12 Best DC Animated Movies Of All Time, Ranked

In terms of live-action, Marvel takes center stage, but when it comes to animation, DC Comics has consistently shone brighter. From the Superman cartoons produced by Max Fletcher in the 1940s right up to present day, DC has excelled at animating its characters. Shows like “Batman: The Animated Series,” “Justice League Unlimited,” and “Young Justice” are often considered the pinnacle of DC animation, but it’s not just about the shows – many of the animated movies are equally impressive. In fact, Warner Brothers has been producing a series of direct-to-video DC Universe Animated Original Movies, which remain popular today.

In this collection, we’ve handpicked the top 12 DC animated movies ever produced. However, before diving in, it’s important to keep in mind that there are numerous other impressive films in the DC universe that deserve your attention. For instance, “Green Lantern: First Flight” and the 2009 version of “Wonder Woman” are certainly worth watching, even though they didn’t make our list. Furthermore, we excluded any movies that were compiled from television episodes, like “The Batman-Superman Movie” or “Justice League: Starcrossed – The Movie.” In this context, we’re focusing on films created as full-length features, not those that were later edited from TV shows. Now, let’s get started, and here are the 12 best DC animated movies available for your viewing pleasure.

12. Justice League: The New Frontier

As a fan, I can’t help but be captivated by the stunning portrayal of “Justice League: The New Frontier,” a masterpiece inspired by Darwyn Cooke’s limited series, “DC: The New Frontier.” This standalone feature, the second under the DC Universe Animated Original Movies banner, beautifully encapsulates the charm and essence of the Silver Age of DC Comics.

Filled with an infectious sense of youthful optimism, we find Earth’s mightiest heroes rising to face a cosmic threat that could potentially destroy our world. This marks the beginning of the golden age of superheroes. “The New Frontier” seamlessly blends elements of science fiction, detective stories, and superhero origins, creating a visual spectacle that is hard to resist. The recognizable characters leap off the screen in this unique blend of genres, leaving you enchanted by its distinctive style.

In the world of superheroes, some like Superman (Kyle MacLachlan) and Batman (Jeremy Sisto) are well-established figures, while others such as Hal Jordan (David Boreanaz) and Martian Manhunter (Miguel Ferrer) are still finding their heroic identities. As they come into their roles, the Justice League of America is formed, and it’s a challenge for any alien invaders to stand against them. Compared to some of DC’s later animated films, “Justice League: The New Frontier” may be overlooked, but it deserves recognition for its compelling narrative, focus on lesser-known characters like Phil Morris’ King Faraday, and dedication to the original comic book source material. If you’re a fan of the Silver Age of DC Comics, this should definitely be at the top of your watchlist.

11. The Death and Return of Superman

Since the debut of “The Death of Superman” comics in the 90s, numerous interpretations of Superman’s death have been presented. For instance, Zack Snyder depicted Superman’s demise at the end of “Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice.” However, when it comes to a faithful portrayal of the original material, none have done it as effectively as the two-part animated series titled “The Death of Superman” and “Reign of the Supermen,” later combined as “The Death and Return of Superman.” These films are part of the DC Animated Movie Universe and offer a heartrending tale where Superman (Jerry O’Connell) perishes in battle, giving rise to several potential successors who attempt to fill his heroic role.

During their battle against Doomsday, the Justice League supports Superman, but his story is primarily about him. His connection with Lois Lane (played by Rebecca Romijn) serves as the emotional core of this two-part drama revolving around death and resurrection. You don’t need to have watched any other DCAMU productions to appreciate this standalone narrative. In this portrayal, O’Connell and Romijn deliver impressive performances as Superman and Lois, given that they are married in real life. However, it’s important to note that a different adaptation of “The Death of Superman” was made by DC a decade ago, titled “Superman: Doomsday.” While this version is distinct, it also offers an engaging interpretation of the same storyline.

