Paradise Star Reveals Shocking Twist and Teases More Surprises Ahead

by

[This story contains major spoilers from the fourth episode of Paradise, “Agent Billy Pace.”]

This past week’s episode of Paradise featured a tranquil sequence, subtly suggesting that Agent Billy Pace harbors secrets yet undisclosed.

A peaceful scene in this week’s episode of Paradise subtly implied that Agent Billy Pace has a hidden past or character traits not yet revealed to the public.

Two months into my life in what they call Paradise – this subterranean sanctuary that shielded its 25,000 inhabitants from an apocalyptic event thought to have wiped out the world above – I found myself at a bar, sharing a drink with another agent, Jon Beavers.

Xavier’s spouse didn’t manage to reach Paradise, which is where Xavier now resides with their two kids. The return of some semblance of normality only intensifies Xavier’s sorrow for the life he once had. However, Billy offers a different perspective. He shares that in his past, he never enjoyed a drink with a friend at a bar, and if Xavier knew about certain actions of his, he might not be sharing this moment with him.

Moving on to the current situation and reminiscing about our previous chat, Billy confides in Xavier that he will reveal all his actions. With tension running high throughout Paradise following the murder of the surviving U.S. President (portrayed by James Marsden), Billy feels compelled to confess to his dearest friend. However, fate has other plans as Billy doesn’t survive until the next day.

In the concluding part of episode 4 from “This Is Us” creator Dan Fogelman’s unexpectedly intricate political thriller, an unforeseen culprit takes the life of character Billy. The perpetrator was none other than Jane, his girlfriend and fellow agent, who secretly worked as a hired gun for Sinatra – the wealthy figurehead of Paradise, portrayed by Julianne Nicholson. It was when Billy opposed Sinatra that Jane orchestrated his assassination.

Dan Fogelman, as Beavers explains to The Hollywood Reporter, has a unique approach through Billy’s character. He wonders if we are defined by our greatest mistakes, rather than just being the total of them. In a broader context, Beavers adds that what makes this show relevant is its ability to pose questions that we all hesitate to consider deeply in the recesses of our minds.

In the “Agent Billy Pace” episode, it was disclosed that another significant turn of events unfolded after the twist-filled three-episode debut – there is indeed life beyond Paradise. Up until this point, Sinatra had led everyone to believe their communication lines were damaged, causing those in the bunker to assume there was no surviving life above ground. Even scientists were sent out on a rescue mission, but unfortunately, they never returned.

Another glimpse into the past illuminated Billy’s significant involvement in their destiny and his tight bond with Sinatra. Prior to his stint in prison for murdering an abusive relative as a young boy, Billy was drawn into a mercenary training program following his release. In Paradise, where he cultivated a relationship with Jane and started a family with Xavier and his kids, Billy seemed to have a clean slate; however, Sinatra exploited Billy’s past for her own purposes, compelling him to carry out a murder mission targeting certain scientists. Just before taking the life of one scientist, Billy was informed that things up above were not as they appeared. Contrary to Sinatra’s description, it wasn’t a “third-world planet”; instead, they discovered that there was indeed life, and the air could be breathed.

With Billy now passed away, Beavers discusses potential secrets that might remain hidden with him, and whether we’ve truly witnessed the final chapter of his story in Paradise. He hints at both surprises and solutions coming up in the murder-mystery series, which eerily resonates as it grapples with climate change and power issues. Regarding the central mystery, he assures us, “We can expect a fulfilling ‘who done it’ resolution in the end.

***

It appears that Billy has met a tragic end, but given Dan Fogelman’s knack for unexpected plot twists, Paradise might not be as it appears. Could you clarify if this marks the final appearance of Billy?

I can neither verify nor negate if Billy will return in the final episode. However, he does feature prominently in significant flashback sequences in the upcoming episode. It’s natural to wonder if this could be his last appearance, especially with Dan Fogelman’s storytelling style. Since a large portion of the narrative takes place in the past, even I am uncertain about the fate of certain characters. Billy is absent from episodes six and seven, and I can’t confirm or deny his presence in the finale. The writers are currently developing some fantastic scripts for season two, but I’m unable to disclose any information regarding Billy’s potential return as Dan has a knack for weaving complex time-travel elements into the plot. Marsden continues to be a popular and impactful character through his flashback appearances.

It seems like there’s still a possibility of a second season (since it hasn’t been officially confirmed yet). Dan Fogelman mentioned that he has a three-season plan for Paradise. When the show was proposed to you, did you know about just the first season or were you made aware of more?

