9 Most Underrated Westerns on Netflix

9 Most Underrated Westerns on Netflix

As a film enthusiast who’s spent countless hours immersed in the dusty plains and gritty towns of Western cinema, I must say that each of these films offers a unique take on this classic genre.


Though the wide-open frontier may no longer be a part of daily life, the essence of the “Western” spirit continues to thrive through films and television. Although it seems that the genre has vanished from the big screen for quite some time now, streaming platforms have brought back the desolate trails and grand vistas, offering both old enthusiasts and novices another chance to appreciate the allure of Westerns.

Netflix, in essence, is a treasure trove for Western-themed content. Although it’s renowned for producing hit TV shows, it has also wisely expanded its collection to cater to the shifting preferences of viewers. Devotees of this genre recognize that it’s not merely about gunfights and scenic landscapes; over time, Westerns have evolved, and filmmakers continue to challenge stereotypes while creating content across various platforms. This compilation highlights some underrated masterpieces on Netflix that offer a blend of entertainment, authenticity, and the raw spirit of the Old West.

9 Strange Way of Life (2023)

In a more recent Western film, Pedro Pascal plays Silva, and Ethan Hawke takes on the role of Sheriff Jake – two long-lost friends who meet again after 25 years in a tiny Wild West town. Their reunion is tinged with nostalgia but has a darker purpose: Silva’s arrival isn’t just for friendship catch-up, but to help his son, Joe, who stands accused of a crime. As they grapple with their intricate bond, the story builds towards a dramatic and moving resolution.

Challenges Traditional Western Tropes

In a straightforward and engaging manner: A brief yet impactful Spanish-language Western titled “Strange Way of Life” premiered at the Cannes Film Festival in 2023, leaving critics in awe. Described as a “queer Western with a touch of eroticism,” this film masterfully blends themes of love, remorse, and rehabilitation, offering both a sense of familiarity and novelty. The captivating performances by Pascal and Hawke add depth and intensity to the intricate narrative, making it more gripping than ever before.

8 Concrete Cowboy (2020)

In his debut as a leading actor in a full-length movie following his recognition for portraying Lucas Sinclair on Netflix’s Stranger Things, Caleb McLaughlin plays fifteen-year-old Cole, who relocates to North Philadelphia to reside with his distant father. As he grapples with fitting in, Cole eventually encounters a lively group of Black cowboys and learns about their deep-rooted culture and horseback riding skills. Through his father, the local riders, and this new community, Cole develops a stronger bond and discovers a renewed sense of acceptance.

Takes a Gallop in a New Direction

Instead of following the conventional narrative of classic Westerns, Concrete Cowboy presents a fresh perspective by setting the story in an urban landscape, showcasing the protagonist adapting to novel surroundings, immersing himself in an unfamiliar lifestyle, and abandoning his rebellious past.

Film director Ricky Staub presents a lesser-explored but impactful movie that provokes thought, lifts spirits, and centers around themes such as family, tradition, ancestry, and atonement. Idris Elba and McLaughlin give standout performances in their portrayal of a father and son, earning high praise for their acting skills.

7 The Killer (2017)

9 Most Underrated Westerns on Netflix9 Most Underrated Westerns on Netflix9 Most Underrated Westerns on Netflix

Titled originally as “O Matador“, this Brazilian Western production goes by the name “The Killer” and was penned and helmed by Marcelo Galvão. The story unfolds in the anarchic wilderness of early 20th-century Brazil, seen through the perspective of Shaggy, a hitman raised secluded under the tutelage of a notorious outlaw called Seven Ears. When Seven Ears vanishes, Shaggy embarks on a journey to locate him and ends up in a town controlled by Seven Ears’ former boss, the oppressive Monsieur Blanchard.

A Slow-Burn Worth Discovering

Galvão’s lesser-known Western, “The Killer,” is remarkable for its compelling narrative and ability to transform a familiar plot into an enthralling viewing experience. The film’s vivid cinematography brilliantly portrays the stunning yet harsh beauty of the Brazilian terrain. Additionally, the intricate storyline tackles themes such as identity and revenge. Diogo Morgado delivers a captivating performance as the protagonist, further enhancing the movie’s allure. Regrettably, despite its merits, “The Killer” remains relatively unknown outside of Brazil.

6 My Heroes Were Cowboys (2021)

9 Most Underrated Westerns on Netflix9 Most Underrated Westerns on Netflix9 Most Underrated Westerns on Netflix

This heartfelt documentary, titled “My Heroes Were Cowboys,” delves into the life of Robin Wiltshire, a well-known horse trainer whose life took a positive turn when he found tranquility and direction in the imagery of classic Western films from Hollywood. Born with a challenging past, Robin’s life was dramatically altered upon his discovery of the skill of horse training. The film traces his journey, from his early years to his rise as a respected horse trainer for both films and television.

A Heartwarming Tale of Redemption

Under Tyler Greco’s direction, the movie “My Heroes Were Cowboys” delves into the process of creating iconic Western films. It’s a tale of fervor and commitment, following one man’s pursuit of purpose through his affection for horses. Stunning visuals and an emotional undertone portray Robin’s odyssey and his profound connection with his equine companions. Despite its brief duration, the film retains the eternal essence of the American West.

