‘Happy Holidays’ Review: A Cleverly Structured Palestinian Drama Explores Constriction and Complicity in Israeli Society

‘Happy Holidays’ Review: A Cleverly Structured Palestinian Drama Explores Constriction and Complicity in Israeli Society

As a gamer with a deep interest in thought-provoking narratives, I found Scandar Copti’s “Happy Holidays” to be an enthralling and poignant exploration of interconnected lives in Israel. Having spent years immersed in virtual worlds, I can’t help but draw parallels between the complex web of relationships in this film and the intricate plots of my favorite video games.


In Scandar Copti’s thoughtfully arranged drama titled “Happy Holidays“, one character, Rami (Toufic Danial), finds out that his girlfriend Shirley (Shani Dahari) is pregnant. This news triggers a wave of anxiety within him because they are both from different ethnicities – Palestinian and Israeli respectively. He worries about the difficulties of raising a child in a nation where their relationship itself can’t be openly acknowledged. Rami proposes to Shirley the idea of terminating the pregnancy, but she declines his suggestion.

In the film “Happy Holidays,” which debuted in the Orrizonti sidebar at the Venice Film Festival, we find an initial set of intertwined conflicts. The story revolves around characters Rami and Shirley, along with their families, as they deal with life in Israel. Co-director Copti, a Palestinian filmmaker known for his work on the Oscar-nominated “Ajami” with Israeli director Yaron Shani, focuses on the intricate interactions within a country heavily militarized and divided. The film explores how personal ties reflect or challenge the nation’s intentions, how national influences can shape or even break relationships, and how women endure oppressive patriarchal structures.

Copti skillfully embeds profound intellectual queries within the captivating twists of a suspenseful plot in this movie. The intricate narrative setup creates an engaging puzzle that discerning viewers will be keen to unravel. Happy Holidays commences with Rami and Shirley, but as each episode (the film is split into four parts) unfolds, it introduces fresh complications and difficulties for their families. Copti elicits convincing performances from his ensemble of amateur actors, who lend authenticity to the film through their poignant depictions of Jewish Israelis and primarily Palestinian Christian characters grappling with existential dilemmas. Given these aspects, if the film secures U.S. distribution, it’s likely to find its niche audience. Wishing you a Happy Holidays!

Rami and Shirley can’t seem to find common ground regarding their baby, causing tension in their relationship that eventually escalates due to anonymous threats. Both suspect foul play from each other; Rami accuses Shirley’s family of sending veiled warnings he has been receiving, while Shirley suspects Rami of hiring goons to intimidate her. The identity of the threat-sender remains one of the enigmatic elements in the movie “Happy Holidays“, effectively portraying the dangerous undercurrents in Rami and Shirley’s relationship. It would have been beneficial to delve deeper into their history, as a substantial part of the film revolves around the controversial aspects of their romance.

As Rami navigates through his personal relationship issues, his sister Fifi (played by Manar Shehab) conceals her own secrets. Following a fateful night, she gets involved in a car accident, which is portrayed in the opening scene, leaving her injured and hospitalized. This unexpected incident at the ER unsettles her family, causing some of its members to uncover details about Fifi’s past sexual life that she wishes to keep confidential. Copti, who both wrote the script and directed the film, employs Fifi’s story to shed light on broader themes presented here. In the movie Happy Holidays, women are often subjected to societal restrictions, with Fifi’s unsuccessful attempts to maintain privacy in the hospital becoming a significant driving force of the plot.

Notable characters in the story are Fifi’s lover Walid (portrayed by Raed Burbara), whose affections for Fifi and his intentions towards marriage appear to be based on a misunderstood and ambiguous idea of purity. Additionally, there is Fifi’s mother Hanah (played by Walaa Aoun), who is arranging a wedding for Fifi’s sister Leila (Sophie Awaada) amidst the family’s financial difficulties, which were exacerbated by questionable accounting practices as previously depicted. The narrative also delves into Shirley’s family, focusing initially on her sister Miri (Merav Mamorsky), who seeks to impact Shirley’s choices regarding pregnancy while dealing with her own daughter’s unexpected bouts of depression.

Delving into the intricacies of my family life, I find myself immersed in the vibrant cityscape of Haifa, where the film unfolds. The glimpses of Fifi at her role as an assistant teacher in an elementary school offer a chilling insight into how Israeli education subtly cultivates anti-Arab sentiments and the perceived need for a dominant military force. Students are taught to write cards to soldiers and are made to believe that their wellbeing hinges on this ever-present armed presence. Over time, these notions solidify into a national identity, used as a means to deepen divisions. Differences are exploited to instill fear. Copti captures all of these sequences, including instances of moral questioning, with an unflinching and honest perspective. By weaving together multiple narratives, Happy Holidays provides a palpable demonstration of interconnectedness, serving as a poignant reminder that true freedom cannot be attained until everyone is free.

Read More

2024-09-07 16:55