I didn’t become familiar with Season 1 until I began working. Looking back, during my auditions, I knew very little about it. With each subsequent round of auditions, I was given more scripts and background information. When I eventually got the job, I received new scripts every week, which not only helped me understand Billy better but also the other characters I interacted with. This made one wonder if the previous episode’s dialogues were sincere. In essence, we were discovering the storyline much like the audience for most of the season.

At the conclusion of the fourth installment, Billy meets his demise; however, prior to that, we delve into his past and he plays a significant role for the entire hour. When you received the script, did you have the opportunity to discuss it with Dan or ask any questions regarding it?

Absolutely, I accepted the role. Dan is outstanding for numerous reasons. Not only was I chosen to portray a real-life war hero in our miniseries, “The Long Road Home“, but I’ve also been offered a captivating part by Kevin Costner for his “Horizon” series. Competing against such established actors, the role of Billy is the most complex and layered character I’ve ever received. Besides Dan being exceptionally talented to write it, he was supportive during the audition process as well. When a role is this compelling on paper, I felt compelled to vie for it despite the formidable competition. Dan himself provided praise for my performance and saw potential in me, which meant a lot coming from him. He creates fully-formed characters and still encourages actors to add their own touch, which I believe is what makes him exceptional. He’s not only intelligent but also emotionally driven.

I’m extremely fortunate that among all the potential choices, it turned out to be me who was chosen, as he fiercely advocated for me and overpowered some more prominent, attractive contenders. I’m deeply appreciative of his efforts. Our partnership was collaborative, but from the beginning, he had a distinct vision in mind.

Could you share any of those shiny faces who also went out for Billy?

I won’t disclose the names, but there are actors I highly respect. Success in this industry often comes at pivotal moments when someone decides to take a risk on you. Dan Fogelman took such a chance with me, and I can only hope I lived up to his expectations.

Actors frequently express gratitude for receiving a backstory, as is the case with Billy. There are numerous mysteries surrounding him. While it appears Sinatra (Julianne Nicholson) doesn’t leave him much room for decision-making, he still must deal with the consequences of his actions. So, what truly defines Billy? Is he the jovial uncle to Xavier’s children or a ruthless assassin? Is he always manipulating situations? Why was he so vulnerable around Jane? In essence, this episode shed light on how to portray Billy – a complex character with hidden depths and multiple facets.

I find that question captivating! The intrigue lies in the fact that amidst the thrilling whirlwind of a murder mystery where suspense is maintained every other minute, Dan embodies his character flawlessly. These characters aren’t merely fictional figures; they are complex individuals with desires, dreams, anxieties, and concealed pasts. Interestingly, Billy finds himself in Paradise, an underground shelter, where everyone else confronts their worst nightmares. For him, it presents a sort of second opportunity. It’s almost like a dream come true, offering a chance to reset. This is the closest he’s ever been to normalcy. Thus, when he chooses to conceal things from his friend Xavier, it’s an attempt to safeguard this opportunity for a better life.

It seems to me that what stands out about Dan’s actions is his question: can we transcend the weight of our past mistakes, are we capable of redemption? Can someone burdened by wrongdoings find a way to make amends and become a positive influence; to be a caring uncle, a reliable friend, even a loving partner? Is it possible to start anew after errors have been made? In other words, is there room for second chances in life?

I found immense joy in responding to your queries by sharing aspects of myself and struggles I often confront. Recently, I’ve become an uncle in my personal life, which has significantly altered my perspective on the world. I can’t help but desire a better place for someone I cherish deeply. This emotional state causes me to reflect on the past while also looking towards the future. It’s incredibly engaging when a character’s experiences resonate with this feeling — not just that, but there’s also a captivating murder mystery with unexpected twists every 10 minutes!

What does the script say about what Billy discovered when he ventured beyond Paradise, a mystery central to the show? Well, it’s been established that Billy can survive outside and even breathe the air. Furthermore, his victim claimed she encountered survivors. So, how was this scene depicted in the script regarding Billy’s findings?

Previously, a significant figure – a survivor – was found among the scientists, suggesting that there might still be populations living on Earth’s surface. This discovery implies that the information provided by Sinatra and those attempting to maintain order below is far from complete. As a fan, I eagerly anticipate season two delving into Earth’s surface and what remains of civilization. These developments are both captivating in their sci-fi, not-too-distant future context, yet they are also brimming with the vibrant themes that Dan enjoys exploring. They present an opportunity to examine human behavior under extreme circumstances. The prospect of this scene was both nerve-wracking to discuss and portray, as it delves into the heart of what lies ahead for the show while also touching on the questions we all have and the secrets we all harbor. All in all, it’s intriguing material.

