Judy Greer Responds After A Fan Points Out The ‘Unbelievable’ Twist In M. Night Shyamalan’s The Village, And LOL

Judy Greer Responds After A Fan Points Out The ‘Unbelievable’ Twist In M. Night Shyamalan’s The Village, And LOL

As a die-hard fan and longtime admirer of Judy Greer‘s captivating performances, I wholeheartedly concur with Scott Mendelson’s hilarious take on M. Night Shyamalan’s “The Village.” The absurdity of rejecting the enchanting Judy Greer is indeed a plot twist that strains credulity.


Approximately two decades have passed since M. Night Shyamalan’s “The Village” premiered in cinemas, a film that, looking back, might not have been perfectly timed due to its ongoing intrigue and controversy. A hallmark of the director’s work, “The Village” remains a point of fascination and discussion among viewers. The movie, known for its shocking twist ending, continues to leave fans either spellbound or exasperated. However, a viewer recently highlighted what they consider the most implausible twist in the film, one that doesn’t involve Shyamalan’s typical plot manipulation but rather actress Judy Greer. In response, Greer has humorously addressed the matter.

The Jurassic World star, who played Kitty Walker in the 2004 thriller, became the subject of a playful critique that had fans laughing. Film critic Scott Mendelson shared an image from The Village with the caption: “20 years later, The Village contains what is still by far M. Night Shyamalan’s least believable plot twist. There’s a key sequence in the first act where… (spoiler) a character declines to marry Judy Greer.” The comment resonated with the Arrested Development alum, who joined the fun by reposting the critique on her Instagram with a witty caption.

A post shared by Judy Greer (@missjudygreer)

A photo posted by on

Mendelson highlights the illogical aspect found within Shyamalan’s movie. In one scene, Judy (played by Judy) expresses affection towards Lucius Hunt, portrayed by Joaquin Phoenix, but he rejects her advances because his affections are already committed to someone else.

Judy Greer Responds After A Fan Points Out The ‘Unbelievable’ Twist In M. Night Shyamalan’s The Village, And LOL

As a certified fan of Greer, I can’t help but agree with Mendelson’s observation. Let’s pause for a moment to acknowledge the versatility of the actress from “Ant-Man and The Wasp.” She is not only a captivating scene-stealer but also an attractive powerhouse of talent. Here are some of her impressive roles prior to “The Village” that support Scott’s argument.

  • Andrea or ‘Dre’ in Kissing a Fool (1998) – In this romantic comedy with David Schwimmer and Jason Lee, Judy’s role as Andrea, though supporting, is captivating and unforgettable, showcasing her beauty and comedic talent.
  • Fern in Jawbreaker (1999) – the Where’d You Go, Bernadette actress shines as Fern, transforming from a shy high schooler into a confident, cunning force in this dark comedy, proving her versatility and magnetic presence.
  • Cathy Daitch in Three Kings (1999) – As a journalist competing with Adriana, the Family Guy performer’s portrayal of Cathy Daitch is sharp and impactful, especially in her early scene with George Clooney.
  • Penny Nicholson in The Wedding Planner (2001) – Greer’s warm and memorable performance as Penny, Mary’s (Jennifer Lopez) sweet but scatterbrained friend, blends humor with heart.
  • Lucy “Tom-Tom” Wyman in 13 Going on 30 (2004) – Judy nails it as Lucy, the sassy best friend-turned-frenemy, adding unforgettable attitude and style to this beloved rom-com.

Over time, the character from the Archer series has moved beyond “best friend” roles and demonstrated a wide array of acting abilities. Notable achievements include her work in The Descendants (2011) and her portrayal of Karen in the modern version of the iconic horror film Halloween. In the initial installments of Blumhouse’s rebooted trilogy, Greer delivered some of the most impressive performances within the series, regardless of personal opinions regarding the quality of the Halloween movies.

Judy isn’t merely attractive; she’s a multifaceted performer who makes an indelible mark on each character she portrays. As Scott Mendelson highlighted, dismissing her would be like another M. Night Shyamalan plot twist taken to the extreme!

Read More

2024-08-22 01:37