10. The Batman vs. Dracula

Originating from the “Batman” animated series that aired on Kids WB during the early 2000s, “The Batman vs. Dracula” might seem absurd at first glance, but it turns out to be an exciting journey. In this tale, Batman (voiced by Rino Romano) persists in his crusade against crime in Gotham City. However, the Penguin (Tom Kenny) accidentally awakens Count Dracula (Peter Stormare), who had been asleep for centuries. Now under Dracula’s control, the Penguin serves as his loyal servant while the vampire seeks to reclaim his undead domain. As Batman starts noticing the peculiar occurrences in Gotham and with the appearance of the enigmatic Alucard, he determines to return this vampire to his tomb, ensuring the safety of his city once again.

This longer superhero movie featuring Batman is scarier than usual Batman episodes, offering ample space for its own unique storyline. It’s uncommon to see Batman battling supernatural entities, but “Batman vs. Dracula” demonstrates his versatility against the unexplained. However, what might be most unsettling is that even the Joker (Kevin Michael Richardson) transforms into a vampire, and watching this dark villain hunt for blood leaves an indelible impression. It’s unfortunate that both “Batman” and “Batman vs. Dracula” have become largely forgotten classics.

9. Batman: Gotham Knight

In 2008, just weeks before “The Dark Knight” was released, the animated film “Batman: Gotham Knight” came out. This production, a collaboration between Japanese and American studios, consisted of six distinct yet somewhat interconnected stories. Its style resembled that of “The Animatrix.” Four different animation studios contributed to the project, but despite the numerous creators involved, “Gotham Knight” emerged as a remarkable tale of storytelling. It delves into various perspectives of Gotham’s citizens regarding the Dark Knight and how his enigmatic nature contributes to his exploits. Each narrative shares some continuity, and it’s worth mentioning that Kevin Conroy lends his voice to Batman once again, proving yet again why he is unparalleled in this role.

It’s worth noting that the release of “Gotham Knight” was strategically timed, as it was initially marketed as an animated bridge between Christopher Nolan’s movies “Batman Begins” and “The Dark Knight.” Given that David S. Goyer, who wrote “Batman Begins,” and Jordan Goldberg, a producer of “The Dark Knight,” were both involved, this connection makes sense. Although not everyone sees “Gotham Knight” as part of the main narrative of the “Dark Knight” Trilogy, it offers an enjoyable supplement that can be watched independently. Moreover, notable DC writers such as Greg Rucka, Brian Azzarello, Bruce Timm, and Alan Burnett contributed to the film’s segments, making it a compelling choice for your viewing list.

8. Justice League: Crisis on Two Earths

While sharing some similarities with Grant Morrison’s “JLA: Earth 2,” the 2010 feature “Justice League: Crisis On Two Earths” stands as a unique entity. Initially conceived as a follow-up to “Justice League Unlimited,” it eventually developed its own identity. When the Justice League encounters an alternate universe Lex Luthor (Chris North), they team up with him in his reality to fight against the villainous Crime Syndicate, an evil counterpart of the League who cruelly enslaved their world. However, it quickly becomes clear that the fate of all realities is at stake.

Featuring standout performances from William Baldwin as Batman and James Woods as Owlman, among others, “Crisis On Two Earths” delivers a gripping tale that makes the multiverse seem less expansive than modern audiences might expect. In contrast to the sprawling narrative of the later “Justice League: Crisis on Infinite Earths” trilogy, “Crisis On Two Earths” shines with its more focused and purposeful storytelling. Two years subsequent, a follow-up titled “Justice League: Doom,” brought back many members of the original “Justice League” animated series cast. Whilst “Doom” was equally captivating, “Crisis On Two Earths” remains the superior installment in this duology.

7. All-Star Superman

Prior to James Gunn envisioning an “All-Star Superman” plot for his 2025 movie, DC had already adapted Grant Morrison’s powerful story into an animated film in 2011. Although not all aspects from the comic book were accurately portrayed on screen, director Sam Liu and screenwriter Dwayne McDuffie succeeded admirably. Featuring a talented cast with James Denton as Superman, Christina Hendricks as Lois Lane, and Anthony LaPaglia as Lex Luthor, the animated “All-Star Superman” effectively compressed the storyline to emphasize more clearly the impending end of Superman’s days.