5 Legends of the Fall (1994)

For over five decades, from World War I right up to the Prohibition Era, Legends of the Fall unfolds against the deceptive landscape of 1920s Montana. The story revolves around the Ludlow family, headed by Colonel William Ludlow, who abandoned military life and now resides in the wilderness along with his sons – Alfred, Tristan, and Samuel. As the specter of World War I approaches and the brothers enlist, the family encounters a calamity and a love triangle that could potentially shatter their bond in a deeply emotional manner.

A Shakespearean Saga of Family

As a devoted cinephile, I’d say that “Legends of the Fall,” masterfully directed by Edward Zwick, is an expansive post-war narrative set against the rugged frontier backdrop. This cinematic gem is adapted from Jim Harrison’s novella of the same name and shares its blend of poignant romance, gripping drama, and the unforgiving truths of life after war.

In this rephrased version, the main character portrayed by Brad Pitt, who is known for his wild and adventurous personality, takes center stage in the storyline. Anthony Hopkins, Julia Ormond, and Aidan Quinn provide exceptional supporting roles. Although the film received critical praise, it has been somewhat overlooked due to some viewers finding its plot overly dramatic. However, this very aspect is what makes it a must-see.

4 Thar (2022)

9 Most Underrated Westerns on Netflix9 Most Underrated Westerns on Netflix9 Most Underrated Westerns on Netflix

Under the guidance of director Raj Singh Chaudhary and featuring Harshvardhan Kapoor in a prominent role, Thar takes you on a journey to the arid Thar Desert of Rajasthan. The story unfolds as Siddharth, an enigmatic antique dealer, enters a secluded village grappling with gruesome murders. His path intersects with that of seasoned police officer Surekha Singh, who has tirelessly been working on the murder investigations. It isn’t long before Surekha discovers that Siddharth is intent on seeking justice for a heart-wrenching personal loss.

Looks at the Western Genre Through an Indian Lens

Thar is a visually captivating and underestimated movie on Netflix that seamlessly blends Western and noir elements. The gradual revelation of the truth and the portrayal of tough desert existence are evident throughout, with its brooding landscapes and exploration into each character’s mind serving to create an eerie ambiance right up until the climactic confrontation. Anil Kapoor, Fatima Sana Shaikh, and Harshvardhan deliver riveting performances, with the latter particularly shining in his lead role. Despite being somewhat predictable, Thar should be acknowledged for its compelling dialogue, stunning cinematography, and tense action sequences.

3 The Harder They Fall (2021)

Western-themed narratives have been largely overshadowed by other genres for many decades, but some contemporary stories still manage to shine due to their innovative twist on classic elements that make the genre endearing. The Harder They Fall is one such narrative, following Nat Law, a vengeful outlaw who lost his parents at the hands of Rufus Buck. Upon learning that Buck will soon be freed from prison, Law gathers a band of outlaws to confront and bring down not only Buck but also his ruthless posse.

Bold, Stylish, and Star-Studded

Instead of other films on the list, The Harder Than Fall stands out for its abundance of shootouts, betrayals, and a climactic showdown that ties up the thrilling plot twists neatly. Under Jeymes Samuel’s skilled guidance, and featuring a predominantly Black cast, this gripping tale immerses you in an environment of revenge and brutality. Stellar performances from Jonathan Majors, Idris Elba, Regina King, Lakeith Stanfield, among others, bring the story to unprecedented heights, giving it the feel of a Sergio Leone masterpiece.

2 Rango (2011)

In the spirit of admiration, let me share my take on describing the acclaimed animated Western, Rango:

A Unique and Whimsical Adventure

The movie Rango is a charming animated film that elegantly blends elements of traditional Westerns with its unique humorous spin on the genre. This blend is masterfully executed through a lively and daring main character, brilliantly voiced by Johnny Depp. It skillfully maintains the essence of the genre’s origins while playfully challenging its stereotypes. The film showcases stunning animated backdrops, sharp-witted dialogues, an intriguing cast of side characters, and a conclusion that leaves a lasting impression.

It’s surprising how forceful the adventure of a changing-colored lizard like Rango can be, even though it won the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature. However, when discussing classic Westerns, this film often goes unnoticed.

1 The Quick and the Dead (1995)

9 Most Underrated Westerns on Netflix9 Most Underrated Westerns on Netflix9 Most Underrated Westerns on Netflix

In Western films, women have traditionally played secondary roles. However, the movie “The Quick and the Dead” breaks this pattern by focusing on a woman gunslinger, referred to as “The Lady,” who enters the gritty town of Redemption for a lethal quick-draw competition. Competing against her are ex-bandit Cort, and a young man called The Kid. The Lady’s actual objective is not just to win the tournament but to seek revenge for her father’s murder at the hands of the corrupt mayor John Herod, who organized the event.

Sam Raimi’s Hidden Western Gem

1990s Western film directed by Sam Raimi showcases his unique blend of unconventional storytelling and suspenseful ambiance. From beginning to end, the movie offers an engaging watch as it reinvents the traditional quick-draw motif with a contemporary twist, featuring snappy edits, creative visuals, and a dash of humor throughout.

Sharon Stone leads an impressive ensemble featuring Gene Hackman and Leonardo DiCaprio, both of whom enjoy portraying more rugged personas. The film The Quick and the Dead, despite underperforming at the box office initially, has since developed a dedicated fanbase.

Read More

2024-09-20 02:02