Beneath the Violence ‘Deadwood’ Is Really About Empathy

by

As a seasoned viewer who’s spent more time than I care to admit watching the dusty plains of the West unfold on screen, I must say that ‘Deadwood’ stands out as a true gem among the gold rush of western TV shows. This isn’t your typical cowboy tale filled with heroic sheriffs and dastardly villains – no, this is the real West, where life was hard, survival was key, and empathy was as valuable as gold.

20 years back, in the year we’re currently in, the TV series “Deadwood” made its debut on HBO on March 21st, 2004. Created by David Milch, a former collaborator from “NYPD Blue”, the show was met with almost unanimous praise and is often discussed among the best television series ever produced. The story unfolds in the 1870s in the gold rush town of Deadwood, which eventually became part of South Dakota. It portrays life on the frontier as tough and filled with danger, where ambitious individuals could strike it rich, so long as they were willing to bend their morals to whatever actions were required.

Beneath its vivid vulgarity and unrelenting brutality, a more compassionate pulse can be found at the heart of Deadwood. Amidst the constant struggles for power and riches, some of the series’ most poignant scenes emerged from observing this diverse ensemble of characters looking out for each other, finding solace in their shared experiences as they collaborated to construct a society. The West is commonly perceived as a lawless region, but in Deadwood’s portrayal, it was also a place where kindness and humanity could flourish.

‘Deadwood’ Is Driven by Its Characters

In Deadwood, a TV series renowned for its exceptional cast, Ian McShane delivers an unforgettable performance as Al Swearingen, a ruthless saloon owner and pimp who effectively rules the town. Any dealings within the town require his approval, and he’s prepared to use violence through his henchmen to safeguard his interests. His dominance is tested by the arrival of Seth Bullock (Timothy Olyphant), a former marshal seeking peace away from his law enforcement career. He initially establishes a business with partner Sol Starr (John Hawkes) before being drawn into the role of sheriff. The struggle between Bullock’s efforts to establish law and order in the once-lawless town becomes the main thread throughout Deadwood’s early episodes.

Amidst all the commotion, every resident of Deadwood carries their personal, entangled narratives, and it’s through these stories that the series demonstrates a community thrives when individuals are prepared to look after each other. When Calamity Jane (Robin Weigert), a scout and confidante of Wild Bill Hickok, is devastated by his death at the close of season one, she discovers renewed meaning and happiness in assisting with the well-being of the town’s expanding group of school-aged kids.

In Deadwood, Sol successfully penetrates Trixie’s (Paula Malcolmson) protective barriers, revealing the genuine person beneath and treating her with respect that very few men had previously offered her. During Season 2, as the Bullocks suffer a tragic loss, the entire town momentarily halts their individual machinations to express condolences. These instances show how the characters in Deadwood unite, providing support and resilience for one another.

‘Deadwood’ and the End of the West

As a devoted fan, I’d say that Deadwood symbolizes the twilight of the legendary Wild West, as it’s often depicted in our collective consciousness – an unruly land where rules were more like guidelines and chaos could break out without warning. In Season 3, Deadwood is on the brink of joining the Dakota Territory, falling under the jurisdiction of greater forces that essentially mark the end of its independent rule as a self-governed town. This period signifies the wane of unrestrained autonomy giving way to a more structured civilization, yet it doesn’t mean that selfishness and malice vanish; instead, they evolve into something that seems more legitimate.

This is most evident in the arrival of George Hearst (Gerald McRaney), a wealthy businessman who comes to Deadwood seeking further riches. He’s just as willing to use violence and intimidation as Al, but without the connection to the town and its people that would occasionally temper Al’s machinations. He also knows how to use the established system for his own ends, manipulating elections and employing the Pinkertons to cause trouble for the townsfolk. Hearst represents a new version of the same selfish impulses that ruled the West, one that hides its monstrous actions behind a mask of progress.

The situation deepens the bonds among Deadwood’s residents, as they unite against an external force trying to seize what they have created. In the 2019 film sequel, Deadwood: The Movie, set in 1889 when South Dakota becomes a US state, Hearst, now a senator, comes back to Deadwood with plans to acquire land that disrupts his new telecommunications venture. However, his corrupt tendencies remain unchanged, and he tries to exert control over the town once more. As before, the residents rally together to protect their community from Hearst’s power grab, ultimately managing to push him out, at least for now.

Time after time, the characters in Deadwood demonstrated their unwavering commitment to each other, showing that a community thrives or falls based on the bonds among its members. While self-interest and ambition can offer temporary success, for a community to persist, the interests of the individual must align with the welfare of the group as a whole. Behind the show’s exceptional acting and unique dialogue lies a core theme of compassion, concern, and understanding, which gives it a lasting appeal, elevating it not only as an outstanding western series but also as one of the finest television productions ever created.

Read More

2024-12-08 23:33