11 Best Psychological Thrillers on Prime Video

As a cinephile who has spent countless hours immersed in the dark recesses of movie theaters, I must say that both “The Silence of the Lambs” and “Get Out” have left indelible marks on my psyche. While they hail from different eras, they share a common thread – the ability to provoke thought, challenge perceptions, and leave audiences questioning the world around them.


Psychological thrillers have a rich tradition of causing shivers up viewers’ spines. They lead both the main characters and viewers beyond their ordinary, comfortable understanding of reality, taking us on exhilarating journeys where we uncover hidden mysteries and face frightening adversaries.

Why not delve into the gripping psychological thrillers that reside on Prime Video, a platform known for series such as The Legend of Vox Machina and The Boys? As we embrace the eerie atmosphere of autumn, there’s no better way to celebrate than by immersing yourself in some of the most critically acclaimed psychological thrillers that Prime Video has to offer!

11 Coherence (2013)

In James Ward Byrkit’s directorial debut, the science fiction and thriller titled “Coherence” unfolds. The story revolves around Emily (Emily Foxler), along with several of her friends who undergo unusual events after observing Miller’s Comet. An ordinary dinner party is held, inviting her boyfriend Kevin (Maury Sterling) and their acquaintances; however, things take a turn when Amir (Alex Manugian) brings Kevin’s former girlfriend Laurie (Lauren Maher) to the gathering. The atmosphere becomes tense as the lights go out, and they discover that more people have shown up than expected.

The Scariness of Seeing Double Explored

In a dark, submerged setting, the characters and their individual apprehensions offer a spine-tingling glimpse into a common “what-if” situation that many ponder over. This film, reminiscent of The Twilight Zone, brilliantly emphasizes the unsettling nature of the unknown, particularly when it assumes familiar forms and figures. The erosion of basic trust and the scrutiny of supposed allies intensify the suspense, culminating in a peculiar yet captivating thriller that compels its characters to grapple with their own existence, contrasting it with an illusion that seems more alluring.

10 A Simple Favor (2018)

The movie titled “A Simple Favor” offers a peek into the seemingly tranquil lives of moms residing in Connecticut. The life of Stephanie (played by Anna Kendrick), who leads a fairly ordinary existence, takes an unexpected turn when she encounters and befriends Emily Nelson (Blake Lively). They bond over drinks, laughter, and confidences. However, one fateful day, Emily disappears, triggering a frantic search spearheaded by Stephanie that uncovers a truth stranger than anything imagined. Despite maintaining a witty and humorous ambiance, “A Simple Favor ” undoubtedly leaves its viewers with moments of genuine apprehension.

A Twisted Concoction of Laughs and Screams

Upon hitting the screens, “A Simple Favor” garnered both commercial and critical acclaim, leading fans to anticipate a follow-up, which was approved earlier this spring. The enigmatic implications surrounding Emily’s disappearance and the intricate truths uncovered during Stephanie’s probe keep viewers guessing about the characters and their situations just as much as it provides them with comedic relief.

9 Charade (1963)

In the movie titled Charade, Cary Grant and Audrey Hepburn captivate audiences as they star in a delightful fusion of romance, humor, and suspense. As Regina Lampert (Hepburn) prepares for her divorce from Charles, she decides to unwind with a tranquil vacation in the French Alps. It is there that she meets Peter Joshua (Grant), and their bond forms instantly. However, Regina’s holiday takes an unexpected turn when she learns about her husband’s murder. Together, they strive to comprehend his death while confronting a secret from his past that eventually affects both of them.

A Gratifying Example of Genre Fusion

Known as “the Hitchcock movie Hitchcock himself never created,” according to the National Catholic Register, Charade still amazes viewers with its spellbinding interaction between the principal characters and unexpected twists. In addition to the intriguing mystery and Reggie’s connection with the captivating Peter, it’s hard not to admire the beautiful surroundings. The film presents breathtaking scenery, and these locations also play a crucial role in solving the peculiar case.

