The Critic Was Canceled Too Soon, but You Can Stream it Free on Tubi

The Critic Was Canceled Too Soon, but You Can Stream it Free on Tubi

As a cinephile with a deep appreciation for the works of Ingmar Bergman and Rainer Werner Fassbinder, I can wholeheartedly say that “The Critic” was a rare gem in the world of animated television. Streaming now on Tubi, this short-lived but brilliant show offered a unique blend of humor and insight into the film industry that resonated with those who shared my passion for cinema.


Over time, it has become typical to see animated series designed for mature audiences. These cartoons frequently employ more daring humor to explore topics previously considered taboo. Before shows like “South Park” gained popularity among adults, there was an animated series that appealed to a different group of viewers. Those who were well-versed in popular culture and appreciated directors such as Ingmar Bergman and Rainer Werner Fassbinder found a show tailored to their tastes. The witty humor of “The Critic,” voiced by Jon Lovitz, was a clever satire of the film industry that resonated with the film enthusiast within us all.

On Tubi, you can watch the short-lived yet captivating series titled “The Critic“. Spanning just two seasons on ABC and FOX in the mid-90s, this show follows the zany exploits of Jay Sherman, a film critic residing in New York City. Despite his preference for classics like “Citizen Kane” and “Eraserhead“, he’s stuck reviewing modern cinema from Hollywood. Regardless of the box office hits, Jay Sherman is known for his signature line: “It stinks.

An Unlikely Lead With Cinematic Chutzpa

The Critic Was Canceled Too Soon, but You Can Stream it Free on Tubi

Jay Sherman is not typically cast as the main character, more akin to George Costanza from Seinfeld. He’s often the subject of humor, and he delivers his share of self-deprecating jokes with a Jewish touch. The Critic had many witty jokes that film enthusiasts could appreciate. For instance, there was an Eraserhead poster in his home or asking his son if he wanted to rent the 13-hour version of Berlin Alexanderplatz, these sophisticated and intellectual references were tastefully used.

Instead of watching movies by Bergman, Welles, Cocteau, or Fassbinder, Jay Sherman found himself critiquing films that were more in line with current trends, years before BoJack Horseman exposed Hollywood’s endless sequence of sequels and money-making ventures. In fact, The Critic was already poking fun at the dominant film industry patterns well before this revelation. As the host of a show titled “Coming Attractions,” Jay often had the opportunity to review films that were popular among contemporary audiences. This setup allowed for numerous film spoofs aimed at mocking many of the widely-released movies from that time period.

In the shows Jay was assigned to critique, there were numerous instances where they paid tribute to various movies. For example, Dudley Moore’s character in Arthur, Dustin Hoffman in Rainman, and Orson Welles taking on any well-paying roles were all frequently referenced. Besides the films under review, many episodes themselves were comedic takes on recently released or popular movies. The first season featured an episode called “Miserable,” which cleverly combined elements from Fatal Attraction and Misery. Additionally, several episode titles were based on witty play-ons of cinematic themes, such as “Sherman of Arabia,” “All The Duke’s Men,” and “Marathon Mensch.

A Supporting Cast of Crazies

The Critic Was Canceled Too Soon, but You Can Stream it Free on Tubi

Apart from the hilarious parodies that made The Critic stand out, another reason it’s so memorable is the remarkable supporting cast surrounding Jay Sherman. For instance, Duke Phillips, a character mimicking Ted Turner, was a power-hungry magnate who owned media and had an unquenchable thirst for ratings. He was essentially a self-proclaimed megalomaniac.

Among Jay’s funniest contrasting partners was his friend, the Australian charm Jeremy Hawke, often likened to a blend of Jeremy Irons and Mel Gibson. In the second season, Alice, portrayed as Jay’s assistant and romantic interest, made her appearance. This allowed for deeper exploration of Jay Sherman’s character, particularly his relationships. To some viewers, the arrival of Alice might seem like a dramatic shift, or a point where the show jumps “the shark,” but her presence adds a heartfelt and authentic touch to their dynamic.

As a die-hard movie enthusiast, I must say that the second season of my favorite animated series, “The Critic,” featured even more star appearances from the likes of Gene Siskel and Roger Ebert, alongside some brilliant parodies of modern cinema. However, the shift to Fox seemed to slightly dilute its original charm, particularly in certain aspects of the scriptwriting. The essence of this change can be summed up as a shift from witty jokes about Fassbinder and Bergman to humor more reminiscent of other popular animated sitcoms such as “The Simpsons.” Yet, despite this transition, “The Critic” managed to preserve its intellectual edge, setting it apart as a unique gem among the limited choices in animated shows at that time.

Gone Too Soon and Far Ahead of Its Time

The Critic Was Canceled Too Soon, but You Can Stream it Free on Tubi

Over the past few years, numerous adult-oriented animated series have emerged, featuring sophisticated themes that offer a critical perspective on the entertainment industry. Among these shows, “The Critic,” although short-lived, has set a trend for future productions. Jon Lovitz’s charisma and audacity perfectly filled the role of Jay Sherman, making the show stand out even today, despite advancements in animation and the entertainment industry. To put it simply, “The Critic” does not reek; instead, it’s worth streaming on Tubi.

Read More

2024-09-25 23:01