As a fellow gamer, let me highly recommend diving into the world of “All-Star Superman.” If you haven’t already experienced it, I won’t ruin the surprise for you because trust me, it’s worth every moment. This tale takes us on an epic journey that harks back to the early days of the Man of Steel, drawing inspiration from the Golden and Silver Ages. It’s a breath of fresh air after countless attempts at modernizing Superman that just don’t seem to capture his essence.

“All-Star Superman,” however, strikes the perfect balance. It showcases our hero’s superhuman feats, raw strength, and brilliant intellect, but it’s his deep affection for Lois Lane that truly brings him to life. The art style is simply stunning, while the animation adds an extra layer of purpose, making you feel as if you’re part of the story itself.

In short, “All-Star Superman” will have you believing in the impossible — not just that a man can fly, but that he can inspire us to reach for the stars and beyond. Give it a read or watch, and I promise you won’t be disappointed!

6. Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox

To watch the DC Animated Movie Universe films in the right sequence, begin with “Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox.” This film marks the beginning of the universe inspired by “New 52,” which is officially introduced in “Justice League: War.” Additionally, it provides an explanation for how the DCAMU came into existence. Based on the “Flashpoint” limited series by Geoff Johns, “The Flashpoint Paradox” is a story centered around Barry Allen (Justin Chambers). In this tale, Barry travels to an alternate world that bears no resemblance to his own. He alters history by saving his mother in the past, resulting in a reality where Thomas Wayne is Batman, Aquaman and Wonder Woman are at odds, and he was never the Flash. Needless to say, it’s quite a head-scratcher!

In “The Flashpoint Paradox”, we discover that the villain causing all of The Flash’s troubles is none other than Reverse-Flash (played by C. Thomas Howell). If you think this storyline seems familiar from “The Flash” TV series or the 2023 “The Flash” movie, hold on! Despite some similarities, this animated “Justice League” project closely follows the original comic book source material more than the others. Not only is it the most accurate adaptation of “Flashpoint” so far, but it also sticks very closely to what made the comic such a significant part of The Flash’s comics history.

5. Batman: Under the Red Hood

Discussing exceptional comic book adaptations, “Batman: Under the Red Hood” closely follows Judd Winick’s original “Under the Hood” comic series, yet it stands independently from other stories in the DC Comics universe. In this animated movie, Batman, portrayed by Bruce Greenwood, confronts Gotham City’s newest vigilante, a dark antihero assassin called the Red Hood (Jensen Ackles). This mysterious figure shares a tumultuous past with both Batman and the Joker (John DiMaggio), and Batman is determined to uncover the truth. However, the truth proves to be difficult for him to accept.

In the “TomorrowVerse” reboot of DCAMU, Jensen Ackles lends his voice to the iconic role of Batman, a part we hope he returns to for a sequel given his stellar performance here as the Red Hood. Meanwhile, Bruce Greenwood delivers an impressive portrayal of Batman in this movie, capturing the character’s tormented soul and complex crusade with his signature gravitas. Although Greenwood reprised the role for “Young Justice,” these two projects are unrelated. If you’re seeking a thoughtful and engaging mystery centered around Batman, “Batman: Under the Red Hood” is one of the character’s most significant journeys worth exploring.

4. Superman vs. The Elite

It’s indisputable that Batman boasts a greater number of animated adaptations compared to Superman. However, this doesn’t diminish the captivating nature of Superman’s films. In terms of exploring moral complexities and the impact of superheroes on society, no animated movie surpasses “Superman vs. The Elite.” Adapted from the Action Comics #775 story by Joe Kelly, this screen version remains remarkably faithful to the original work, preserving its essence in translation.

In this film, Superman (voiced by George Newbern) grapples with the questionable methods employed by a new team of heroes known as “The Elite.” Their aggressive tactics, including lethal force, challenge Superman’s principles. This conflict between Superman and The Elite becomes increasingly pronounced, with The Elite rapidly gaining popularity among the public.

In “Superman vs. The Elite”, it’s not until the end that we truly understand how different Superman is from Manchester Black (Robin Atkin Downes). However, it’s when we witness what Superman might transform into if he followed The Elite’s methods, that the story reaches its climax. In a time when shows like “The Boys” challenge the notion of superheroes, “Superman vs. The Elite” stands out by championing Superman, reinforcing to viewers worldwide that his old-fashioned morals and ethics remain relevant, even if society takes a different route. Among all the films in this list, none highlight the significance of Superman as effectively as “Superman vs. The Elite”, which deserves recognition for its commitment to the character.

