Why Michael Said No In The Deposition: The Office’s Controversial Scene, Explained

by

As a long-time fan of “The Office,” I must say that the show took a slightly different turn after Michael Scott left Scranton for good. Don’t get me wrong; the series still had its moments, but it was never quite the same without our beloved regional manager. That being said, the writers managed to pull off an impressive comeback in the final season by tying up loose ends and giving us one last hurrah with our favorite characters.

Season 4 of the popular NBC sitcom “The Office” boasts some of its finest moments, with standout episodes like “Dinner Party” and “Fun Run.” This season marks the start of Pam and Jim’s romantic relationship, culminating in their near-engagement by the end. Additionally, Michael Scott’s assistant, Ryan Howard, experiences a rapid rise before ultimately facing legal trouble and ending up incarcerated.

Even though I thoroughly enjoyed the impressive array of entertainment, there were a couple of instances that left me scratching my head – like the Michael Scott scene in “The Deposition.” You see, as a fan, it was tough to watch Michael, our beloved Dunder Mifflin Scranton boss, navigate between his vengeful girlfriend, Jan (Melora Hardin), and the higher-ups who had just let her go from the company. Under normal circumstances, I’d expect him to side with his girlfriend; but when push came to shove, he chose a different path. He defended the brass against Jan’s vicious, slanderous accusations. In the end, when asked if the company showed disrespect towards its employees, Michael said “Absolutely not,” thereby supporting the organization and potentially damaging Jan’s case.

The question arises, why did Michael betray his girlfriend? To put it simply, we can’t say for certain. Michael himself questions his actions at the end of the episode, admitting, “Why did I do it? I don’t know.” However, hints are dropped throughout the episode that suggest a complex backstory and the boss’s hidden motivations. For instance, he says, “You expect to get betrayed by your company. You never expect to get betrayed by your girlfriend.” Let’s delve deeper into Michael’s contentious phone call in “The Deposition” and uncover what might have pushed him to make such a move.

What Happens in The Office Season 4, Episode 12, The Deposition

The Deposition” is the 8th episode in Season 4, which was cut short with only 14 episodes due to production disruptions. The season features several two-part episodes, making the exact number of episodes a bit tricky to determine. In this episode, the focus is on Michael and Jan as they travel to New York City’s Dunder Mifflin headquarters for Jan’s deposition. This is part of her effort to secure a $4 million settlement from the company in relation to a wrongful termination claim, although discussing specific figures can seem somewhat impolite.

We see Jan groom Michael with rehearsed answers, but once he’s in the chair being questioned, it doesn’t take him long to go off script. The momentum shifts back and forth as the prosecution and defense lawyers grill the helpless lover and employee who has found themselves caught in the crossfire. The topless picture of Jan surfaces at one point, pushing her to reveal Michael’s personal diary to bolster her case. In the end, Michael is forced to choose sides, and he opts to state that Dunder Mifflin is a good company that doesn’t prey on its employees.

Indeed, as events transpire, Pam endeavors to silence the boisterous Kelly by grooming Jim into a proficient ping-pong player capable of besting Darryl. However, this secondary tale serves more as amusement, while the main action plays out in New York City.

Why did Michael go against Jan in the deposition?

It isn’t explicitly stated why Michael turns against Jan, but there are some hints that guide us towards the answer. One of these clues is his diary; when a vacation photo of them is accidentally shared, it forces Jan to disclose Michael’s private journals (a mistake on Michael’s part). However, this doesn’t alter the fact that she is betraying her boyfriend by exposing his deepest thoughts to an audience that includes their mutual enemy, Toby. Additionally, we learn in the episode that while working under Jan, she frequently gave Michael unfair performance evaluations.

Beyond the evident aspects, there’s a deeper layer of meaning here. It seems Michael’s hidden feelings might play a significant role. Despite learning just beforehand that David Wallace didn’t seriously consider him as Jan’s replacement after she was fired, Michael remains loyal to the company that has been kind to him throughout his career. Additionally, recalling Season 5 Episode 5, “Employee Transfer,” when Holly (played by Amy Ryan) suggested they should part ways, Michael reacted frantically by proposing a return to Jan, despite his dislike for her.

Deep within him, Michael is convinced that Jan exhibits abusive behavior. Yet, he holds a different perception about Dunder Mifflin – he believes it to be a faithful employer run by fair-minded individuals. This belief was reinforced when David Wallace extended an earnest apology at the end of the episode. Even though David didn’t explicitly say those words, Michael instinctively complimented him, hinting at his positive opinion. Although we may never know for certain, it appears that one of the reasons Michael chose to challenge Jan in the deposition was because he felt a stronger sense of loyalty and trust towards Dunder Mifflin, sensing it as a more reliable force in his life compared to Jan.

Why did Michael leave The Office in the show?

Although Michael Scott remained faithful to Dunder Mifflin throughout, he ended up parting ways with the company not just once, but twice – and each time, it was on his own accord. In the 18th episode of Season 5, titled “New Boss,” Michael resigns due to certain work-related modifications (which I’ll discuss later). He then ventures out to establish his own paper company as a rival to Dunder Mifflin. This venture doesn’t last long and seems destined for failure. However, before the season comes to an end, Michael manages to utilize this new business endeavor to regain his previous position at Dunder Mifflin.

After that point, Scott remains steadfast throughout Season 6. However, it’s not until midway through Season 7 when Michael’s former girlfriend, Holly Flax, reappears following her transfer to another office in Season 5. This event sparks him to pursue her, go on dates with her, propose to her, and ultimately move away together for a life of bliss in the Rockies with his partner.

Did The Office go downhill after Michael left?

To put it another way, did Michael’s leaving affect “The Office”? In essence, yes, but with a twist: while Michael Scott is undeniably crucial to the series, his absence also brings about change. The characters often rely on his unique, unpredictable management style for their development. However, this departure presents challenges in maintaining the show’s coherence, especially during season 8 where some episodes struggle, giving the impression that the show might be losing its momentum.

In Season 9, the creators of “The Office” skillfully reversed the show’s fortunes by going all out, especially since it was their final season. They tied up loose ends and emphasized the fictional documentary aspect, thereby rekindling interest in the Scranton office staff for a farewell tour. The finale, one of the series’ highest-rated episodes, served as a fitting conclusion to the series.

Who replaced Michael Scott in Season 5?

Initially, when Michael Scott departs from his job, Charles Miner (played by Idris Elba) takes over. The fresh manager who succeeds Jan makes a bold entrance at Scranton, leading Michael to resign and engage in competition with his employer. This leaves Miner managing daily operations at Scranton, struggling unsuccessfully to find a replacement for Michael. Eventually, Miner and David Wallace are compelled to negotiate a deal where they buy out Michael’s company and reinstate him as manager for a few more years.

In the long run, Michael departs Scranton permanently, but this occurs in Season 7. His departure is followed by a move to Boulder, Colorado, where he resides with Holly. Upon his exit, Deangelo Vickers, portrayed by Will Ferrell, steps in as his replacement. While Ferrell served as a refreshing change for the writers, his character eventually moves on, just like the many other candidates featured in the two-part Season 7 finale entitled “Search Committee.

In the initial scenes of Season 8, it’s disclosed that James Spader’s character, Robert California, has been appointed as Dunder Mifflin Scranton’s new top executive. However, California’s tenure in Michael’s position is brief. This power-hungry and unsettling figure swiftly surveys his new workplace before setting out to persuade his superior, Jo Bennett (played by Kathy Bates), to hand over her role as CEO to him. Upon achieving this transition of authority, California selects Andy Bernard to take over Michael Scott’s position.

Read More

2024-11-19 18:30