10 Best TV Shows Like American Primeval You Need To Watch Next

Beginning in January 2025, the Netflix action-drama titled “American Primeval” marks a new wave of high-quality Westerns on TV, influenced by real-life events. Shows like “Lawmen: Bass Reeves,” which only scrapes the surface of the story, or the Epix series “Billy the Kid,” are examples of this trend in streaming networks rediscovering the intense drama within this genre. Directed by Peter Berg, who has worked on big-screen productions like “Friday Night Lights,” “American Primeval” focuses on the less famous 19th-century conflict called the Utah War.

Often overshadowed by the subsequent American Civil War, the Utah War, also known as the Mormon Rebellion or Mormon War, lasted for over a year from May 1857. This conflict, rooted in cultural differences, began when the federal government aimed to exert greater control over a region heavily influenced by the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, which was considered controversial. The government’s intent was to dismantle their self-governance and restrict many of their religious practices, including polygamy. In response, Mormon militias engaged in fierce battles with federal troops, resulting in over 150 casualties.

In “American Primeval,” we delve into a tale of two factions battling for their convictions, examining the price of liberty and probing the boundaries of authority’s reach. This gripping series is set in an era marked by chaos, where the government grappled with keeping order over its lands. It offers a thrilling Western adventure, deep-seated family dynamics, and numerous ethical debates. If you’re intrigued already, don’t pass up these 10 shows similar to “American Primeval” that you should catch next!

1883

If you’re new to “American Primeval” and Taylor Sheridan’s series, you might want to start with “1883”, which is essentially a miniseries within the larger context. Featuring country music icons Tim McGraw and Faith Hill as real-life spouses, “1883” serves as a prequel to the popular show “Yellowstone”. While it’s connected, you can still fully appreciate “1883” independently. In fact, some viewers find it even more captivating when watched before the Kevin Costner-led “Yellowstone”.

Much like “American Primeval,” the show is set in an era where individuals had the opportunity to shape their own destinies with just a horse and a backpack. Characters McGraw and Hill embody James and Margaret Dutton, while Isabel May portrays their determined teenage daughter Elsa. Alongside young John Dutton (Audie Rick), this family embarks on a wagon train journey alongside inexperienced European settlers, crossing the plains in search of a new home. They are guided by an old Union veteran named Shea Brennan (Sam Elliott) and a Pinkerton agent called Thomas (LaMonica Garrett).

Along the way, the group is forced to deal with all manner of catastrophes, from daring bandit raids to attacks by vengeful tribes of Lakota to devastating storms and the horrors of disease. In a time when merely crossing a river could lead to a massacre, nothing is certain, and “1883” hammers home the precarious nature of the untamed West. Though it didn’t win any major awards, the series may be the best Western of the last decade, even if it left plenty of unanswered questions for audiences to ponder.

Yellowstone

Despite being the sole series on this list set in the present, you might find an unexpected similarity between the narrative of “Yellowstone” and the 19th-century action depicted in “American Primeval”. In a sense, these two shows could be seen as kindred spirits: “Yellowstone” tells the story of the Dutton family, descendants from the “1883” line, with John Dutton III (Kevin Costner) at the helm. The Duttons have evolved into a formidable dynasty, owners of a vast Montana ranch nestled amidst mountains and bordered by federal land and the Broken Rock Indian Reservation.

Despite possessing significant power in their region, the Duttons face threats from various directions, much like the characters in “Primeval” confront diverse challenges. They ward off attacks from neighboring Native American tribes, yet they also grapple with aggressions from corporate conglomerates and influential politicians who covet their ancestral land. However, John Dutton’s greatest hurdles sometimes originate within his own family, as his lawyer son Jaime (Wes Bentley), hard-nosed daughter Beth (Kelly Reilly), and rebellious son Kacey (Luke Grimes) don’t always agree on the ranch’s future course.

As a gaming enthusiast, I can’t help but feel drawn to the captivating world of “Yellowstone”. It’s more than just a crime drama, it’s a blend of genres that takes you on an exhilarating journey, filled with action, suspense, and shocking plot twists. Set in modern times, this series doesn’t shy away from the rugged charm of cowboys riding rough, gunfighters shooting sharp, and delivering thought-provoking social commentary. During its impressive five-season run, it was a television sensation, sparking a franchise with numerous spin-offs that could potentially provide answers to the many intriguing plot threads left unresolved.

Hell on Wheels

From 2011 to 2016, no Western TV show surpassed “Hell on Wheels” in quality. The title symbolizes the temporary settlements that accompany railway construction, and the series chronicles one of the most significant railway projects in U.S. history: the development of the first transcontinental railroad during the 1860s. Set after the American Civil War, the narrative revolves around Cullen Bohannon (played by Anson Mount), a former Confederate colonel who is tasked with managing railway construction crews for the Union Pacific Railroad as they advance westward.

Working with immigrants and ex-slaves, the former Confederate soldier finds himself in a challenging predicament, concealing his own buried truths. However, Bohannon discovers an unexpected ally in Elam Ferguson (Common), a freed man who understands that the abolition of slavery does not equate to acceptance or genuine freedom. The two are compelled to labor for a real-life railroad tycoon, Thomas “Doc” Durant (Colm Meaney), a merciless entrepreneur more interested in his wealth than people’s wellbeing, who is ready to trample anyone obstructing him. They must endure the harshness of their job while battling opposition from both outside and within.

