The Avengers Movie Just Doesn’t Hold Up After 12 Years

The Avengers Movie Just Doesn't Hold Up After 12 Years

Quick Links

  • How Has the Superhero Genre Changed Since The Avengers?
  • Is It a Bad Thing That The Avengers Feels Old?

As a child of the 90s who grew up with the excitement of comic books and the magic of superheroes, I must say that “The Avengers” holds a special place in my heart. Back then, it was a breath of fresh air, a cinematic marvel that brought together my beloved heroes on the big screen for the first time. It was more than just a movie; it was an experience that transcended the boundaries of entertainment and left an indelible mark on popular culture.


In its early stages, the superhero genre was far from what it has become today, and unquestionably, “The Avengers” raised the bar for potential storytelling. After carefully setting up each hero individually, they came together in live action to confront Loki as he wreaked havoc in New York City. It remains astounding, even after 12 years. Rewatching it now, we see simpler versions of characters that would later be fleshed out in subsequent films. The foundation for what Marvel would ultimately become can clearly be seen in “The Avengers” and the script by Joss Whedon.

In the early stages, you can clearly discern both the positive and negative outcomes when examining The Avengers from a hindsight perspective. It’s where you notice the foundational pieces coming together, but also recognize certain elements that now seem outdated as the Marvel Cinematic Universe expands. This is not a criticism of the movie itself, but rather a reflection on how it appears increasingly like a forerunner artifact within its genre as the MCU continues to grow and evolve.

For more than a decade, it’s been since Iron Man rescued New York from a nuclear threat, and reminiscing about those times can bring a sense of nostalgia, much like watching an old movie that seems blurry in the rearview mirror. Is The Avengers now seeming dated? Could Marvel be responsible? Is this a negative development? Here’s what you should understand.

Why Does The Avengers Feel Like an Old Movie Now?

2012’s cinema trip for The Avengers felt like a unique, unparalleled experience. The movie’s blend of characters was unprecedented, and it was exceptionally well-crafted. Joss Whedon’s witty script and straightforward superhero narrative style prevented the film from becoming a chaotic mix of tones. The Avengers were distinct personalities, yet they united against a common foe. This individuality became less prominent in subsequent films as the team expanded, which is understandable given the growth of any group. The Avengers was revolutionary at the time, but it seems somewhat traditional now compared to the expansive Marvel Cinematic Universe. It’s unfortunate because The Avengers skillfully combined humor and emotion, a trait that Whedon is renowned for. This balance proved more challenging in Avengers: Age of Ultron, a struggle that ultimately led to challenges for Whedon.

If people generally think that the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) has been lacking direction recently, then “The Avengers” serves as a representation of where the genre used to be, not where it’s headed. What was once a groundbreaking cinematic experience in 2012 now seems more like a classic cartoon by today’s standards in 2024. The sense of awe and excitement that made “The Avengers” so exceptional has, unfortunately, lost some of its potency over time. This is one of the elements that contributed to the film’s greatness. As superhero trends have evolved, there’s an ongoing debate about whether the true essence of what makes superheroes special has become less extraordinary as a result.

How Has the Superhero Genre Changed Since The Avengers?

The Avengers Movie Just Doesn't Hold Up After 12 YearsThe Avengers Movie Just Doesn't Hold Up After 12 YearsThe Avengers Movie Just Doesn't Hold Up After 12 YearsThe Avengers Movie Just Doesn't Hold Up After 12 Years

It seems that the novelty of combining characters in movies, particularly in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), has lost some of its initial sparkle. Over time, each genre reaches a certain level of maturity, and replicating comic book storylines directly on the big screen isn’t always feasible or desirable. The success of Marvel with films like Avengers: Endgame is undeniable, but even the original The Avengers stands as a significant milestone that perhaps didn’t require such extensive follow-ups. Introducing more characters was a logical progression for the MCU, but it shifted the focus from personal team dynamics to simply showcasing different heroes together on screen.

Following the airport brawl in “Captain America: Civil War”, it seemed that Marvel had exhausted their unique charm. While it was enjoyable watching the characters assemble in “Avengers: Endgame”, the fight between Iron Man, Captain America, Thor, and Thanos held a more captivating appeal. Introducing additional fighters into the fray tends to result in faceless CGI adversaries, numerous characters whose only power is fighting effectively, and maintaining a smooth flow of action. The Avengers were distinct because they were identifiable, as seen when Captain America leveraged his seniority to command police forces and his team.

Is It a Bad Thing That The Avengers Feels Old?

The Avengers Movie Just Doesn't Hold Up After 12 YearsThe Avengers Movie Just Doesn't Hold Up After 12 YearsThe Avengers Movie Just Doesn't Hold Up After 12 YearsThe Avengers Movie Just Doesn't Hold Up After 12 Years

There isn’t a genre that has grown as rapidly as the superhero genre. That growth demanded higher stakes, but the superhero genre can only go so far before it repeats itself. There’s always a more dangerous enemy until there isn’t anymore. Raising the stakes too high sacrifices the charm that The Avengers had in spades. Every franchise’s starting point will feel different from where it ended up. But for how long superheroes have dominated the box office, to have seen a real lack of narrative variation highlights the focus on consistency over quality.

The fact that later Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) projects lack the unique charm found in Joss Whedon’s “The Avengers” doesn’t imply that it should have remained the peak of Marvel’s potential. Instead, the essence of what made “The Avengers” captivating seems to have been lost as more heroes were added to the mix. While evolution is crucial for growth, Marvel appears to have strayed from the elements that initially made “The Avengers” so influential and groundbreaking, as it became just another superhero team-up film in a series. Put simply, “The Avengers” held a special significance because of when and where it was released – being the first of its kind to shape the face of movies for an entire generation.

Regrettably, the unique charm that made The Avengers stand out might have waned slightly as similar narratives have been repeated frequently. It’s normal for this to happen, yet it doesn’t diminish the sadness. For now, superheroes continue to save the day, but should they ever fail, The Avengers will remain a memorable team-up that met audience expectations, albeit appearing somewhat old-fashioned after 12 years. You can watch The Avengers on Disney+.

Read More

Sorry. No data so far.

2024-10-07 04:01