8 The Handmaiden (2016)

In simpler terms, “The Handmaiden” is a captivating blend of suspense, romance, and intense drama, set during the Japanese occupation of Korea. The story begins with Count Fujiwara (Ha Jung-woo), a cunning but deceitful individual, concocting a scheme to defraud Lady Hideko (Kim Min-hee), a wealthy Japanese noblewoman. He enlists the help of Sook-hee (Kim Tae-ri), a pickpocket, in his plan to marry Lady Hideko and eventually have her committed to an asylum for her wealth. However, what follows is an unexpectedly thrilling game of chess that challenges initial assumptions.

A Dynamic Game of Cat and Mouse

As a cinephile, I’d say: “If it weren’t for the palpable sapphic intrigue permeating the grand estate or the captivating backgrounds of its characters, ‘The Handmaiden’ leaves viewers spellbound by the labyrinthine psychological games woven into the narrative. The constant deception and the cunning traps laid among the characters make for a film that is not only intriguing but downright riveting. Furthermore, the movie offers a profound glimpse into the complex power dynamics of class, gender, and ethnicity under Japanese imperialism, adding layers to an already engaging story.

7 The Neon Demon (2016)

In a different setting, numerous media outlets have delved into the concept of a protagonist entering what seems like a radiant paradise filled with dreams, but later discovers they’re submerged in the depths of a city’s vices instead. The film The Neon Demon, for instance, focuses on Jesse (played by Elle Fanning), a 16-year-old girl who ventures away from her home state of Georgia following her orphaning.

As a passionate cinephile, I chose LA as my stage, rapidly rising as an aspiring model. There, I met Ruby, a photographer (portrayed by Jena Malone), who became my friend and guide. She introduced me to other models, Gigi (Bella Heathcote) and Sarah (Abbey Lee). However, my journey in the glamorous world was far from a fairy tale; it spiraled into a nightmare filled with vivid dreams and sinister colleagues. One harrowing incident followed another, testing my resolve.

Fame, Dark But Just a Game

As a film critic, I found “The Neon Demon” to be a thought-provoking exploration of the darker side of the entertainment industry, where the line between ambition and abuse becomes alarmingly blurred. The movie’s enigmatic moments might appear underdeveloped at first glance, but they serve to heighten the mystery surrounding the characters and their hidden desires. These characters cloak their materialistic yearnings in superficial, otherworldly associations, which, while seemingly innocent, ultimately reveal a troubling appropriation of something more profound. The chilling aspect of “The Neon Demon” lies in the ruthless measures individuals are willing to take to transform their dreams into tangible reality.

6 Elephant Song (2014)

Elephant Song

A Game of Tricks and Time

Based on a play written by Nicolas Billon, this movie garnered mostly positive feedback. Some viewers appreciated its use of unexpected turns and compelling storytelling. However, others criticized certain aspects of the cinematography that didn’t quite align with the film’s development. The performances, particularly those by Greenwood and especially Dolan, were highly praised for turning a typical asylum thriller into an intriguing exploration of memory’s complexities and the mind’s potential depths.

5 Green Room (2015)

The 2015 movie titled “Green Room” is a gripping psychological thriller featuring Anton Yelchin, Patrick Stewart, and Imogen Poots. Set in the Pacific Northwest, it tells an unsettling tale of a punk band who stumble upon a group of Neo-Nazis while performing at a remote club. After deciding to play at a nearby event known for its Nazi affiliation, The Ain’t Rights (consisting of Pat [Yelchin], Sam [Shawkat], Reece [Cole], and Tiger [Turner]) encounter an appalling secret in the green room, causing them to fight for their survival.

A Chilling Adrenaline Rush of a Film

In a restricted distribution, the movie titled “Green Room” received high praise from critics. The intense bond between the band members for survival, their repugnance towards the palpable wickedness encompassing them, and the skillful tempo made this film exceptionally gripping. Although “Green Room” doesn’t delve into complex themes, it stands out as a movie that is both straightforward and insightful, and above all, bone-chillingly frightening.

4 The Gift (2015)

In “The Gift,” director Joel Edgerton shares the screen with Jason Bateman and Rebecca Hall in a spine-tingling thriller that follows a couple as they attempt to leave their harrowing past behind, yet are persistently haunted by a lingering reminder. As Simon (Bateman) and Robyn (Hall) decide to start anew in Chicago, everything appears to be moving smoothly. However, the arrival of Simon’s old school friend Gordo (Edgerton), who insists on assisting them with their relocation, disrupts their plans.