In “Hell on Wheels,” the main characters, including Bohannon and his teams, confront various challenges from Native American tribes, disgruntled Mormon settlers, and even the federal government itself. This gripping series, set during a turbulent period in history, provides a vivid portrayal of the escalating conflicts that early Western pioneers encountered as they journeyed westward. If you’re interested in watching a show that captures the tensions and struggles faced by these trailblazers, then “Hell on Wheels” is an excellent choice.

Deadwood

The book “American Primeval” delves into the numerous disputes and clashes occurring among disparate communities that migrated to the American West during the final period of unrestricted liberty. If you’re interested in understanding how such freedom-cherishing prospectors coexisted, take a look at “Deadwood,” an account of the notorious Wild West town often featured in Western legends. This town served as a melting pot for various individuals, from enthusiastic pioneers confident of striking it rich to the most depraved souls who ever traversed the prairies.

In the gritty, muddied town of Deadwood, I find myself standing face to face with Deputy U.S. Marshal Seth Bullock, a historical figure whose name may not ring a bell for many, but is revered by historians and Wild West enthusiasts alike. Arriving in this lawless town during the 1870s, Bullock crossed paths with legends like Wild Bill Hickok and Wyatt Earp, both of whom make an appearance in the series. However, my true nemesis seems to be Al Swearengen, a booze-swilling, hot-tempered, profane brute who runs the town’s brothel and appears to have his fingers in every pie imaginable.

The exceptional choice of casting was a standout feature of the show, with relatively unknown actor Olyphant delivering an outstanding, career-making performance, while McShane swiftly established himself as one of television’s top villains. Despite airing for just three seasons and 36 episodes, it concluded its narrative in 2019 with “Deadwood: The Movie.” Not only is it a must-watch series following “American Primeval,” but “Deadwood” could very well be the most iconic Western of the 21st Century.

Hatfields and McCoys

As a devoted admirer of cinematic greats in the Western genre, names like John Wayne and Clint Eastwood often come to mind. Yet, it’s Kevin Costner who has been subtly carving out an exceptional career in this field, with an array of memorable roles. Whether it’s the rugged landscapes of “Silverado” or the expansive vistas of “Horizon: An American Saga,” there’s a certain mystique about him, always seen through the brim of a cowboy hat. In 2012, he teamed up with the late Bill Paxton in the captivating historical miniseries, “Hatfields and McCoys.

Similar to how “American Primeval” delves into a localized conflict in the 19th-century Western territories, this three-part mini-series also focuses on a conflict – but rather than a cultural clash, it’s a prolonged feud between families, recounting one of the nation’s most lethal family disputes. This bitter enmity spanned generations, and history remains unclear about who ignited it initially. However, regardless of the instigator, the outcome was countless casualties on both sides. The conflict was spearheaded by characters portrayed by Kevin Costner as William Hatfield and Billy Bob Thornton as Randall McCoy. During the Civil War, these families fought on opposite fronts, and it appears they continued their war long after Reconstruction in their very own backyards.

As a devoted viewer, “Hatfields and McCoys” – a gripping three-part saga – makes an excellent choice for a marathon session following “American Primeval.” Kevin Costner and Billy Bob Thornton are joined by an impressive cast including Tom Berenger, Powers Boothe, Sarah Parish, and a young Boyd Holbrook. While it’s not aiming for strict historical precision, this mini-series delivers a gripping family drama set in a time where a minor slight could escalate into a deadly feud.

The Son

Set during the time period preceding “American Primeval,” the TV series “The Son” that debuted in 2017, was a high-quality drama that spanned over two seasons on AMC. Notably, this marked Pierce Brosnan’s return to a leading role in television since his days in the ’80s spy show “Remington Steele.” Interestingly, Brosnan had almost taken on the role of James Bond in 1985, but instead portrays wealthy Texas rancher Eli McCullough whose business is struggling in 1915.

As his fortune dwindles, the charismatic yet elusive character McCullough embarks on an endeavor to expand his ventures, delving into the thriving oil industry. In spite of his struggles, he harbors dreams of restoring his empire and recovering his lost wealth for the benefit of his two sons. However, it becomes evident that they might conceal some hidden truths. The main narrative of “The Son”, however, unfolds in the 1800s, as we witness a much younger McCullough (portrayed by Jacob Lofland) undergo one of the most harrowing experiences: Kidnapped by a hostile Comanche tribe, he is held captive for numerous years.

As the narrative progresses, we uncover more about McCullough’s backstory and how it molded his harsh, dogmatic perspective on life. While critics had differing opinions, the general consensus was that it was one of the superior Westerns in recent times. On the other hand, Brosnan delivers an outstanding performance, showcasing some of his best work throughout his distinguished career.

