Best Detective Series Based on True Stories

As a true crime enthusiast with over two decades of immersion in grisly tales and unsolved mysteries, I must say that this list is a veritable treasure trove for anyone who shares my macabre fascination. From the chilling Mindhunter to the shocking The Pembrokeshire Murders, each series presents a unique perspective on the darker side of humanity, offering a glimpse into the minds of those who perpetrate heinous acts.

Life itself can sometimes present an unrivaled enigma compared to any fictional mystery. Although well-crafted detective series are captivating, it’s the ones inspired by true events that leave viewers genuinely astounded. True crime has found a strong following in podcasts and documentaries, yet over the years, numerous productions have skillfully employed genuine stories and exceptional acting prowess to narrate the astonishing tales that unfold.

Currently, you’ve got a wealth of true-crime documentaries at your fingertips, thanks to streaming services. Netflix, in particular, has played a significant role in escalating the genre’s popularity. From tales of police corruption and notorious serial killers to exhilarating investigations, this list is brimming with captivating stories. Join me as we discover the next enthralling detective series inspired by real-life events, destined to top your must-watch list.

10 ‘Unbelievable’ (2019)

The series, titled “Unbelievable”, is inspired by a Pulitzer Prize-winning article from 2015 published by The Marshall Project. It revolves around the story of a young woman who was sexually assaulted and initially suspected of lying about the incident. Detectives Grace Rasmussen (played by Toni Collette) and Karen Duvall (portrayed by Merritt Wever) meticulously investigate similar cases that occurred in the Colorado region, eventually uncovering connections to Marie Adler’s (Kaitlyn Dever) initial case.

A Troubling Case

After the events of the case, Adler’s life is significantly disrupted, leading to complications with her employment, housing, and mental health. This true story highlights instances of unjust policing and how innocent individuals can be coerced into admitting to crimes they didn’t commit. Despite its challenging themes, the series manages to maintain a positive trajectory as the investigation delves deeper, ultimately revealing the truth. The series serves as a testament to Dever’s exceptional acting abilities and ranks among her most memorable performances.

9 ‘Under the Banner of Heaven’ (2022)

As I settle into my seat, I find myself immersed in the gripping storyline of “Under the Banner of Heaven,” where Andrew Garfield masterfully portrays detective Jeb Pyre. This captivating series, inspired by Jon Krakauer’s book, delves into the chilling real-life events surrounding Ron and Dan Lafferty, who tragically murdered their sister-in-law back in 1984.

A Mysterious Murder

In the tightly-knit Mormon community, Pyre, a fellow member, encounters strong criticism as he investigates potential suspects within a prominent family. The show garnered widespread acclaim due to its acting talent, with Garfield being particularly praised and earning an Emmy nomination. To discover where each performance stands for the series, explore this detailed ranking list.

8 ‘Des’ (2020)

This three-part British series centers around Dennis Nilsen, a notorious serial killer portrayed by David Tennant, who was eventually apprehended following the discovery of human remains in a drain close to his residence. The gripping true crime drama delivers an eerie depiction of Tennant’s character as he embodies the terrifying role of the murderer. Tennant’s exceptional portrayal landed him the International Emmy for Best Actor, and the series was also nominated for the Best TV Movie/Miniseries award. This performance is one reason David Tennant has become a favorite among streaming audiences.

Dangerously Dark Dramas

The ITV series examined the true crime story with a dark and unflinching eye as detectives interviewed Nilsen. The series follows the investigation to the trial where Nilsen is tried for the killings of multiple men. The miniseries has only three episodes which makes it the perfect show to catch up with immediately.

7 ‘Under the Bridge’ (2024)

1997 saw a 16-year-old girl from British Columbia attending a party and failing to return home. Screenwriter, Godfrey (played by Riley Keough), journeys back to her hometown to pen a book about the troubled youth in the region, only to find herself embroiled in something she was unprepared for. The missing girl, Reena Virk (portrayed by Vritika Gupta), suffered a brutal attack at the hands of her peers before her body was discovered beneath a bridge.

Based on a Popular Novel (And True Story)

6 ‘I Am the Night’ (2019)

In 1960s Los Angeles, and centered around the Black Dahlia murder mystery, “I Am the Night” was broadcasted in 2019, featuring Chris Pine in the cast. The narrative revolves around Fauna Hodel (played by India Eisley), a woman who uncovers through her family history a possible link to the suspect, none other than her own grandfather. Pine portrays a struggling journalist who delves into investigating Hodel’s grandfather in pursuit of answers concerning the unsolved murder.

