Dune: Prophecy’s First Episodes Have Screened, And Critics Mostly Agree On HBO’s ‘Frequently Stellar’ Prequel Series

Dune: Prophecy’s First Episodes Have Screened, And Critics Mostly Agree On HBO’s ‘Frequently Stellar’ Prequel Series

As a longtime fan of the Dune series, I have eagerly anticipated every new addition to this expansive universe. With my heart still racing from the visual grandeur of Denis Villeneuve’s cinematic masterpiece, I was more than ready to dive into the HBO prequel series, Dune: Prophecy.


The eagerly anticipated sequel to “Dune,” titled “Dune: Part Two,” was one of the most anticipated films in the 2024 movie lineup. Given this excitement, it’s no wonder fans are ecstatic about a series that will serve as a bridge while we await further information on “Dune 3.” The HBO prequel series, titled “Dune: Prophecy,” takes place 10,000 years before the birth of Timothée Chalamet’s character Paul Atreides. This series focuses on Valya and Tula Harkonnen as they lay the groundwork for the legendary sisterhood of the Bene Gesserit. Critics have been given a sneak peek at four out of the six episodes, and their initial reactions suggest that they are generally satisfied with the backstory being presented.

The television series “Dune: Prophecy” is set to air on HBO and can also be streamed with a Max subscription starting November 17. Emily Watson and Olivia Williams will portray the enigmatic Harkonnen sisters, while Travis Fimmel takes on the role of the enigmatic soldier Desmond Hart. Mike Reyes from TopMob has previewed some episodes and believes that this talented cast and HBO’s knack for creating immersive worlds will help make the anticipation for “Dune Messiah” more bearable, according to his own words.

I’m confident that the upcoming series “Dune: Prophecy” will make the anticipation for “Dune: Messiah” more bearable. With a stellar cast from top to bottom, and visually stunning world-building reminiscent of an HBO production, I can hardly wait to see how it all unfolds.

According to Chase Hutchinson of The Wrap, the upcoming series “Prophecy” is expected to be well-received by fans of the franchise when it airs in 2024. Interestingly, it’s also designed to be enjoyable for those who are not familiar with the intricate world created by Denis Villeneuve. The initial introduction sets up the narrative smoothly for the sisters’ story to follow. In summary, Hutchinson notes that the series is well-structured in this regard.

Although it lacks the extensive scale and stunning visuals of its predecessors, this series excels in its thematic depth, consistently outperforming others by effectively distinguishing itself from the impressive movies that came before. It offers a captivating portrayal of power corruption and the individuals struggling to influence the course of time. While it may appear somewhat stage-like, it’s universally well-executed acting makes it a compelling choice to keep you occupied until the films resume with Dune Messiah.

According to Belen Edwards from Mashable, the series truly shines after the initial explanations, offering viewers a more profound insight into the Bene Gesserit and their surroundings. Furthermore, be prepared for the occasional appearance of those colossal sandworms. Edwards further notes that…

Dune: Prophecy Unveils an Enticing Sci-Fi Saga with a Wide Range of Appeal

Ben Travers from IndieWire awards the series a ‘C’, acknowledging that although the plot is “odd and enigmatic”, the show Dune: Prophecy seems to mimic the style of Game of Thrones. It’s uncertain if this series possesses the longevity needed to keep viewers engaged. In simpler terms, Travers suggests that while the story is intriguing and mysterious, it appears the show is trying to recreate the feel of ‘Game of Thrones’, but its potential for lasting appeal remains questionable.

In contrast to the films, which skillfully made Frank Herbert’s intricate world-building digestible, the Dune series seems to be grappling with seamlessly incorporating its expository elements. The heavy narration, coupled with repetitive dialogue to highlight confusing or crucial plot points, often results in dialogues that feel awkward, even for accomplished actors like Watson, Olivia Williams (portraying Valya’s sister and Sister Tula), and Mark Strong (the Emperor) to convincingly deliver. The series does reuse some of the films’ visually appealing innovations, such as the worms gliding across the desert and the armor that illuminates blue or red during combat, but it fails to introduce unique visual elements of its own.

Amy West from GamesRadar contends that although there are hints of what made the Dune films captivating, Prophecy mostly misses the mark, even with a remarkable acting job by Olivia Williams. The series is burdened by an excessive number of characters and a convoluted universe that, contrary to another critic’s viewpoint, remains inaccessible to those unfamiliar with the narrative. West assigns the series 2 out of 5 stars, commenting:

This complex series not only makes it challenging to keep up with the constantly evolving relationships, but it also overloads viewers by delving into Herbert’s intricate universe, encompassing artificial intelligence, revenants, and The Agony. The eerie touch provided by The Agony, where characters engage with spectral apparitions of the dead, certainly adds a chilling aspect to Prophecy. However, for casual fans or newcomers to the Dune franchise, it can be an overwhelming experience. It’s hard to imagine how a novice would manage to follow along effectively.

Based on four of the six episodes of Dune: Prophecy being viewed by critics so far, it seems like there’s a lot for fans to explore as they anticipate more from this franchise. Currently, Rotten Tomatoes is reporting an overall positive response with 74% approval from 27 reviews. Make sure to tune in yourself, as the series premieres at 9 p.m. ET on Sunday, November 17, on HBO and can also be streamed on Max.

Read More

Sorry. No data so far.

2024-11-12 23:39