Supernatural’s 3 Endings: Which One Is Truly The Best?

As a dedicated fan, I’ve followed the extraordinary journey of “Supernatural” for fifteen seasons and witnessed several attempts at spin-offs. Among the three different conclusions, one stands head and shoulders above the rest. Conceived by Eric Kripke, this captivating series chronicled the adventures of brothers Sam (Jared Padalecki) and Dean (Jensen Ackles) Winchester as they roamed the country, combatting supernatural entities. Initially, Kripke envisioned a narrative spanning just three seasons, but his imagination expanded to encompass five. However, “Supernatural” defied expectations, running for an impressive fifteen seasons, even after Kripke parted ways with the show following season 5.

As a devoted aficionado of all things cinematic, I can confidently affirm that “Supernatural” stands out with its captivating mix of terror, laughter, and emotional depth. Initially, Supernatural unfolded as a tale about two siblings on a quest to find their missing father and avenge their mother’s death at the hands of a yellow-eyed fiend. Over time, this series evolved into an intricate tapestry of supernatural lore, with Sam and Dean Winchester confronting not only the Devil but also God themselves. Supernatural’s earliest epic saga reached its climax at the conclusion of its fifth season, while the grand finale that marked the end of this extraordinary journey was finally unveiled at the close of season 15.

Supernatural’s 3 Different Endings Explained

Supernatural Season 5, Season 15, & The Winchesters Season 1 All Delivered Endings Of A Sort

In the fourth season of Supernatural, after observing several seasons of Sam and Dean’s monster-hunting adventures, the angel Castiel (Misha Collins) entered the scene, significantly altering the show’s course. Despite being manipulated pieces in the apocalyptic conflict between Heaven and Hell, Sam and Dean struggled to preserve the world and retain their own freedom. This grand tale reached its climax in the thrilling season 5 finale “Swan Song,” where Sam made a selfless choice by diving into Hell, allowing Dean to lead a somewhat normal existence thereafter.

In contrast to “Swan Song,” which most viewers consider one of the show’s finest episodes, the season 15 finale of “Supernatural,” titled “Carry On,” sparked much debate among fans. Following their victory over God in the previous episode, Sam and Dean set out on a seemingly ordinary vampire hunt. Unfortunately, during the fight, Dean is fatally wounded by a spike and succumbs to his injuries, leading to an unsatisfying conclusion for a character who had made so many sacrifices. It’s left to Sam to carry on with the rest of his life in relative peace before eventually reuniting with his brother in Heaven.

In the series “Supernatural” spin-off, “The Winchesters,” which was initially presented as a prequel focusing on Sam and Dean’s parents, Mary Campbell (Meg Donnelly) and John Winchester (Drake Rodger), an unexpected epilogue was added to Dean Winchester’s story. This twist in the series finale saw Dean appearing from Heaven, revealing that the events portrayed in “The Winchesters” unfolded in a parallel universe. This conclusion added a new dimension to Dean’s narrative, reinforcing his ongoing mission to save the universe even beyond his own demise.

Supernatural’s Season 5 Finale Was The Perfect Ending For The Show

“Swan Song” Remains Supernatural’s Highest-Rated Episode On IMDb

I’m grateful that shows like “The French Mistake” from season 6 and “Baby” from season 11, among others, led to Supernatural extending its run beyond season 5. However, I believe that if the series had ended with “Swan Song,” it would have been a fitting finale for Supernatural. At the end of this episode, Sam and Dean were portrayed as heroes, having saved the world and thwarted the apocalypse. They bravely confronted some of the most powerful entities in the universe, choosing not to be manipulated, and emerged victorious.

If “Supernatural” had concluded with the events of “Swan Song,” it would have served as a poignant conclusion for the Winchester storyline. It’s both heartbreaking and triumphant, symbolizing humanity’s victory over darkness. Following Sam’s selfless demise in “Swan Song,” Dean might have eventually learned to relinquish his brother and discover a life beyond hunting. The episode “Swan Song” is indeed a masterpiece of television and a fulfilling conclusion to the initial phase of “Supernatural.

The Winchesters Is Now A Really Weird Epilogue To Supernatural

Dean’s Appearance In The Winchesters Doesn’t Feel Like A True Ending

The narrative of The Winchesters primarily revolved around Mary, John, and their companions, yet it failed to recapture the magic that made Supernatural so captivating. Dean Winchester’s return in The Winchesters softened the impact of his Supernatural demise, but it seems unusual as a conclusion to the Winchester chronicles. Although envisioning Dean traversing various universes, continuing to rescue people and hunt entities, his presence in The Winchesters didn’t feel like an ending.

In the final episode of “The Winchesters”, Dean disclosed that he was on a quest for a universe where his family could enjoy a happy ending, after encountering the Akrida and their imminent danger to multiple realities. With assistance from Jack (Alexander Calvert) and Bobby (Jim Beaver), Dean saved the day once more, thereby setting up this iteration of his parents for success. However, it’s unclear what Dean did subsequently or how his deviation ties into “Supernatural’s” finale. Fortunately, there’s a possibility for additional “Supernatural”, and I fervently hope that Dean Winchester’s narrative will eventually be continued with another installment or two.

2025-07-04 13:28