Toronto: ‘Russians at War’ Director on Political Reasons for Russia-Ukraine War: “I Don’t Know”

Toronto: ‘Russians at War’ Director on Political Reasons for Russia-Ukraine War: “I Don’t Know”

As a gamer with a keen interest in history and politics, I find myself deeply intrigued by the story of Anastasia Trofimova and her documentary, “Russians at War”. Having spent countless hours immersed in strategy games that simulate real-world conflicts, I can’t help but appreciate the effort it takes to get close to the truth behind such complex issues.


Following a stir of debate in Venice with her documentary titled “Russians at War“, and a delayed North American debut in Toronto due to reported security concerns, director Anastasia Trofimova expressed on Tuesday that she remains perplexed about the political motives behind the Russia-Ukraine conflict.

During a post-screening discussion, the Russian-Canadian director explained that her motivation for joining this conflict was to gain insight into the individuals involved in the fighting. Regarding political motives, she admitted she’s still uncertain.” (While Trofimova was embedded with a Russian army battalion in Eastern Ukraine, the film was being made.)

She was answering a spectator of a TIFF film regarding if Trofimova had gained insights from her three-year production of “Russians at War“. “I remark, even now, I can’t fathom the causes of this war,” Trofimova shared with the inquirer. “If you have figured it out and everything is evident to you, then my compliments are in order. But for myself, I remain perplexed.

Toronto: ‘Russians at War’ Director on Political Reasons for Russia-Ukraine War: “I Don’t Know”

When asked if Russia was primarily responsible for the central European conflict, Trofimova responded: “I believe there are numerous other factors at play, yes, and it’s true that they’re deploying troops to address any disputes. However, I don’t think it’s just.

When the TIFF interrogator thanked Trofimova for her response, the movie’s Oscar-nominated producer, Cornelia Principe (who was also on stage at TIFF Lightbox), further elaborated on the director’s response. Essentially, she reiterated that Trofimova suggested sending troops to invade a country is not an effective solution to a problem, as expressed by her words. This point was acknowledged by the festival-goer, who once more thanked Trofimova for her insightful answer.

During a heated discussion, Trofimova replied from the stage, “It appears you’re not getting it,” and Anita Lee, the chief programmer of the Toronto Film Festival, decided to conclude the post-screening question-and-answer session at that point.

Ivanka Tymchuk, who is part of the Ukrainian Canadian Congress and has voiced criticism towards the movie “Russians at War” as being propaganda, was questioned regarding Trofimova’s apparent lack of understanding about the political aspects of the Russia-Ukraine conflict during a question-and-answer session following the film screening.

In an interview with The Hollywood Reporter, filmmaker Tymchuk, who holds a university degree, expressed that her analytical mind would enable her to assemble the pieces and grasp the reality: Russia has taken control of three Ukrainian provinces, which is a violation of international law. This statement was made near TIFF Lightbox, where approximately 200 Ukrainian Canadian protesters were holding a vigil on Tuesday.

Tymchuk stated that Russia’s intention is clear: they aim to occupy as much of Ukraine as they can,” he continued. Trofimova shared earlier last week that her documentary, which features her personal conversations with Russian soldiers over a span of seven months in Ukraine, provides a unique perspective not seen on official Russian TV or by Western journalists.

Toronto: ‘Russians at War’ Director on Political Reasons for Russia-Ukraine War: “I Don’t Know”

The organizers of Toronto’s festival have moved the North American premiere of Russians at War to September 17th, following the conclusion of its 2024 edition, due to security concerns and political tension. At a 2:30 p.m. screening of the film, two Ukrainian protesters expressed their dissent as they exited the movie theater.

As a gamer, I found myself caught in the heat of a movie scene when the director posed a question to a young soldier on screen: “Why do you deny the atrocities like rapes and murders of innocents, allegedly perpetrated by our military?” This query, asked by director Trofimova, sparked an intense protest from the theater audience.

While making my way out of the theater after watching an intense movie, I overheard protesters voicing concerns about alleged war crimes committed during the conflict in Ukraine. They claimed that more than 100,000 incidents had occurred, involving civilian murder and torture. During the post-screening Q&A, Principe provided additional context that wasn’t part of the film itself.

From the TIFF Lightbox stage, Principe explained that the scene portrayed him as unaware of the truth unfolding around him. After all, just moments earlier, he was chatting about his girlfriend’s broken nail. If you choose to believe his character’s perspective, it’s understandable that he wouldn’t be privy to war crimes. However, we, the audience, know such atrocities occurred. Trofimova’s intention was to discover if he knew or suspected about these war crimes.

The movie’s producer explained that the comment wasn’t based on fact for the film; instead, it reflected the thoughts of a child speaking to his girlfriend about her broken nail. Controversy surrounding the film initially surfaced during its debut at the Venice Film Festival, where it was first screened.

Toronto: ‘Russians at War’ Director on Political Reasons for Russia-Ukraine War: “I Don’t Know”

On September 10th, approximately 400 Ukrainian residents of Toronto assembled outside the TIFF Lightbox to demonstrate against a private screening of a movie. Their signs read “Russians at War Justifies and Victimizes Murderers and Rapists” and “TIFF, Russian Propaganda is Deadly.

During a press conference in Ottawa, Deputy Prime Minister and Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland, who has Ukrainian heritage, voiced worries about the film “Russians at War” being screened at the TIFF festival. The tension surrounding this film, along with potential dangers to the festival’s operation and public safety as stated by TIFF organizers, reportedly led to the cancellation of Trofimova’s film’s official North American premiere during Toronto’s September 5-15 run. However, just a few days later, “Russians at War” was reinstated for screenings at the TIFF Lightbox on September 17.

On September 20th, the Lunenberg Film Festival in Nova Scotia will showcase the film “Russians at War”, while the Windsor Film Festival in Ontario has scheduled screenings for October 25th and 26th of a Canada-France collaboration.

Read More

2024-09-18 02:55