Ringo” solidify its place as a must-see among the greatest Spaghetti Westerns ever made. It’s widely admired for its gripping narrative and Giuliano Gemma’s charmingly rebellious portrayal of the title character. Despite adhering to traditional elements like charm and gunplay action, the film also serves up a healthy serving of humor, which is what gives it a unique and enduring appeal.

1 ‘The Great Silence’ (1968)

10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone10 Best Spaghetti Westerns Not Directed by Sergio Leone

The last Spaghetti Western on the roster, helmed and jointly penned by Sergio Corbucci, is titled “The Great Silence“. This film is set in the harsh, snow-covered vistas of Utah. It narrates the tale of a mute gunslinger called Silence who embarks on a quest for vengeance against a band of bounty hunters responsible for his parents’ demise. While silently but relentlessly pursuing them, he is also recruited by Pauline to avenge her slain spouse.

A Bleak and Unflinching Look Into the West

The Great Silence is admired largely due to its somber mood and stark, snowy landscapes, and it significantly differs from the lively, grandiose films within its genre. Instead, it presents a deadly contest of intellect and morality, compelling viewers to delve into the grim storyline. Ennio Morricone’s powerful and melancholic soundtrack, combined with Jean-Louis Trintignant and Klaus Kinski’s distinctive acting, create the essence of the genre.

Read More

Sorry. No data so far.

2024-11-20 02:02