3. Batman: The Dark Knight Returns

As a devoted gamer, I’ve always yearned for Zack Snyder to bring “The Dark Knight Returns” to life in live-action, but in my honest opinion, this Frank Miller graphic novel shines brightest when animated. Stepping into the realm of animation, we find ourselves immersed in the DC Animated Original Movies’ first two-part story, “Batman: The Dark Knight Returns.” This adaptation doesn’t shy away from the gritty realism of the comic book, even setting the story in the mid-80s, a time when an older Batman takes on foes like the Mutant gang, Two-Face (Wade Williams), and the Joker (Michael Emerson). The Batman in this animated masterpiece, voiced by Peter Weller, is unlike any other – he’s raw, aggressive, violent, and ready to challenge the world for Gotham City’s safety.

In this tale, Carrie Kelly (Ariel Winter) steps into the role of Robin alongside Batman in his ongoing mission. Not wasting a moment, she swiftly dons the costume. Among Batman tales, “The Dark Knight Returns” stands out as particularly iconic, and its animated version nearly matches its brilliance. The climactic encounters between Batman, the Joker, and Superman are a wish fulfilled for comic enthusiasts, leaving us yearning for more. If additional content is desired, the 2011 prequel film, “Batman: Year One,” serves as another exceptional adaptation of Frank Miller’s work, one that adheres closely to the original material.

2. Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker

Wrapping up the “Batman Beyond” animated series, the movie “Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker” is exceptional in numerous ways. For starters, it brings the new Batman, Terry McGinnis (Will Friedle), face-to-face with the original Batman’s most formidable adversary. Additionally, it elevates the Joker (Mark Hamill) to a level of terror never seen before. Not only does this villain manage to cheat death, but he carries out some truly gruesome acts in the process. If you’ve ever pondered what would happen if the Joker discovered Batman’s secret identity, “Return of the Joker” explores that concept and takes it to its darkest (and most unsettling) end.

The movie skillfully combines elements from “Batman Beyond” and “Batman: The Animated Series,” creating a unique standalone piece that also serves as a connection between them. The acting by Friedle and Hamill as Batman and the Joker, respectively, is outstanding, while Kevin Conroy continues to impress as the elderly Bruce Wayne. Watching the Joker wreak havoc in the futuristic Neo-Gotham, aiming for one last showdown with the Dark Knight, offers a thrilling experience. However, it’s Terry McGinnis’ handling of the old Batman’s arch-nemesis that provides a fresh perspective on the classic dynamic. Writer and director Paul Dini excels in this production to such an extent that Warner Bros. requested two versions of the movie: a “theatrical” one and an unrated one.

1. Batman: Mask of the Phantasm

Without a shadow of a doubt, “Batman: Mask of the Phantasm” remains unrivaled as the best DC animated film. This pioneering theatrical animated Batman movie offers an in-depth exploration of Bruce Wayne’s (Kevin Conroy) psychological journey as he narrates his early transformation into Batman. Conroy pours his heart and soul into this film, infusing the Dark Knight with emotional depth that surpasses even the most impactful episodes of “Batman: The Animated Series.” Boasting impressive animation and a poignant script that underscores the true sorrow of Batman, we come to understand that our caped hero once sought to abandon his destiny, but fate had other plans.

The animated film “Batman: Mask of the Phantasm” stands out as a top-tier example of superhero storytelling, effortlessly tackling mature themes in a manner suitable for both children and adults, much like the classic Batman comics. A special mention must be made about Dana Delaney’s portrayal of Andrea Beaumont and her on-screen chemistry with Conroy. However, what truly sets “Mask of the Phantasm” apart is its ability to stir hope in viewers that Bruce Wayne might one day escape the shadow of Batman and discover genuine joy. Regrettably, in keeping with noir tradition, he ultimately returns to his cape and cowl, yet it’s this aspect that makes the story so captivating as it sheds light on why he remains committed to the role.

2025-04-22 14:32