The resilience of survivors in this series evokes thoughts of the communities in “The Walking Dead,” although that series takes place after a zombie apocalypse. In contrast, this Paradise climate catastrophe seems alarmingly relatable to real-life scenarios. I was curious to learn about the research that went into developing this show’s storyline, and Dan mentioned that he spent three weeks with experts and writers to ensure its authenticity. Could you tell me more about the research behind crafting this narrative?

To some extent, I’m unsure about the identities of those they interacted with. Some individuals preferred to remain confidential, yet they conducted thorough investigations. Dan disclosed alarming information, such as casually questioning experts, “By any chance, if you’re correct, where should I relocate my family?” and they provided specific responses. At this point, everything is largely speculation, but what sets this program apart is its boldness in posing questions that we all secretly ponder. It delves into the realms of power, who gets to decide crucial matters when lives are at risk, and who can claim safety when our own security becomes uncertain.

In the past, creating a series set in a dystopian apocalypse usually meant placing it at least 20 or 30 years into the future. However, Dan’s show seems to be unfolding within less than a decade from now. This gives off a sense of surprise, like “That can’t be!” I believe this might unsettle viewers as it becomes more challenging to deny the reality portrayed when it’s so close to our present time.

Given that you’re situated in Los Angeles, the current wildfires make the storyline particularly relevant since it delves into themes like evacuation, abandoning possessions, and survivor’s guilt. Have you managed to gauge the response from L.A. residents regarding your work?

During filming, I had the privilege of working with an exceptionally talented actor named Krys Marshall, who portrays top Agent Robinson, the president’s lover. Unfortunately, due to wildfires in Topanga, she was forced to evacuate her home. From her ring camera, she watched as the flames approached minute by minute. Fortunately, her house remained standing, but not everyone in her neighborhood was so fortunate.

Krys’s performance is incredibly moving, and her humanity shines through, especially in how she brought us all closer together following this tragic event. She refocused our efforts on telling this story as a call to action for humanity rather than a political statement. In my opinion, if we don’t recognize that we are all in the same boat regarding climate change, then I fear we may be living in a state of denial. After all, there is only one planet Earth!

Over the past few weeks, as we’ve started sharing this story, it has become increasingly clear that Mother Nature is responding, and she will continue to do so more loudly and clearly if we don’t unite in some way. I can only hope that this shared experience brings us together and helps us take action against climate change.

How about discussing the enigmatic number Xavier discovered scribbled on the president’s cigarette? There seems to be strong implications suggesting it’s a plane’s registration number. Can you provide the solution for this puzzle?

I do know what that number is, and you guys all will soon.

What should we make of the significance of that number?

Let me express that all the fan theories I’ve encountered are remarkably insightful. They match or even surpass the theories I initially developed after my first read-through of the season. Each piece you’re examining carries weight, but if you believe you’ve identified the culprit, I’m ready to wager $100 that your guess isn’t spot on.

In this version, the sentence structure is simplified and made more concise while maintaining the original meaning. The use of “express” instead of “say” adds a touch of formality, and “encountered” gives a sense of exploration or discovery in reading fan theories. The phrase “if you think you know who did it” is rephrased to “if you believe you’ve identified the culprit,” which is more direct and easier to understand. Finally, “I’m willing to bet you $100 you’re not quite right” is restated as “I’m ready to wager $100 that your guess isn’t spot on,” making the intention clearer while still preserving the playful tone of the original sentence.

Is Sinatra a total villain at this point, or is there hope for her still?

I’m incredibly fortunate to be a member of this exceptional cast, with Sterling K. Brown leading the way in terms of both leadership and acting prowess. A significant factor contributing to the show’s success is his presence. Not only is he an outstanding actor, but he’s also a remarkable individual, which speaks volumes. As both star and executive producer, his influence extends throughout the cast, attracting talented actors like James Marsden and Julianne Nicholson who don’t just join the show but deliver performances that are truly exceptional, particularly in the case of Ms. Nicholson. The creative freedom we have under Dan’s direction allows us to challenge the audience by making it impossible to determine who is good or bad. If you’ve seen Julianne’s performance as Sinatra, despite her character doing things that I find questionable, if not downright unforgivable, the empathy she conveys through her portrayal makes deciding between good and evil an impossible task.

It seems the challenging aspect of such situations for us as individuals often lies in instances where solutions aren’t straightforward or definitive. Contrary to expectations, this narrative won’t end with a classic ‘whodunit’ resolution that clearly identifies guilt or innocence. Instead, it appears we’ll all be left grappling with shades of good and evil.

Is that answer coming by the end of the season?

You betcha. Hang onto the edge of your seat, it’s really good.

***

The initial four installments of the series “Paradise” can be watched on Hulu, and fresh episodes are released every Tuesday. Check out THR’s post-premiere analysis with the show’s creator, Dan Fogelman.

Read More

2025-02-05 02:27