Cooper Koch Has Empathy For Erik Menendez’s Response To Netflix Series

As a seasoned film critic with over two decades of experience under my belt, I’ve seen it all – from blockbusters to indies, and everything in between. So when I sat down to watch “Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menéndez Story,” I approached it with an open mind, knowing that the line between fact and fiction can often blur in true-crime dramas.


The Netflix miniseries titled “Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menéndez Story” has swiftly gained popularity on the platform, yet it has also faced a significant amount of criticism since its release last week. Much of this criticism is directed towards the creative liberties taken by the series, as claimed by the real brothers involved in the story and those who believe they were driven to kill their parents due to years of physical, sexual, and emotional abuse from their father.

As criticism against the series escalates, some individuals both on and off camera are voicing their opinions. Notably, one of the younger stars taking the lead in the show has handled the backlash with respect, a commendable approach. Cooper Koch, who plays Erik Menéndez in the miniseries, recently spoke to Variety about Erik’s claims that the series was “naive and inaccurate.” Koch expressed understanding towards his real-life counterpart, acknowledging it must be difficult for him to have “the most challenging period of his life broadcasted for millions to witness.

[Erik’s response] strongly resonated with me and evoked various emotions. I share his pain, I feel it deeply. I can relate. It must be agonizing to have one’s most challenging moments broadcasted for the world to witness. It’s so exposing. I comprehend his feelings and I stand by his side. As for interacting with him and portraying his character, I was determined to conduct thorough research and delve deep within myself to portray him truthfully and authentically, as a means of showing support not only for him but also for his family and everyone who stands with him.

Not Everyone Shares Cooper Koch’s Empathetic Response

Not all the responses have been as respectful as Koch’s. Veteran performer Nathan Lane, who takes on the role of journalist Dominick Dunne, a man who Murphy named when discussing the incest theory portrayed on the show that has garnered a bulk of the series’ backlash, seemed to believe that Erik should have little to say since he likely hadn’t watched the series. It should be noted that even though both Lyle and Erik Menéndez are in prison, it would not be hard for them to obtain information about what is being portrayed on the Netflix show.

“It seems he hasn’t watched the show yet, but he’s quick to criticize and judge it. Since we don’t know how accurately his life is being portrayed in this Netflix miniseries, it’s important to take his comments with a bit of skepticism. If you haven’t seen it yourself, it would be wise to watch it before making further judgments.

Paraphrasing Option 1:

This type of series is likely to elicit varied viewpoints, particularly from those directly connected. For instance, characters such as Murphy, who appeared defensive when faced with criticism, and Lane, whose responses seemed casual, contrast starkly with their younger colleagues Koch and Chavez, who empathize with the potential hurt felt by the real individuals involved. In essence, these dynamics underscore the depth of the reactions significantly.

Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story
is currently streaming on Netflix.

Read More

2024-09-27 00:04