A Dark Unnerving Experience

The movie titled “The Gift” garnered acclaim not just for its engaging plot and delightful twists, but also for its skillful direction. Witnessing Edgerton’s effort and creativity as a co-director, actor, scriptwriter, and producer is truly remarkable, more so with a captivating narrative like this one. The journey of Simon and Robyn uncovering mysteries about Gordo and themselves creates a harmonious blend of tension, suspense, and disenchantment. Homes, generally a place where one feels the most secure, are skillfully manipulated in this film to challenge the notion that familiarity can shatter the illusion of safety.

3 Memento (2000)

In the movie called “Memento”, Guy Pearce plays Leonard Shelby, a man grappling with anterograde amnesia, meaning he can’t remember recent events. To help him recall important details, he uses photographs, written notes, and tattoos. As the story unfolds, these visual cues aid him in unraveling the mystery surrounding his wife’s murder and identifying the culprits. By combining elements of neo-noir and psychological thriller genres, “Memento” is far from simple or predictable.

A Pleasantly, Disorienting Ride Down Memory Lane

From a passionate cinephile’s perspective, Christopher Nolan’s directed thriller, Memento, stands out due to its ingenious storytelling, offering a captivating narrative that strays from conventional story structures. By employing non-linear narratives and creatively contrasting black-and-white and color scenes, Memento serves as an engaging puzzle for the viewer. As Shelby endeavors to unravel his life’s fragments, so too do we, the audience, engage in the process of deciphering what Shelby has forgotten, creating a refreshingly unique cinematic experience.

2 The Silence of the Lambs (1991)

As a cinephile, I’d have to say that “The Silence of the Lambs” stands out as one of the most iconic thrillers for many compelling reasons. Starring the talented quartet of Jodie Foster, Anthony Hopkins, Scott Glenn, and Ted Levine, this film tells the gripping story of Clarice Starling (Foster), a tenacious detective who seeks the advice of Dr. Hannibal Lecter (Anthony Hopkins), a notoriously vicious serial killer, to thwart the sinister intentions of Buffalo Bill (Levine). The narrative unfolds as Clarice engages in fascinating psychological cat-and-mouse games with Bill, all in an attempt to finally apprehend him and put an end to his reign of horror.

A Uniquely Thought-Provoking Mystery Thriller

The movie, “The Silence of the Lambs,” is thought-provoking and engaging, particularly in its examination of gender issues. It delves into Clarice’s position as a woman in a brutal, male-dominated profession and Bill’s intriguing yet disturbing portrayal of gender, sparking lively debate. The movie uses identity as a means to explore the human psyche, desires, and complexities, making it an engrossing study. Regardless of the time of year, “The Silence of the Lambs” is a film not to be missed.

1 Get Out (2017)

The movie “Get Out” exceeded everyone’s expectations upon its release in the late 2010s. What started as a seemingly romantic journey takes an unsettling turn into a race-themed struggle against time, which feels eerily authentic even at its most unrealistic moments. The couple, Chris (played by Daniel Kaluuya) and Rose (Alison Williams), are from New York City and decide to take the scenic route when traveling to Rose’s family home in a secluded upstate location. As they are confronted with awkward conversations and unsettlingly odd behavior, Chris gradually comes to the realization that there is more than meets the eye regarding Rose’s family.>

A Surreal Nightmare Come to Life

In a skillful blend of genres – science fiction, thriller, and horror – the movie “Get Out” expanded viewers’ outlooks significantly. Jordan Peele masterfully combines thought-provoking conversations about black people being dehumanized through objectification with traditional horror elements such as relentless fear experienced by a targeted character, and the fragile network of secrets and deceit that eventually unravels at the opportune moment. The film offers a well-timed release of mounting tension, innovative storytelling, and believable performances. If it continues to captivate audiences, “Get Out” could very well be recognized as one of the most influential thrillers of the 2010s, if not the entire century.

Read More

2024-10-26 06:02