Harvey Weinstein Pleads Not Guilty to New Sexual Assault Charge

Harvey Weinstein Pleads Not Guilty to New Sexual Assault Charge

As a seasoned gamer who has spent countless hours immersed in virtual worlds, I must say that the ongoing saga of Harvey Weinstein feels like a never-ending RPG (Role Playing Game) with unexpected twists and turns. The latest chapter in this real-life drama is as gripping as any quest, filled with intrigue, legal battles, and high stakes.


On Wednesday, Harvey Weinstein denied guilt for a charge of first-degree criminal sexual conduct, following its presentation by Manhattan prosecutors. They had updated the initial indictment against the ex-movie tycoon.

1st degree sexual crime is categorized as a Class B felony, which involves forcing someone into oral or anal sexual acts against their will. This allegation originated from a 2024 indictment by the grand jury, and if convicted, the offender could face imprisonment for up to 25 years.

Additionally, Harvey Weinstein is set for a new trial regarding allegations connected to his 2020 rape conviction in New York that was later dismissed. Currently, he is accused under two separate indictments of committing three separate sexual offenses.

On Wednesday, Weinstein made his initial court appearance since his recent heart surgery and hospitalization. He was wheeled into the courtroom, as he has done for previous hearings, carrying two books and wearing a bandage on his hand, which was visible under the gauze. In response to the charges, he declared his innocence aloud.

The legal team seeking conviction is advocating for combining the latest accusations with the initial one, against Weinstein’s defense attorney Arthur Aidala who prefers separate trials and plans for a November retrial linked to the original 2020 rape allegations. On October 2nd, a ruling will be made regarding the motion to combine the cases.

About a week and a half ago, I found myself hospitalized at Bellevue in New York for heart surgery – Weinstein, that is. Last Thursday, when the indictment against him was made public, he wasn’t present in court because he hadn’t received the necessary medical clearance yet.

Due to his medical condition, Judge Curtis Farber granted the defense’s motion to hold Weinstein in Bellevue Hospital’s prison ward for the time being, rather than Rikers Island. His attorneys argued for the stay at Bellevue, saying that Weinstein’s health could not be properly monitored at Rikers Island and it was necessary to hold him at the hospital to “stop what may be the death of Mr. Weinstein.”

In a recent court proceeding, Judge Farber announced that Weinstein had made his third visit to Bellevue Hospital in a short timeframe. His current condition necessitates close monitoring because of an accumulation of fluids around his heart, the same issue that required his latest surgery and hospital stay, as stated by Judge Farber.

At Rikers Island, Weinstein remained detained, anticipating a potential new trial set for November, following an overturning of his 2020 rape conviction in New York and the subsequent 23-year sentence in April.

The change in events was triggered by the presentation of evidence concerning sex offenses for which no indictments were made. A panel of seven judges from the State Courts of Appeals, in a 4-3 verdict, ruled that the “trial court incorrectly allowed testimony about unindicted, alleged past sexual incidents,” deeming it as an “overstep of judicial discretion.

According to Aidala, presenting this evidence meant that Weinstein couldn’t testify, as the accusations were decades old.

In California, courts can use a defendant’s past sexual offense history as evidence, even if those accusations didn’t result in formal charges. However, in New York, this kind of evidence is only admissible when it’s essential for understanding the defendant’s motive, intent, or pattern of conduct related to the alleged crimes.

At present, all of Weinstein’s current convictions are based on testimony from Jane Doe No. 1, who has identified herself as former Russian model Evgeniya Chernyshova. In a verdict that combined guilty and not-guilty findings from the Los Angeles District Attorney’s Office jury, he was found guilty on three charges: forcible rape, forcible oral sex, and penetration with an object. The jury, however, acquitted him of sexual battery by restraint against another accuser and could not reach a consensus on charges related to two other accusers.

Jessica Mann, one of the women who filed charges against Weinstein during his 2020 trial, has expressed her intention to reappear in court against him. In a statement issued last week, she stated, “Just as I did when Harvey was convicted for the first time, I have found my voice. I eagerly anticipate employing it once more in our upcoming legal encounter and demonstrating that my life holds immense worth – something he will never be capable of diminishing.

Read More

2024-09-18 22:56