Critics Were Wrong About Tom Cruises Vanilla Sky

Critics Were Wrong About Tom Cruises Vanilla Sky

Quick Links

  • Tom Cruise’s 1999 Erotic Thriller Is an Excellent Companion Piece to Vanilla Sky
  • Vanilla Sky Has to Be Seen More Than Once

As a cinephile who has spent countless hours immersed in the intricate worlds of films, I must admit that “Vanilla Sky” is a movie that truly resonates with me on multiple levels. Like a fine wine, it tastes better with age and repeated viewings.


Tom Cruise has consistently demonstrated a readiness throughout his acting career to leverage his fame for complex projects and roles. This began with his critically acclaimed portrayal of Vietnam veteran Ron Kovic in the 1989 biographical drama film, “Born on the Fourth of July.” Furthermore, Cruise demonstrated boldness by taking on unconventional characters, such as the misogynistic dating coach Frank T.J. Mackey in the 1999 drama film, “Magnolia,” and the ruthless assassin Vincent in the 2004 thriller film, “Collateral.” These roles challenged audience perceptions by presenting him as characters that were not typically sympathetic.

This bold career path, perhaps best illustrated in the 2001 psychological thriller film “Vanilla Sky”, features Tom Cruise as a self-indulgent New York playboy. His life of freedom and reality are drastically altered when David Aames, his character, undergoes a horrific car accident that leaves him disfigured. Similar to other thought-provoking films like “Memento” and “Mulholland Drive”, “Vanilla Sky” challenges viewers to think along with David, whose subsequent battle to discern fantasy from reality causes him to question the authenticity of his own existence. This film is a remake of the 1997 Spanish thriller “Open Your Eyes”.

Although it was generally under-valued by both audiences and critics upon its initial release, Vanilla Sky has since been recognized as one of Tom Cruise’s most visionary films. This is particularly evident in the way that, much like the character David, Cruise seems to have attained a form of immortality through his remarkably youthful appearance.

Vanilla Sky Exists Between Dreams and Reality

To fully grasp Vanilla Sky, it’s beneficial to concentrate on the authenticity of Tom Cruise’s character, David Aames, as a genuine individual who inhabited the real world. The film sets up the ambiguity between fact and illusion from its striking opening scene, where he seemingly drives his Ferrari into crowded Times Square without encountering any people.

David resides in an apartment beyond Central Park West, home to bachelor David, the successor of a publishing dynasty, who casually engages in a romantic entanglement with actress Julie, although Julie, portrayed by Cameron Diaz, perceives their relationship quite differently. During a festive gathering at his residence commemorating a birthday, he encounters Sofia, an enchanting woman played by Penélope Cruz, and spends the night at her apartment, seemingly captivated by her and potentially falling in love.

David’s end is signaled by an encounter with Julie, who was stalking him, outside Sofia’s apartment building the next day. Once he got into Julie’s car, she expressed her jealousy towards David through a long outburst about the value of commitment. In a tragic turn of events, Julie intentionally caused a crash, which resulted in both her death and severe disfigurement for David. Although he lived through the accident, no plastic surgery could restore his good looks, leaving him to wear a prosthetic mask as he endured constant pain.

In a different version of events, a downcast and secluded David crosses paths with Sofia at a club. Sofia seems to recoil from what she perceives as David’s disguised persona. The story comes to an end for him outside the club, where a drunk and overdosed David tumbles onto the sidewalk before slipping into a dreamlike coma-like state, immersing himself in a world that his mind has created on its own.

Tom Cruise’s 1999 Erotic Thriller Is an Excellent Companion Piece to Vanilla Sky

Critics Were Wrong About Tom Cruises Vanilla SkyCritics Were Wrong About Tom Cruises Vanilla SkyCritics Were Wrong About Tom Cruises Vanilla SkyCritics Were Wrong About Tom Cruises Vanilla Sky

Vanilla Sky shares a resemblance with Tom Cruise’s 1999 psychological drama film Eyes Wide Shut, as both movies delve into the complexities of human perception of reality. In Eyes Wide Shut, Tom Cruise portrays Bill Harford, a New York doctor who appears to have a content marriage. However, when his wife, played by Nicole Kidman, admits to him that she once considered an affair, Bill’s grasp on reality weakens. This confession sends Bill on an adventure where he explores a hidden sex society, investigates what he believes is a murderous plot, and ultimately questions the nature of his own existence.

In the movie Vanilla Sky, the secret that Tom Cruise’s character, David, discovers is connected to his dream-like condition and a company called Life Extension, which freezes terminally ill patients until a cure can be found. Similar to how Eyes Wide Shut presents Bill with the challenge of distinguishing between actuality and his deep-seated impulses, David struggles to believe what he sees and thinks as more proof emerges that his existence may be nothing more than a figment of his imagination.

Both Bill and David learn that dreams coming true can lead to terrible outcomes. For David, this revelation involves cryonic preservation and the understanding that the perfect world he’s been experiencing since leaving reality is actually controlled by his lucid dream state, which gradually turns into a nightmare for him. Unlike Bill, who gives up on exploring the secret society due to fear and coercion, David, after finding out the truth about his existence, becomes determined to achieve immortality, even though he’s lost everyone and everything he cared about in his past life.

Vanilla Sky Has to Be Seen More Than Once

Critics Were Wrong About Tom Cruises Vanilla SkyCritics Were Wrong About Tom Cruises Vanilla SkyCritics Were Wrong About Tom Cruises Vanilla Sky

Although the movie “Vanilla Sky,” earning over $200 million globally and marking Tom Cruise’s ninth domestic box office hit surpassing $100 million, was a financial triumph upon its release, it was met with considerable skepticism and disapproval by both audiences and critics. This seems to be primarily because of Cruise’s portrayal that many found unappealing and the movie’s intricate narrative.

Upon rewatching Vanilla Sky, it becomes increasingly clear that the acting of Tom Cruise, Penélope Cruz, and Cameron Diaz adds a strong layer of emotional authenticity, outshining the movie’s fantastical aspects, even when compared to its original Spanish version, Open Your Eyes.

Similarly to the Matrix film franchise, Vanilla Sky also leaves a lasting impact by masterfully portraying the unsettling, lingering dread that our choices and destinies may be manipulated by an unseen reality. In essence, we might find ourselves as conscious entities trapped in a simulated world, much like a brain in a vat or a lab rat. You can stream Vanilla Sky on Paramount+ and Prime Video.

Read More

Sorry. No data so far.

2024-10-28 00:33