The Black Dahlia Murder

The grisly slaying of Elizabeth Short, known also as the Black Dahlia, captivated the nation following her gruesome death in 1947. Tragically, this aspiring actress lost her life at just 22 years old, and to this day, her murder remains unresolved. The television series I Am The Night skillfully employs this unsolved mystery to generate suspense as Hodel finds himself increasingly entwined in the case and its shadowy perpetrator.

5 ‘Manhunt: Unabomber’ (2017)

The Discovery Channel’s show titled “Manhunt” spanned over two seasons, with the first season delving into the story of Ted Kaczynski, the Unabomber. The character of FBI agent Jim Fitzgerald, portrayed by Sam Worthington, is introduced to evaluate and profile Kaczynski, played by Paul Bettany, in a bid to assist in apprehending him. This gripping and psychologically intense series offers an insightful exploration into the minds of criminals and the investigations aimed at capturing them, shedding light on one of history’s most cunning murderers.

Fresh Techniques

Fitzgerald serves on a special task force dedicated to apprehending and bringing down Kaczynski during the ’90s. The show offers a unique perspective by portraying his one-on-one interactions with the notorious suspect, providing viewers with an intimate glimpse into the intricacies of the case and the methods used to finally catch him.

4 ‘Landscapers’ (2021)

In an unexpected twist, seemingly ordinary individuals Susan and Christopher Edwards, who are actually ruthless killers, have been concealing their true identities. These real-life murderers, brilliantly portrayed by the Academy Award-winning actress Olivia Colman and David Thewlis, shine in a captivating dark comedy detective series. The offbeat humor seamlessly complements Colman’s comedic flair, making it one of her finest performances yet.

Surprising Suspects

In a shocking turn of events, it was uncovered more than ten years later that the actual married pair were responsible for Susan’s parents’ disappearance and eventual deaths. As the detectives dissect their tales, viewers will find themselves in fits of laughter. Yet, they will also be taken aback by the realization that these seemingly ordinary individuals were capable of such horrendous acts. This dark comedy is a rare gem on this list, but its mystery is as compelling as any other exceptional true crime story.

3 ‘We Own This City’ (2022)

The series titled “We Own This City” is primarily set in Baltimore and was masterfully crafted by TV visionaries David Simon and George Pelecanos. It delves deeply into the gritty reality of corruption within the local police department. The story largely revolves around character Wayne Jenkins, played by Jon Bernthal, who is a key figure in this corrupt system, and the ensuing legal battle against the police officers.

Police Corruption

Jon Bernthal garnered outstanding praise for his portrayal of Sergeant Wayne Jenkins, with the show earning a remarkable 93% rating on Rotten Tomatoes. Simon masterfully weaves journalistic insights to unfold a complex narrative about corruption, revealing how the very men sworn to protect their community were instrumental in its ruin. The series delves into the investigation leading to the downfall of these officers, making it an immediate must-see for this critically acclaimed miniseries.

2 Mindhunter (2017)

Drawing inspiration from the authentic true-crime book, “Mindhunter: Inside The FBI’s Elite Serial Crime Unit” by John E. Douglas and Mark Olshaker, the series delves into the genuine accounts of serial killers, leveraging the research conducted by the authors. In this gripping drama, Mindhunter features Jonathan Groff in the 1970s era, focusing on the establishment of the Behavioral Science Unit within the FBI. The esteemed director, David Fincher, imparts his meticulous touch to the gritty production that spanned over two captivating seasons.

Real-Life Killers

This television series, particularly appealing to enthusiasts of serial killer narratives, delves into the minds of several murderers throughout its two-season span, aiming to explore the psychological motives behind their heinous acts. During its run, this Netflix production garnered high praise and maintains a dedicated fanbase who eagerly await a potential third season. With two Primetime Emmy nominations under its belt and positive critical acclaim, there’s a strong demand for more episodes of the show.

1 ‘The Pembrokeshire Murders’ (2021)

The Welsh miniseries unfolds around the notorious Welsh serial killer, John Cooper. In the early 2000s, Detective Steve Wilkins, portrayed by Luke Evans, resurrects two cold cases that ultimately lead him to the murderer. Leveraging innovative DNA technology unavailable earlier, Wilkins manages to trace and apprehend the killer in this suspenseful miniseries.

New Tech

As a movie buff putting myself in Wilkins’ shoes, I can’t help but feel the weight of responsibility on my shoulders and my team’s as we race against time to uncover undeniable proof before our suspect walks out of prison. This chase leads us down countless paths of interviews and research, each one crucial in validating our suspicions and ensuring this ruthless killer stays behind bars. Leveraging cutting-edge technology becomes our ultimate weapon, guiding us through the labyrinth of clues until we finally crack this heinous case wide open.

2024-12-09 02:33