Batman: Caped Crusader’s Penguin Shows the Value in Deviating From Canon

Batman: Caped Crusader's Penguin Shows the Value in Deviating From Canon

Quick Links

  • How Has Penguin Changed?
  • What Does This Change Mean for the Canon?
  • Iconic Penguin Portrayals in the Batman Universe

As a long-time admirer of the Batman universe, I must say that the recent portrayal of Penguin in “Batman: Caped Crusaders” has truly captured my heart. Having watched countless iterations of this iconic villain over the years, it is refreshing to see such a fresh take on the character.


Debuting in 1941, the character known as Penguin has persisted through numerous decades in both books and films, solidifying his status as one of Batman’s toughest adversaries. Known for his unique blend of underworld influence and a certain level of sophistication, he’s managed to connect with some of the most influential figures in Gotham City. His reputation has grown even further following the debut of “Batman: Caped Crusader”.

In the criminal underworld, the Penguin has cultivated a sophisticated and dapper persona. He is often seen in a tailored suit, with a monocle and top hat, although his appearance may vary slightly depending on the medium and its tone or style. Some comics might present him as more flamboyant, while Danny DeVito’s film portrayal in 1992 was decidedly grittier.

Debuting on Amazon Prime in early August, “Batman: Caped Crusader” introduces an intriguing twist to the Penguin’s persona. While the character has been male since his inception, this animated series transforms Oswald Cobblepot into Oswalda. Apart from her gender, the character remains faithful to its original portrayal. This alteration underscores the importance of diverging from established material, as it breathes new life and dimension into the character with a seemingly minor adjustment.

How Has Penguin Changed?

Batman: Caped Crusader's Penguin Shows the Value in Deviating From Canon

Indeed, the primary modification involves switching the character’s gender, which seems incredibly suitable. Notably, this alteration has proven quite effective, as the revised portrayal has garnered rave reviews and contributed significantly to the show earning a flawless rating on Rotten Tomatoes.

As a devoted fan, I can’t help but appreciate how the writers masterfully utilized Oswalda’s unique role as a mother in this series. By making Penguin a mom, they added an extra layer of surprise when her violent actions toward her own children unfolded. In the show’s very first episode, Penguin’s son, Aaron, unwittingly exposed one of her targets to her explosion traps. In response, she cleverly exploited her maternal charm to trick him into a false sense of safety, only to imprison him in a box and send him plummeting to the ocean floor.

As a gamer, I appreciate that the Penguin series doesn’t heavily emphasize its gender aspects. It feels like they’re crafting this new Penguin based on more than just her gender, making for a well-rounded character. The portrayal of Oswalda closely mirrors the original, both in appearance and behavior. And let’s not forget about her iconic umbrella, which proved crucial in her ultimate victory against Bruce in the final battle.

What Does This Change Mean for the Canon?

Batman: Caped Crusader's Penguin Shows the Value in Deviating From Canon

From a fan’s perspective, it’s not like the character of Penguin has undergone a significant transformation compared to other alterations seen in Batman tales. What sets Penguin apart is that he maintains his sanity amidst the chaos, which shifts the power dynamic between him and Batman. This sanity allows us, as viewers, to perceive his malevolent actions as truly wicked. For instance, when Oswalda cold-bloodedly kills her own son for merely alerting someone of an impending attack, we understand that this heinous act was entirely her decision.

The actress who played the Penguin in Batman: Caped Crusader shares her thoughts on the character’s transformation. In an interview with GamesRadar+, she explained how she viewed the Penguin as less human and more like a creature, focusing on its animalistic traits rather than its human qualities. Consequently, she suggested that making Penguin female was primarily a stylistic choice.

As a long-time comic book enthusiast, I must say that I was truly impressed by the innovative revamp of the classic character, Penguin, in the show “Batman: Caped Crusaders.” Being immersed in the world of comics for most of my life, I’ve witnessed the evolution and sometimes stagnation of beloved characters over time. The challenge of keeping these characters fresh and interesting becomes increasingly difficult as their history spans decades.

So, it seems more fitting to wonder, why did it take so much time to reimagine the Penguins’ characters in this manner?

Iconic Penguin Portrayals in the Batman Universe

Batman: Caped Crusader's Penguin Shows the Value in Deviating From CanonBatman: Caped Crusader's Penguin Shows the Value in Deviating From CanonBatman: Caped Crusader's Penguin Shows the Value in Deviating From Canon

Since first making an appearance, Penguin has been a beloved character with numerous memorable showings. Many fans often reminisce about his on-screen appearances from the 1960s, especially those featuring Burgess Meredith. With his distinctive purple hat, hooked nose, and pipe that he smoked in camp style, his image left a lasting impact on the Penguin franchise, inspiring generations of Penguins to follow.

In the 2014 TV show “Gotham,” Robin Lord Taylor delivers a contemporary masterpiece in acting. Drawing from both Meredith and DeVito’s interpretations, viewers are treated to a detailed journey as they witness his transformation from a sly, ambitious low-level crook into a relentless gangster. Furthermore, the show provides a platform for exploring the complexities of Cobblepot’s sexual identity, a feature that resonates strongly with many fans, thereby elevating this portrayal to an even more memorable status.

As a gamer, I can’t help but appreciate the diverse portrayals of Danny DeVito’s Penguin character. The one from the DC Animated Universe stands out for me because he’s usually quite rude, but when his affection is betrayed, there’s a heartfelt side to him that makes this Penguin surprisingly sympathetic. This contrasts heavily with Tim Burton’s Batman Returns version from 1992. Now, fast forward to 2022, and Colin Farrell’s interpretation seems like a complete reversal of DeVito’s. Instead of hiding in sewers and being more psychotic in his methods, Farrell’s Penguin takes a hands-on approach, making him an intriguing character to follow.

Minnie Driver’s performance in Batman: Caped Crusaders is poised to become as iconic as the Penguins, given her portrayal of a cabaret singer and mobster who sails on a yacht with an oversized top hat and an umbrella on deck. The character is simply fantastic, leaving viewers eagerly anticipating more of her appearances in future seasons. Watch it now on Prime Video.

Read More

2024-08-04 01:36