‘Based on a True Story’ Season 2 Review | Frantic but Familiar Fun

'Based on a True Story' Season 2 Review | Frantic but Familiar Fun

As a long-time fan of dark comedies, I can confidently say that Season 2 of “Based on a True Story” is a rollercoaster ride worth taking! With its unique blend of humor, suspense, and unexpected twists, this show never fails to keep you on the edge of your seat.


Greetings! Let’s have a chat, and I need to express milk from my breasts during our conversation! This is the situation with Ava (Kaley Cuoco), a new mother and potential crime solver, in Season 2 of Peacock’s humorous yet tense comedy-thriller titled Based on a True Story. If you found the outrageous antics of this quirky whodunit comedy in Season 1 appealing – somewhat similar to Only Murders in the Building – then you’ll likely be keen on this installment as well. Indeed, it remains entertaining, bold, and slightly crazy, but it’s undeniable that it’s also stretching itself thin and could be pushing its creative limits beyond what another season might sustainably handle.

In this show, we meet Ava and Nathan Bartlett, portrayed by Chris Messina, after they’ve been parents for three months. The main themes running throughout the season are addiction, fixation, and hallucination. Ava is seen yearning to lose herself in another instance of solving true crimes, while her real estate business requires attention. On the other hand, Nathan, a tennis pro, struggles with his desire to be accepted and adored by others. Lastly, there’s Tory, played by Liana Liberato from Scream VI, who is willing to risk her own safety to have a sense of control over her life instead of feeling controlled by her elder sister, Ava.

To start things off, a major unexpected turn of events: Tory and Matt (known for his role in Cold Pursuit) have not only been romantically involved, but it appears their relationship is long-term. This new development will undeniably impact Ava and Nathan’s lives in ways that will take you by surprise. This fresh dynamic sets the stage for plenty of humor, given that Matt was the infamous plumber/serial killer known as The Westside Ripper during Season 1. He then teamed up with Ava and Nathan to create a podcast together. In Season 2, the tension escalates as there’s a baby on the way, and the chaos continues as Ava and Nathan assist Matt in quitting his violent habits, all while another potential serial killer seems to be active. However, this is just speculation for now.

More Blood, More Twists, More Freak-Outs

In the film “Based on a True Story“, the writers initially hint at Tory and Matt’s involvement earlier, and later reintroduce them into Ava and Nathan’s world. When fresh murders catch Ava’s attention, her curiosity is piqued. Could it be Matt? This time, he seems to cast a larger shadow over their lives, and the bonds of loyalty are strained.

Initially, Matt exudes a strong, attractive demeanor that leaves Nathan charmed. His bold self-assurance is hard to resist, leading them to share some amusing moments. This dynamic unfolds as Nathan coaches a young tennis player, whose persistent and demanding mother irritates Matt so much he wishes he could confront her, but instead, he’s trying to control his anger and follow the principles of his 12-step program, such as changing the things that are within his power (which doesn’t include murder).

Kaley Cuoco Keeps It at 11 (For Better or Worse)

'Based on a True Story' Season 2 Review | Frantic but Familiar Fun'Based on a True Story' Season 2 Review | Frantic but Familiar Fun'Based on a True Story' Season 2 Review | Frantic but Familiar Fun

Initially, the first three episodes of the season show Ava, skillfully portrayed by Kaley Cuoco, experiencing high levels of stress. This could be due to sheer panic or her determined search for clues to unravel a fresh series of murders. The audience can anticipate an early significant disclosure concerning past killings. It’s enjoyable to watch the usually energetic Ava navigate one obstacle after another, until it becomes overwhelming.

Perhaps Kaley Cuoco should consider moving away from these types of characters, as Ava shares many traits with Cassandra from The Flight Attendant. Just like that series, her current one seems to follow a similar structure. While there’s enjoyment in watching Cuoco play these anxious roles, it can become tiresome when they’re constantly at high intensity. It’s possible that we’re allowed to behave similarly, but maybe we shouldn’t analyze it too deeply.

Additionally, you might encounter some imaginative detours involving Ava and Nathan’s thoughts, as they ponder over various scenarios of the past and future. While there may be intense moments, this narrative is more about their internal struggles as they strive for a more harmonious life. Perhaps, it would be best to steer clear of themes like serial killers, but let’s focus on their journey instead.

The Predictable Story Beats of Modern Dark Comedies

'Based on a True Story' Season 2 Review | Frantic but Familiar Fun'Based on a True Story' Season 2 Review | Frantic but Familiar Fun'Based on a True Story' Season 2 Review | Frantic but Familiar Fun'Based on a True Story' Season 2 Review | Frantic but Familiar Fun'Based on a True Story' Season 2 Review | Frantic but Familiar Fun'Based on a True Story' Season 2 Review | Frantic but Familiar Fun

Undeniably, the strong bond between Nathan and Matt promises some exciting twists in this season. Similarly, Ava’s budding friendship with Drew (the charming Melissa Fumero from Brooklyn Nine-Nine) will unfold. At first, it provides Ava a welcome diversion, but there seems to be a possibility that she might open up and reveal her true feelings to another equal. Keep an eye on how this develops. It’s one of several anticipated storylines in Season 2.

In today’s 2020s, viewers are accustomed to specific plot twists in dark comedies like this one. Compared to shows such as Apple TV+’s The Afterparty, Season 2 of Based on a True story performs admirably, but its predictability is notable. However, it’s important to note that the series does contain unexpected elements; you might encounter some surprises along the way, despite the rapid tempo not deviating significantly from the norm.

In the latest development, Annie Weisman, the creator of the series ‘Physical’, has assumed control from Craig Rosenberg as the new showrunner. Although Weisman brings fresh perspectives to the chaotic narrative, certain elements remain constant. Nathan is expected to find his backbone, Tory will defy Ava’s counsel, Matt will exude sex appeal and charisma, with a hint of potential lethal intentions. Whether he actually kills or not remains a bit ambiguous. Graphic violence may surface. Above all, Ava’s reactions will be dramatic.

Messina & Cuoco Still Have Chemistry

In essence, the second season of Based on a True Story brings about some innovative changes, largely due to the new showrunner. These novel twists are likely to lead to further thrilling escapades for Ava and Max in Season 3. It’s speculated that this season might be the last, as narratives tend to have a natural expiration date.

Despite some predictable tropes and intense moments, the duo’s captivating chemistry and Messina’s versatile performances make “Based on a True Story” an entertaining watch. Stream the second season starting November 21st on Peacock!

Read More

Sorry. No data so far.

2024-11-19 21:31