‘Agatha All Along’ Review: Kathryn Hahn Works Her Magic in Disney+’s Uneven Marvel Spinoff

‘Agatha All Along’ Review: Kathryn Hahn Works Her Magic in Disney+’s Uneven Marvel Spinoff

As a gamer who’s spent countless hours navigating through the labyrinthine worlds of RPGs, I can’t help but see parallels between my gaming adventures and the journey through Disney+’s Agatha All Along. Just like in those games where you start off thinking you’re exploring a seemingly ordinary village, only to uncover hidden depths and mysteries as you progress, Agatha finds herself trapped in a magical trap that appears normal at first glance but hides a much bigger picture.


At the onset of her spinoff series based on “WandaVision”, Agatha Harkness (Kathryn Hahn) starts to question if the world she’s in is less expansive than it seems. Although it may appear ordinary from one moment to the next, her town resembles a poor imitation of “Mare of Easttown”. However, over time, she has developed a growing suspicion that there might be a larger puzzle at play which she’s yet to comprehend.

Without a doubt, she’s correct. By halfway through the debut performance, it becomes apparent that she has fallen into a magical snare designed to deceive her into thinking she’s free while actually confining her within tight restrictions.

Watching Disney+’s Agatha All Along, one can’t help but feel a sense of familiarity that mirrors the anticipation surrounding new Marvel projects. Standing on its own, this series could potentially offer an enjoyable journey with a charming cast and a playful tone, yet there’s plenty of scope for improvement. However, uneven pacing and constant plot twists make it seem less like a captivating adventure and more as a clever extension of the brand rather than a standalone enchantment.

Much like its predecessor, Agatha All Along hails from the creative mind of Jac Schaeffer, who skillfully weaves in references to popular cultural motifs. However, the initial mystery-like setup is somewhat misleading. Instead, this new tale draws heavily on the rich legacy of TV and cinematic witches, with an odyssey reminiscent of the Yellow Brick Road. After losing her powers during the finale of WandaVision, Agatha believes the only solution is to follow a mystical path known as the Witch’s Road. Due to the regulations governing her craft (and the demands of captivating television), this solitary witch is forced to gather a coven, albeit reluctantly.

The main strength of ‘Agatha All Along’ lies in its exceptional cast. Hahn, as Agatha, is captivating with her ability to swiftly transition between serious and mischievous, sarcastic yet genuine. Although Agatha is portrayed as a supervillain, it’s challenging not to be endeared by her character, especially when she nonchalantly remarks about babies being delicious in response to another sorceress criticizing their community for poisoning apples and stealing babies. In the words of Teen from ‘Heartstopper’, her mysterious fanboy-familiar-sidekick, “Name a badder bitch.” This phrase elegantly summarizes Agatha’s charm and impact on the audience.

Hahn has a bubbly chemistry with all her co-actors, but she truly sparkles when acting alongside her archrival Rio, portrayed by Aubrey Plaza as one of Hahn’s signature intriguing and captivating oddball characters. Although it’s difficult to believe too much in the hype surrounding Agatha All Along being the most “gay-themed” Marvel production yet, there is a significant amount of tantalizing sexual tension between them in the initial four episodes that I can only hope will be fully developed in the remaining ones.

Agatha’s doubtful team consists of:

It’s no surprise that with such a star-studded cast, it’s delightful just being around them. The fact that they all seem to intensely dislike Agatha, for reasons that appear valid, only makes it more entertaining. Watching episode after episode of these characters taking jabs at each other while reluctantly setting aside their disagreements to conquer the supernatural challenge of the week is a spectacle I wouldn’t mind witnessing. Essentially, this show can be described as such. Although The Witch’s Road appears as a dimly lit, lifeless CGI forest path, its essence lies in a series of tests, each designed specifically for a particular witch and their unique style.

In one scenario, the characters find themselves in a high-end beach house, adorned with understated neutral outfits as they work to counteract the mind-bending effects of an unusual toxin. In another, they’re transported to a glamorous ’70s rock star mansion filled with musical instruments and flashy attire, where they’re compelled by supernatural forces to perform a jam session. The reasoning behind each setting isn’t always apparent, but it provides plenty of opportunity for the costume and set design teams (headed by Daniel Selon and John Collins) to showcase their talent.

The narrative in this production can be either engaging or underwhelming. Compared to other spin-offs within the franchise, Agatha All Along thankfully doesn’t delve deeply into intricate lore, hidden references, or the complexities of the “multiverse.” There are no such elements – it might be interesting if they touched upon the mystery surrounding Teen’s identity (possibly hinting at his future role in the Young Avengers). However, it often seems that this question overshadows the more immediate issues about who he is as a character and his significance to Agatha. Fortunately, the production largely steers clear of feeling like one of those Marvel stories that are primarily designed to pave the way for other tales.

Regrettably, the series falls short of having a unique identity and seeming essential. The issues aren’t necessarily due to Marvel but rather because it appears as though it hasn’t found its purpose beyond capitalizing on established franchises. Despite having promise, the character-focused comedy-drama it could evolve into seems limited by the rush to progress the plot and the understanding that Agatha is the primary focus.

Instead of diving deep into the characters’ pasts and carefully constructing a rich tapestry of lore, the scripts in this show tend to speed through these elements, often glossing over them. Rather than focusing on intricate world-building, they prefer dramatic scenes and flashy moments. When it comes to music, however, this series certainly knows how to deliver; Robert Lopez and Kristen Anderson-Lopez have crafted a catchy tune for the portal-opening sequence that has become quite memorable. Unfortunately, despite these musical highlights, Agatha All Along seems to lack the necessary patience and interest to fully develop its story and make it truly captivating.

Read More

2024-09-19 04:28