Gregory Peck’s Only Purely Villainous Role Came From The Boys From Brazil

Gregory Peck's Only Purely Villainous Role Came From The Boys From Brazil

As a cinephile with a soft spot for character-driven dramas and a keen interest in historical narratives, I can wholeheartedly recommend “The Boys from Brazil.” This film offers a unique blend of suspense, mystery, and a powerhouse performance by the legendary Gregory Peck as the enigmatic Dr. Josef Mengele.


When considering Gregory Peck as an actor, people often recall his portrayal of morally upstanding and heroic characters across his movie career – from Atticus Finch in To Kill a Mockingbird to General Frank Savage in Twelve O’Clock High, and Captain Keith Mallory in The Guns of Navarone. However, contrary to the images of good-hearted roles he usually played, in 1978, Gregory Peck took on the chilling role of one of history’s most evil men – using false science to attempt to bolster the Nazi party

As a movie enthusiast, let me tell you that “The Boys From Brazil” is an exceptional film that presents Gregory Peck in a way you’ve never seen before. I’ll delve into the thrilling tale of this sci-fi mystery, explain why it deviated from his typical roles, and suggest whether it’s worth watching for any fellow cinephiles like myself. Enjoy the ride!

The Boys From Brazil Plot and Cast

Gregory Peck's Only Purely Villainous Role Came From The Boys From BrazilGregory Peck's Only Purely Villainous Role Came From The Boys From BrazilGregory Peck's Only Purely Villainous Role Came From The Boys From Brazil

A young investigator, working under the label of a Nazi hunter, disentangles a scheme orchestrated by the notorious Nazi scientist Dr. Josef Mengele (Gregory Peck), who was later killed for his meddling. The investigation then lands on the shoulders of a seasoned tracker named Ezra Lieberman (Laurence Olivier). Notably, he discovers that a band of Nazis were systematically eliminating 95 men of similar age from around the world. As he delves deeper into the mystery, he begins to unravel that Mengele’s unusual decree was an attempt to reproduce a potential new leader for the Nazis, with the intention of re-elevating the Nazi party to power once more

The film introduces Steven Guttenberg as Barry Kohler, a youthful Nazi hunter who initially reveals Mengele’s scheme. Following the swift end of the characters, the probe falls upon Ezra Lieberman, portrayed by the esteemed Laurence Olivier. Renowned for his mastery over the Bard’s works and plays, Olivier is a celebrated stage actor; on-screen, he is most recognized for his stellar performance in Sleuth (1972). The eminent Gregory Peck takes on the role of Dr. Josef Mengele in The Boys from Brazil

“The film ‘The Boys From Brazil’ was helmed by Franklin J. Schaffner, a director renowned for his work on ‘Patton’ and ‘Planet of the Apes’. This movie is an adaptation of the 1976 novel of the same title penned by American author Ira Levin.”

Gregory Peck Is at his Most Villainous in The Boys From Brazil

Gregory Peck's Only Purely Villainous Role Came From The Boys From BrazilGregory Peck's Only Purely Villainous Role Came From The Boys From BrazilGregory Peck's Only Purely Villainous Role Came From The Boys From Brazil

In the promotion for “The Boys From Brazil,” it was stated that Gregory Peck’s role in this film marked his first villainous character. While some might argue this, considering Peck had previously played morally questionable characters like Ahab in “Moby Dick” (1956), Jesse in “The Duel in the Sun” (1946), and Jim in “The Bravados” (1958), these roles did not exhibit the unambiguous wickedness portrayed when he took on the character of Dr. Josef Mengele

“In the world, your lineage is unmatched in nobility. Dreams that seem grand to you now pale in comparison to the ambitions you’ll achieve, Bobby. You will achieve them, without a doubt. You mirror the greatest man history has ever known.” (Gregory Peck as Dr. Josef Mengele in The Boys From Brazil)

Gregory Peck considered Dr. Josef Mengele to be the most unrelatable character he’s ever played. His portrayal received divided reviews, with some appreciating the shift but others finding it distasteful. Gene Siskel from the Chicago Tribune even criticized the entire production as an example of poor traditional filmmaking. Despite this, Peck expressed disappointment at the negative feedback on his performance, claiming that he, along with actors like Laurence Olivier, Walter Matthau, and Jack Lemmon, felt he excelled in a role outside his usual repertoire, but the criticism was harsher because it didn’t fit his typical roles

In the case of “The Boys from Brazil,” it currently boasts a solid 70% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, based on 33 critic reviews. While some found Peck’s performance to be divisive, many were captivated by the unique portrayal of Dr. Josef Mengele as a man who viewed himself not as evil but as someone carrying out an essential mission he alone could fulfill. Peck’s convincing embodiment of a man wholly immersed in his own delusions and imbued with a palpable intensity made for a compelling performance. The actor’s portrayal of Dr. Mengele in “The Boys from Brazil” has left viewers yearning for more villainous roles from him throughout his career

Why You Should Watch the Boys from Brazil

Gregory Peck's Only Purely Villainous Role Came From The Boys From BrazilGregory Peck's Only Purely Villainous Role Came From The Boys From BrazilGregory Peck's Only Purely Villainous Role Came From The Boys From Brazil

Although the plotline of “The Boys of Brazil” contains some science fiction undertones, it might not satisfy those seeking a more rigid interpretation of the genre. The intricate web of conspiracy, involving the cloning of multiple potential “mini-Hitlers,” was a rather distant notion in the ’70s when compared to the modern era, especially considering the significant advancements in technology since then (notably Dolly the sheep was not cloned until 1996)

The draw of The Boys from Brazil will come from its dramatic elements, building mystery, and its performances. All of these elements are well handled and intriguing, particularly seeing Gregory Peck as such an unsympathetic villain. The movie is certainly not perfect, but it offers a wonderfully intense slow-burn mystery with an exciting plot full of twists and turns. Moreover, director Franklin J. Schaffner also managed to navigate sensitive themes without becoming exploitative, treated with the deserved condemnation and sensitivity of the history behind it. You can stream The Boys from Brazil on Prime, Tubi, or Flex.

Read More

2024-09-05 02:33