IRS unveils new crypto tax rules: Are they a good thing?

As a researcher with a background in tax policy and cryptocurrencies, I believe these new crypto tax reporting rules mark an important milestone for the digital asset sector in the United States. While the finalization of these guidelines has been a long time coming, I am optimistic about the benefits they bring to all parties involved.


After the long-awaited crypto tax regulations have been officially approved by industry advocates, there are still complicated discussions to be had regarding the taxation of non-custodial providers.

After much deliberation, the Internal Revenue Service and the Treasury Department have reached a consensus on new crypto tax reporting regulations for investors, which is long-awaited.

Initially, these new guidelines might cause unease or apprehension for both trading platforms and their users.

Despite the frustration expressed for a long time about the ambiguity surrounding this issue, the new policy has garnered widespread approval following the record-breaking 44,000 public comments received during its consultation.

“What’s the reason for this change? The answer is that there are newly established guidelines to adhere to, which could potentially bring advantages for all parties involved.”

As a responsible and compliant crypto investor, I understand that starting from now, trading platforms are required to report my gains and losses to the relevant authorities. This regulation is being phased in gradually over the next three years.

Taxpayers, who have traditionally been tasked with reporting their crypto earnings for tax purposes, can now do so more smoothly and accurately.

As a researcher, I’ve discovered that this proposal could potentially generate a substantial revenue for the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). Some calculations suggest that this could translate into an additional tax income of around $2.3 billion per year or $28 billion over a ten-year period.

Is there anyone who has lost out? Yes, that includes individuals who have neglected to report their cryptocurrency profits for the past several years under the mistaken belief that such transactions remain untraceable.

The IRS expressed its intention to address the tax discrepancy concerning digital assets and strengthened regulations, taking into consideration the practical implementation challenges in the cryptocurrency industry.

“These regulations play a crucial role in our broader initiative aimed at ensuring tax compliance among high-income individuals. It’s essential that we prevent the use of digital assets as a means to conceal taxable income. These final regulations are designed to enhance our ability to detect noncompliance within the high-risk domain of digital assets.”

IRS Commissioner Danny Werfel

Officials emphasized that further actions are required in this regard. Notably absent from the latest regulations are decentralized exchange platforms, which do not hold users’ coins in their custody.

The IRS and the Treasury acknowledged the necessity of further reflection on these complex transactions, stating, “We require additional time to fully understand the intricacies.” Nevertheless, the majority of taxpayers prefer dealing with centralized brokers for their transactions.

‘A game-changer’

The new regulations announced by the U.S. authorities, as communicated to crypto.news by Erin Fennimore, TaxBit’s Vice President of Tax, represent a significant advancement for digital assets in the United States.

She further emphasized that they provide “essential transparency and validity to a burgeoning financial sector.”

“This development brings significant change to the industry. With this new regulatory clarity, businesses and conventional financial organizations can comfortably explore the digital asset market.”

Erin Fennimore

I would put it this way: This development could broaden the accessibility of digital assets as an investment choice for both individuals and corporations, expanding upon the growing trend of exchange-traded funds tied to Bitcoin‘s spot price. There are even whispers that Ether could join the ranks soon.

“The new developments provide essential guidance for compliance to institutions such as custodial cryptocurrency exchanges, reinforcing the role of digital currencies in the larger financial marketplace.”

Erin Fennimore

To simplify and clarify, she urged businesses operating in the cryptocurrency sector to enhance their internal compliance processes. This means minimizing redundancies in reporting and reducing the risk of customers encountering unwanted tax issues.

A messy fight

Coin Center expressed approval for the finalized reporting guidelines. However, they emphasized that an excessive amount of time and resources have been expended in reaching this stage.

As a crypto market analyst, I’ve noticed that there has been much debate surrounding the definition of a “broker” in the cryptocurrency industry. For over six years, a nonprofit organization has advocated for a narrow interpretation, insisting that only centralized exchanges such as Coinbase and Kraken should be included in this classification.

Now that it has come to pass — however, the IRS and the Treasury may have missed out on significant tax revenues during their protracted negotiations with Congress.

“For the past five years, we should have had accessible and authentic data documenting taxpayer profits from centralized exchanges. However, this information is currently unavailable to us.”

Coin Center

As a crypto investor, I understand the concerns raised about the potential vague and unreasonable definition of a broker in the context of cryptocurrency regulations. Such a definition could have put miners, validators, software developers, and even individual users in a precarious position, requiring us to monitor transactions of our fellow crypto users and report private ones or risk facing criminal charges. This situation raised serious constitutional concerns as it infringed upon our right to privacy and freedom of expression.

“If this broker definition had been implemented, the US would have lost its competitiveness in the rapidly developing field of open blockchain technologies.”

Coin Center

Regrettably, it’s still undecided how non-custodial entities should be dealt with. The future could bring complications.

Read More

2024-07-04 21:58