Broken Trail

During the mid-2000s, even though “Deadwood” on HBO was quite successful, there weren’t many Western shows on TV. However, one that was worth watching from this small selection is the 2006 miniseries, “Broken Trail,” which was based on a novel by Alan Geoffrion and he also wrote the script. This series was directed by Walter Hill, who has had a long career in screenwriting for movies like “48 Hrs” and directing the 1995 Western starring Jeff Bridges, “Wild Bill.

In the movie “Broken Trail,” we’re introduced to Prentice Ritter, played by Robert Duvall, as he endeavors to reconcile with his long-lost nephew, Tom Harte (Thomas Haden Church), following the demise of their estranged mother. However, their reunion takes an unexpected turn when they set off on a cattle drive heading towards Wyoming. During this journey, they stumble upon a disquieting truth: a former military captain named Billy Fender is involved in the illegal trade of women for sexual exploitation. Upon freeing some of these women, Prentice and Tom become marked targets for retribution by the ruthless gang who are determined to reclaim their captives.

This Western tale stands out for its clear-cut morality, offering an enjoyable watch with a well-crafted narrative and intense drama. Instead of the usual gray areas, you’ll find two noble cowboys battling truly detestable villains who are far from relatable. Some might label it as a “White Savior” narrative, but regardless, it’s a compelling series that emphasizes the struggle for justice in a world where taking a stand could cost one dearly – much like “American Primeval.

Frontier

In other words, not all period pieces from our list share the same century as “American Primeval”. It’s essential to remember that not every tale about frontier life and conflict took place in the American West. A compelling narrative of borderland war can be found in the 2016 Netflix original drama “Frontier”, which is fittingly titled. This series features Jason Momoa, a popular character from DC, portraying Declan Harp, a warrior with both European and native ancestry.

The show ‘Frontier’ takes place during the late 1700s, in the vast wilderness of what is now known as the Great White North. At this time, the fur trade was booming, transforming a once untouched land into a thriving hub for fortune hunters. The series starts with the region largely under the control of the dominant Hudson Bay Company. However, lawless outlaws and rogue factions aim to exploit the riches through illicit means. The English trading organization has established its dominance but is frequently at odds with the native inhabitants, whose traditional way of life is being eroded by industrialization. Harp, a character with ancestors on both sides of this conflict, finds himself in the midst of these tensions.

Stepping into an era seldom highlighted in our textbooks, I find myself captivated by the series “Frontier.” This captivating show illuminates a historical conflict typically overlooked, offering a fresh perspective on the past. The thrilling action sequences, breathtaking visuals, and bold narrative make it resonate deeply with me, not just because of its Wild West vibe, but also due to its striking resemblance to “American Primeval.” It’s a tale about an individual standing strong, determined to safeguard his home from forces intent on demolishing it in the name of progress.

Barkskins

In a timeframe predating “Frontier,” there’s the 2020 limited series, “Barkskins,” which debuted as an original scripted drama on National Geographic. This show premiered during the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic, causing many other TV shows to be canceled. Unfortunately, “Barkskins” didn’t receive much acclaim, and it might be one of the most overlooked shows on this list. The story unfolds at the end of the 17th century, when French colonizers were just beginning to settle in what was then called “New France.

In my perspective, I’m deeply immersed in a captivating French Colonial drama that unfurls the story of a motley crew who embark on an adventurous journey to this uncharted territory, yearning for a brighter life. The men, driven by dreams of prosperity, opt to serve as indentured laborers, believing it will pave their way towards land ownership one day. On the other hand, the women aspire to find companionship amidst the sea of eligible bachelors. Regrettably, their aspirations are met with a stark reality that belies the glimmering facade of a better life. The hardships they face include conflicts with native populations, and even their own governments renege on their empty promises.

In a nutshell, “Barkskins” is a gritty, intense drama with David Thewlis and Marcia Gay Harden as the main faces, although many other cast members may be unfamiliar. Despite this, the series doesn’t compromise on quality, offering stunning visuals, top-notch acting, even if some of the narrative feels familiar.

Into the Wild Frontier

If you’re a fan of TV characters from the Wild West and crave intense Western storylines, but don’t have extensive knowledge about 19th-century American history, then this show is perfect for you! “Into the Wild Frontier” is a four-season documentary drama that premiered on the lesser-known network INSP in 2022. The series combines documentary-style discussions with film-like reenactments of actual historical events, offering expert analysis throughout and seamlessly switching between historians and dramatizations in a way that leaves you eager for more of both.

Instead of having a continuous narrative like many documentaries, “Into the Wild Frontier” is structured as a series of individual episodes. Each episode focuses on a real historical figure, often well-known pioneers or lawmen such as Lewis and Clark, Mason and Dixon, or Daniel Boone, but also delves into lesser-known characters like Kit Carson and Joe Meek. The series typically explores the deeds of these figures, including their confrontations with notorious outlaws they encountered along the way.

Over approximately 30 episodes, you’ll discover captivating tales about pioneers such as explorers, fur traders, cowboys, and mountain dwellers who played a crucial role in shaping this region. Blending elements of historical reflection with the excitement of a Western saga, “Into the Wild Frontier” offers an engaging blend of education and amusement for those fascinated by the history of the American West and the courageous individuals who considered it their playground.

2025-02-18 16:01